This section is from the book "Vital Factors Of Foods - Vitamins And Nutrition", by Carleton Ellis, Annie Louise Macleod. Also available from Amazon: Vital Factors Of Foods: Vitamins And Nutrition.
A study of the dietary properties of tubers, as represented by the potato, showed27 that dietary props of potato closely resemble those of cereal grains. The first limiting factor for growth is a relative shortage of calcium, sodium and chlorine, as has been found to be the case with seeds thus far examined. The content of A is too low for promotion of nutrition at optimum, and the biological value of nitrogen yielded seems to be of about the same order as that of cereal grains. The results on the value of the potato nitrogen for growth place it in a very different light from those reported by other investigators who have observed its value for maintenance of nitrogen equilibrium in the adult, all ascribing to potato nitrogen a biological value considerably greater than that found by McCollum and his associates for any of the protein mixtures contained in the more important seeds employed as human foodstuffs.28
23 McCollum, Simmonds and Pitz, J. Biol. Cham. 90, 14.
24 McCollum and Simmonds, Ibid. 33, 303.
25 McCollum, Simmonds and Pitz, J. Biol. Chem. 30, 13.
26 McCollum, "Newer Knowledge of Nutrition," 1919, p. 43.
27 McCollum, Simmonds and Parsons, J. Biol. Chem. 36, 197.
Cooked dried potato can be supplemented by the addition of purified protein, sodium chloride, calcium carbonate, and a fat containing A, so as to be satisfactory support of growth at about normal rate, and to induce reproduction and rearing of the young. The mortality of the young was high and the fertility of adults decidedly below normal. Young from these rats have grown at the normal rate for about three months after weaning, when confined to the diet to which their parents have been confined throughout life, and one gave birth to three young.
The beet appears to resemble the potato in general nutritive character. Referring to this McCollum29 says:
"The fleshy roots of the potato and the sweet potato have an inorganic content which resembles that of the seed in a general way, so that an inspection of the analytical data relating to the composition of the ash of the seeds, tubers, and roots, gave no promise that the combination in diets of seeds with either of the latter ctosscs of foodstuffs would correct the inorganic deficiencies of the former. Feeding experiments in which a seed and a tuber were combined, and so supplemented with purified protein, and fat-soluble A (in butter fat), that all the deficiencies of the mixture, except the inorganic, were made good, have shown that in the combinations of each of the more important seeds with the potato, the resulting mineral supply, which is derived solely from the natural foods themselves, is not of a character suitable for the support of growth. The content of the elements, calcium, sodium and chlorine, must be augmented by greater amounts before such food mixtures are complete with respect to their mineral content.
No studies have as yet been made to determine the biological value of the nitrogen of the tubers other than the potato, and none at all of the edible roots.
"From the results of systematic feeding trials with mixtures of seeds alone and the same with single and multiple purified food additions, and the same type of experiment using certain of the tubers and root foods in place of the seeds, it is shown that all these classes of foodstuffs resemble one another in all respects except in the high content of water in the tubers and roots. In the dry state, they are all much like the seeds, but there is one minor difference which should be mentioned. The most important difference lies in the character of the nitrogen compounds. In the seeds the nitrogen is almost all contained in the form of true protein. In the tubers and edible roots most of it is in the form of much simpler compounds, a part being the same amino-acids which are derived from proteins on digestion".
28 Hindhede, Ugesk. Laeger, 79, Nos. 13, 14, 15, 1917; J. Am. Med. Asso. 68, 1880, 1917; Thomas, Arch. Physiol. 1909, 219; Rose and Cooper, J. Biol. Ghem. 30, 201.
29 "Newer Knowledge of Nutrition," 1919, p. 48.
Running parallel with McCollum's experiments in biological analysis is an equally interesting and valuable series of papers by Osborne and Mendel, besides various communications from other authors.
Osborne and Mendel 30 demonstrated that the proteins are not all equally adequate in nutrition, but that their biological efficiency depends on the amino acids present. They showed that a supply of tryptophane in the food is necessary in order to maintain an animal without loss, and that in addition lysine must be present to secure growth. The rate of growth appears to be limited by the proportions of these amino acids furnished.31
Proteins from one source which contain an insufficient supply of the essential amino acids may be supplemented by combining with proteins from other sources which have a surplus of those acids which the first lacks. Thus the lactalbumin of milk supplements the inadequate protein of corn most satisfactorily,32 while gelatin is a better supplement for oat protein.33
Studying the comparative nutritive value of different proteins for growth by feeding exactly equivalent amounts of energy in the form of foods with unlike proportions of the individual proteins, and observing the minima for growth and the limits of intake for maintenance as shown by failure to make proper gains or to maintain weight, Osborne and Mendel conclude that the economy of the different proteins as nutriments in growth appears to be closely bound up with the constitution of their amino acids. Normal growth is attained on a diet containing twelve per cent of casein, but the addition of isolated cystine to a diet containing only nine per cent of casein renders it equally efficient, indicating that the proportion of this acid in casein is below the optimum for growth. Lactalbumin appears to be the most efficient of all proteins for growth.34 Rats could be maintained without loss of weight with a smaller intake of this than of any other protein studied,35 maintenance being frequently secured with as little as five per cent of lactalbumin in the diet as the sole source of protein.
When corn or corn meal formed the chief constituent of the diet of white rats it was found necessary to supplement this with a protein concentrate rich in tryptophane and lysine in order to secure the best results.36
30 Osborne and Mendel, Carnegie Publication 156, 1911, J. Biol. Chem. 12, 473, 13, 233.
31 J. Biol. Chem. 17, 326; 25, 1.
32 J. Biol. Chem. 18, 1; 26, 293; 29, 69; 44, 1. 33 J. Biol. Chem. 34, 621. 34 J. Biol. Chem. 20, 121.
 
Continue to: