This section is from the book "Vital Factors Of Foods - Vitamins And Nutrition", by Carleton Ellis, Annie Louise Macleod. Also available from Amazon: Vital Factors Of Foods: Vitamins And Nutrition.
An attempt to determine the relative values of the proteins in the various cereal grains proved difficult. The general conclusion was drawn that the total proteins of rice and barley, in contrast to those of corn and oats, when furnished in diets containing 16 to 17 per cent of protein, supply enough of all the amino acids essential for growth.
Later37 there seemed to be some indication that oats can actually furnish all the essential nitrogenous units if the intake of food and its concentration of protein are adequate, but as a rule, rats failed to eat the oat foods very heavily. The value of rye proteins is questionable, and wheat appears to be unsatisfactory as an exclusive source of protein,38 since, although the first generation could be raised to full adult size on a diet containing ten per cent of protein from wheat, the second generation on this food failed to grow with normal vigor.39 It appears that the proteins of the wheat endosperm are adequate for maintaining adults, but that they are inadequate for growth.40 Additions of meat, milk, or eggs to wheat flour so greatly enhance the value of the protein for growth that a great economy in consumption of protein results.41
A method of expressing the growth-promoting value of proteins numerically was worked out by Osborne, Mendel and Perry42 who found that the maximum efficiency of the different proteins or of mixtures of them can be expressed with considerable accuracy in terms of gain of body weight per gram of protein eaten, provided the rate of growth is fairly rapid. With a diet containing 7.9 per cent of lactalbumin the maximum gain of weight per gram of protein eaten was three grams, which is approximately the mnYimiim growth-promoting capacity of lactalbumin. On a similar diet with casein as a sole source of protein the greatest gain per gram of protein was 2.25 grams when the diet contained 12 per cent of casein.
35 J. Biol. Chem. 22, 241; 26, 1. 36 Proc. Am. Physiol. Soc., Am. J. Physiol. 40, 147. 37 J. Biol. Chem. 41, 275.
38 Osborne and Mendel, 1. c; McCollum, Simmonds and Parsons, J. Biol. Chem. 37, 156.
39 J. Biol. Chem. 37, 557.
40 J. Biol. Chem. 41, 290.
41 J. Biol. Chem. 34, 521.
42 Oaborae, Mendel and Ferry, J. Biol. Chem. 37, 223.
For further reference to factors other than vitamins in the diet see also:
McCollum (Am. J. Physiol. 1911, 29, 215). The nature of the repair processes in protein metabolism. McCollum and Davis (Ibid. 1915, 20, 415). The influence of protein intake on growth. Rohmann (Bioch. Zeitschr. 1912, 39, 507). Artificial nutrition. Abderhalden (Zeitschr. physiol. Chem. 1912, 77, 22). Feeding investigations with completely digested nutrients. (Ibid. 1913, 83, 444). Synthetic powers of the organism of the dog. {Ibid. 1915, 96, 1). Nitrogenous metabolism. Totani (Bioch. J. 1916, 10, 382). Feeding experiments with a dietary in which tyrosine is reduced to a minimum. Mitchell (J. Biol. Chem. 1916, 26, 231). Feeding experiments on the substitution of protein by definite mixtures of isolated amino acids. Ackrpyd and Hopkins (Bioch. J. 1916, 10, 551). Feeding experiments with deficiencies in the amino acid supply. Hopkins (J. Chem. Soc. 1916, 629). Newer standpoints in the study of nutrition. Buckner, Nollau, and Kastle (Am. J. Phyaiol. 1915, 39, 162). Feeding young chicks on grain mixtures of high and low lysine content. Hogan (J. Biol. Chem. 1916, 27, 193). Nutritive properties of maise. Ibid. (1917, 20, 485). Maise as a source of protein and ash for growing animals. Sherman, Wheeler, and Yatet (Ibid. 1918, 34, 383). Experiments on the nutritive value of maise protein.
Sherman and Winters (Ibid 1918, 35, 301). Efficiency of maize protein in adult human nutrition. Hart, Halpin and Steenbock (Ibid. 1917, 31, 415). Behavior of chicks restricted to wheat or maize kernel. Morgan and Beger (Zeitsoh. physiol. Chem. 1915, 94, 324). Injurious effect of an exclusive oat diet attributable to an acid intoxication. Sherman, Winters and Phillips (J. Biol. Chem. 1919, 39, 53). Efficiency of oat protein in adult human nutrition. Steenbock, Kent and Gross (Ibid. 1918, 35, 61). Dietary qualities of barley. Hart and Steenbock (Ibid. 1919, 39, 209). Maintenance and reproduction on grains and grain products as the sole dietary. Daniels and Longhlin (Ibid. 1918, 33, 295). Feeding experiments with peanuts. Johns and Finks (Ibid. 1920, 42, 569). Nutritive value of peanut flour as a supplement to wheat flour. Richardson and Green (Ibid. 1916, 25, 307; 1917, 30, 243; 31, 379). Nutrition investigations on cottonseed meal. Wells and Bwing (Ibid. 1916, 27, 15). Cottonseed meal as an incomplete food. Daniels and Nichols (Ibid. 1917, 32, 91). Nutritive value of the soy bean. Osborne and Mendel (Ibid* 1917, 32, 369). Use of the soy bean as food. Rose and Cooper (Ibid. 1917, 30, 201). The biological efficiency of potato nitrogen.
Daniels and Rich (Ibid. 36, 27, 1918). The role of inorganic sulphates in nutrition. Plimmer (J. S. C. I., 40, 227R, 1921). The relative value of the proteins in nutrition. Physiology of Protein Metabolism, Oathcart, London, 1921.
While the basal diets used in vitamin studies vary with every in-vestigator, almost with each investigation, certain general principles are followed. The protein of the basal ration is very commonly furnished by casein (or caseinogen, see p. 263), and the carbohydrate by either dextrin or starch, the lactose used in the early experiments having been found difficult to purify. Drummond 43 recommends the use of rice starch, which, in the crude state, is almost entirely devoid of vitamin and may therefore be employed without any lengthy extraction. In order to remove any possible traces of vitamin from the casein Punk 44 resorted to extraction with hot alcohol. This method was ob-jected to by McCollum and Davis on the ground that the high temperature might affect the casein unfavorably.45 Since experiments had shown that casein suffers deterioration on prolonged heating McCollum and Davis thought it unwise finally to extract this material for a long period with boiling alcohol, as Punk and McCollum 46 had done in order to remove all traces of unknown accessory substances.
Through this treatment the value of the casein may be decidedly reduced.
 
Continue to: