In order to ascertain the biological value of mixtures of cereal and legume seeds, McCollum and Simmonds18 experimented with mixtures of maize and beans as a diet for rats. The mixture, as was to be expected, proved deficient in mineral content and A and in protein, The protein in what was apparently the optimum mixture of 80 per cent maize and 20 per cent beans had just about one-half the biological value for growth that the total protein mixture in milk possesses.

A further study of the values of some seed proteins for maintenance was made by McCollum and Simmonds.19 Since it has been repeatedly shown that seeds in general are lacking in three dietary factors, mineral content, A vitamin, and protein, it follows that if a particular seed is fed supplemented with both salts and butter-fat, the limiting factor is the quality of the protein. In order to determine the relative value of the total protein the following method was employed:

(a) The seed supplemented with the necessary salt and butter fat is fed alone; (b) a pure carbohydrate is added to produce a low protein mixture; (c) the supplemented seed is fed with a protein preparation from the same seed so as to raise the plane of protein intake to higher levels. The results show the relative value of the total protein of the seed as compared with that of other seeds. It was found that with rats six per cent of wheat or maize proteins just suffice to maintain the animals in body weight, while four per cent of oat proteins maintained them in distinctly better condition as judged by their appearance than did six per cent of wheat and maize proteins. Flaxseed proteins appear to have a still lower biological value when fed as the sole source of protein. It requires about eight per cent of flaxseed proteins in the food to maintain a full grown rat. Millet seed proteins possess a somewhat higher value for maintenance. Pea and bean proteins possess about the same biological values when fed alone, both being inferior to either wheat or maize. The value of the bean proteins is enhanced by the addition of oat proteins while that of the pea is not.

Contrary to the conclusions of Thomas,20 the proteins of polished rice appear to be of about the same quality as those of wheat and maize.

17a See Sure, J. Biol. Chem. 46, 443, 1021.

18 McCollum and Simmonds, J. Biol. Chem. 32, 29.

19 McCollum and Simmonds, J. Biol. Chem. 32, 347.

When mixtures of seeds are fed there is some improvement in the biological values of the proteins over those derived from a single seed. McCollum and Simmonds21 aver that in certain cases the value of such mixtures doubtless are high, but with simple mixtures of the cereal grains they were not able to demonstrate a high degree of efficiency as a source of protein in any case.

Since young rats are able to grow at approximately half the normal rate on food mixtures in which protein from maize, rye or barley are present to the extent of nine per cent of the food mixture, and which are otherwise entirely adequate, McCollum, Simmonds and Parsons22 carried on a series of experiments in which the food contained nine per cent of protein derived from two seeds, one furnishing two-thirds, and the other one-third of the total protein, together with adequate amounts of the other necessary ingredients, and compared the growth obtained with that produced by an equivalent amount of protein from a single seed. Of the single seeds, wheat gave the best results, rolled oats the poorest, but a ration containing eight per cent of protein from milk powder was far superior to one containing nine per cent of wheat protein. For the most part the proteins from the mixed grains seemed to offer little advantage over those from a single seed for growth, the most striking exception being a mixture of rye and flaxseed in which rye furnished protein equal to six per cent and flaxseed half as much, which, for growth, appeared to be almost if not quite equal to proteins of milk.

A combination in which two-thirds of the protein came from peas and one-third from millet also gave good growth and reproduction, and millet proved to have some supplementary value when combined with rolled oats also.

20 Thomas, Arch. Physiol. 1909, 219.

21 McCollum and Simmonds, J. Biol. Chem. 33, 303.

22 McCollum, Simmonds and Parsons, J. Biol. Chem. 37, 155.

In no case can the necessary mineral content of the diet be satisfactorily supplied from seeds alone.23 Even with mixtures of two to five seeds,24 additional sodium, chlorine, and calcium must be supplied before any growth can be obtained.

The value of the leaf as a supplement to the deficiencies of seed rations was studied by McCollum, Simmonds and Pitz,25 who found that a mixture of sixty per cent seed and forty per cent alfalfa flour gave much more satisfactory growth than can any seed diet unless extensively supplemented. Sixty per cent of rolled oats and forty per cent alfalfa leaf induces nearly normal growth to adult size in the rat. In this connection McCollum26 says:

"The leaf proves to be a very different thing from the seed from the dietary standpoint. The dry leaf usually contains from three to five times as much total ash constituents as does the seed, and is always especially rich in just those elements in which the seed is poorest, via., calcium, sodium, and chlorine. It follows therefore that the leaf supplements the inorganic deficiencies of the seed. The leaf, in most cases, contains much more of the dietary essential, fat-soluble A, than is found in any seed, so that combinations of leaf and seed prove more satisfactory for the nutrition of an animal than do mixtures of seeds alone. The leaf contains protein and amino-acids which result from digestion of proteins as does the seed. The amount varies from eight per cent of protein (nitrogen multiplied by 6.25) in such fleshy leaves as the cabbage, after drying, to more than fifteen per cent in the dry alfalfa or clover leaf. The seeds vary in their content of protein from about ten to twenty-five per cent. The leaf proteins appear, from the data available, to supplement and enhance in some degree the value of the seed proteins with which they are combined.

The leaf supplements, therefore, all the nutritive deficiencies of the seed, but not necessarily in a highly satisfactory manner".