I gave the suggestion to an educated young man (a student) during hypnosis that bo would tap me on the right shoulder with his left hand when he awoke. He resisted the impulse, for he was very obstinate, and would not allow bis freewill to be interfered with at any price. He went home. I told him to come again in a week's time, and when he came he confessed to me that my suggestion had worried him the whole week - so much so that on one or two occasions he was on the point of coming to me (a distance of about three miles) to tap me on the shoulder. Was the whole week, during which the young man was working as usual, listening to lectures, sleeping, and so on, a condition prime ?

An intelligent, very suggestible nurse was so powerfully affected by suggestions as to time that she told me that she was quite overpowered by them, and would be compelled even to commit murder if I were to suggest it to her. The impulse to carry out even the greatest nonsense was fearful. Her repeated energetic attempts to resist only increased the impulse the more violently. Once she was speaking to me about hypnotism before two other persons. She said: " But it is always the same, doctor; I must do everything that you have suggested to me during sleep. Still, although I never know anything about it before, I always notice that it comes from you when it does come. There is always such a peculiar impulse, like something strange." I then said to her: "Go to sleep." She went to sleep at once. I then said to her: "After you have been awake for half a minute, you will get the idea, entirely of your own account, to ask me the following question: 'Doctor, I have been wanting to ask you for a long time how it is that one goes to sleep so rapidly when hypnotized. This is not so in ordinary sleep; one takes much longer to go to sleep. How is it? It is very extraordinary.' You will have no suspicion that I have said this to you during your sleep; the idea will originate entirely of yourself. You will have been wishing to ask me for a long time. past. Count up to sis, and you will awake." She counted to six, awakened, and assured me that she had slept well.1 Then, about half a minute after, she broke out with the suggested sentence, word for word. Her inquiring tone manifested the highest interest in the matter. I listened quietly to her, answered her in detail, and then asked her how she came to ask me this question. "Well, I have been wanting to ask it of you for a long time." "Is it not a suggestion which I have just given you during your sleep?" "Certainly not; I am not to be deceived; this was my own idea." "But you have deceived yourself notwithstanding. Here are two witnesses, who have heard that I have suggested it word for word two minutes ago." The poor hypnotized girl was quite confounded, and had to acknowledge that she could not recognize every suggestion as such, but could only recognize those which were so idiotic that they could not Lave been the efforts of her own brain.

1 She slept exceedingly deeply each time. This was objectively unmistakable.

A very thorough, intelligent young law student, who was close to bis final examination, knew the theory of suggestion well, I was able to put him to sleep deeply, with total amnesia. I once suggested to him that he would go to Dr. D., one of our colleagues here, as soon as he awoke, and ask him his name, where his home is, and also if he has had any experience of hypnotism. This was accomplished, but the student added to this: "I seem to have seen you before. Isn't your name X.?" As the statement as to his home did not coincide, he said that he must have been mistaken, and went away. When he presented himself to me on the following day, I asked him why he had questioned my colleague D. as he had done after his last hypnosis. " I thought that he was an acquaintance, but it appears that it is not so." I asked whether he put those questions of his own accord from his own free will. The student looked at me in astonisluncnt, and said, "Certainly." I asked whether it was not one of my suggestions. "No. At least, I know nothing about it" He then became rather angry, blew his nose, and asked me: "Is it due to suggestion, too, that I have to blow my nose?" (This was not so.) He assured me that he had not had the faintest suspicion that his question to Dr. D, was not due to a natural desire of his own, and was very struck, and at the same time interested, by my explanation.

I could add many more examples, as I have paid special attention to this subject For example, the posthypnotie hallucination of the lady that she could not distinguish two suggested violets from a natural one which I have mentioned in a preceding page belongs to this category. However, what has been said will suffice to show that one can smuggle and intertwine a suggestion into the normal activity of the waking normal mind in such a way that all outside phenomena of a hypnosislike character can be excluded. In these cases the "hypnotized" is completely deceived, believes that he is thinking or acting spontaneously, and does not guess at the insinuating suggestion of the hypnotist

One cannot illustrate Spinoza's statement more strikingly than by detailing these hypnotic experiments. The statement is: "The illusion of the freewill is nothing else than the want of knowledge of the reasons of our resolutions." We have a real visible demonstration that our subjective freewill is objectively produced. The only difference is that it is caused by suggestions of others in the hypnotized, and by feelings, instincts, habits, autosuggestions, etc., besides the plastic self-adapting activity of reason, in the not hypnotized. This means that it is caused in the latter ease by the combinations of engrams of the inherited and individually acquired mneme.

However, an interesting and common intermediate form between actual hypnosis and waking condition consists in the fact that the hypnotized actually has his eyes open, behaves just like a normal person, and does not forget anything; but he shows an unmistakable fixed stare, and accepts unnatural, meaningless suggestions as natural - i.e., he does not wonder at them, and carries them out without questioning them. If one asks him later on, he not infrequently admits that he was a little giddy or dreamy; he was not absolutely wide awake and clear. This would correspond to the veille somnambulique, or condition prime. This is the early stage of contraction of the consciousness, the commencement of the monoidism of hypnosis with report.