When one has frequently observed these phenomena, one realizes quite distinctly that the condition of the mind of the hypnotized persons in the three cases mentioned above must be, and actually is, the same. The mind is awake, but is altered. One asks one's self: In what way is it altered? This question was first put forward by Liegeois,1 and later by Beaunis 2 and Delboeuf. 3 Liegeois calls this condition, in which the hypnotized is wide awake up to the point which has been "forbidden or commanded " by the hypnotist, by the term condition prime. This term is meant to stand as an analogue to condition seconde. The latter was used by Adam for the second condition of consciousness in his case (Felida) of double consciousness in the waking condition. Later on, however, Liegeois also came to the conclusion that the condition prime is only a variety of the condition seconde. Beaunis styles the condition prime as veille somnambulique. Delboeuf, on the other hand, considers that he has proved that in all these cases the hypnotized person has only been hypnotized again, and that one is dealing simply with ordinary somnambulism, only the person has his eyes open. The suggestion is supposed simply to produce a new hypnosis by means of association uncon-ciously. Later on he, however, changed his views, and came to the same conclusion 4 which I have arrived at.

In my opinion, none of these views are tenable, because they are all too dogmatic and too systematizing. Delboeufs older view certainly holds good for many cases. The onset of the realization of the suggestion may produce the autosuggestion of a perfect hypnosis in posthypnotic and waking suggestion, and also in suggestion as to time. The look becomes fixed, and the hypnotized may even become amnesic for all that has taken place, afterwards. If one generalizes in these eases, one deceives one's self just as much as one does if one generalizes in those undoubted cases in which the suggestion has been realized during complete clear waking condition. It is possible also by means of suggestion to remove everything which is hypnotic, including the intended suggestion, from these conditions, so that the condition becomes absolutely identical with the condition of complete wakefulness. One meets with all stages, from the fixed look to a perfectly clear look; from the automatism wanting in sound judgment, in which the most flagrant nonsense appears natural and comprehensible as it does in a dream, to the finest, sharpest self-criticism on the part of the hypnotized, and to the most energetic struggle against the compulsion and impulse of the suggestion. One can even limit the suggestion to such natural and unimportant details, such as one intertwines constantly in the temporal linking of thought, that there is no longer any question even of a condition prime (Liegeois's definition). I have observed, apart from individual peculiarities, that the conditions under discussion approach more nearly to actual hypnosis if one suggests a wide, coherent, and at the same time idiotic complex, while it approaches more nearly to the normal waking condition the more natural, probable, limited, and curt the suggestion is. Examples will illustrate this clearly.

1 Jules Liegeois. "De la suggestion hypnotique dans ses rapports a vec le droit civil et le droit criminel." {Paris: A. Picard, 1884.)

2 Beaunis, "Recherches experimentales sur les condition de 1'Activite Cerebrale," etc.: "Somnambulisme provoque." p. 67.

3 Revue de l'hypnotisme, I ere annee, 1887, p. 166. 4 Ibid, 1888.

I have said to a woman during complete wakefulness that she could not move her arm; I raised the arm at the time. She stared at me, attempted vainly to depress the arm, became confused, and so on. I then added the following suggestions rapidly one after another: "Here comes a lion; you see him? He will eat us up. Now he is going away. It is getting dark. The moon is shining. Look at the great big river there with thousands of fishes in it. You are quite rigid all over; you cannot move at all," etc., etc. In a few seconds all these impressions rush through the consciousness of the woman in the form of perceptions with corresponding sensations. Her mental condition approaches more and more that of the ordinary hypnosis; she becomes like one in a dream. One can say with Delboeuf in this case that "she is hypnotized again."

I have said on another occasion to the same hypnotized nurse: "Every time that the assistant medical officer comes into your ward and you report on the condition of the excitable patient, Louisa C, you will make a mistake and call her Lina C. You will notice your mistake, and attempt to correct yourself, but will not be able to do so; you will always say Lina for Louisa. And each time you call the medical officer "Doctor," you will scratch your right temple with your right hand without being aware of it." The suggestion was realized. The nurse made the mistake, and said Lina C. instead of Louisa C. regularly in ordinary conversation. It was just like a suggested paraphasia of a word. She noticed it, tried to correct herself, but made the same mistake again, and was astonished at it. Every time that she called the assistant medical officer "Doctor" she scratched herself exactly in the manner I suggested. It was quite extraordinary to see how the unsuspicious nurse repeated the mistake with C.'s name almost every day, apologized, and was astonished; she could not make out what was the matter with her; such a thing bad never in her whole life occurred to her before. The scratching, on the other hand, took place quite instinctively, without her noticing it. After some weeks she began gradually to assist herself out of the difficulty by leaving out the patient's Christian name, and simply saying C. A single suggestion sufficed for the disturbance which recurred for so long a time. One would have to assume that the condition prime only held good during the speaking of the Christian name and during the scratching, while the rest of her speech took place in the condition of normal wakefulness. But during the time that she is scratching, she speaks of things which were not suggested, and which are quite rational. In consequence, the condition prime existed only for a portion of her psychical activity.