Can one permanently alter the mind or any nerve function by suggestion, in however slight a degree ?

One has been able to give suggestion as to time for a whole year's duration; one has produced sleep lasting for days by suggestion; and, above all, one can show a number of lasting therapeutic results. But still, on the other hand, every one who has taken up the question of suggestion must admit that the action of a hypnosis becomes weakened of itself in the course of time. But I have not been able to convince myself that the hypnotized person gradually ceases to be under the influence of the hypnotist when the latter has kept away for a long time. This used to be stated as a fact. I frequently find, on the contrary, that later, after a long pause - more than half or one year - the results of hypnosis are better than if one exhausts one's self by continuously hypnotizing a patient or a healthy person.

The therapeutic results of hypnosis appear to me to give the best solution to our question if one regards them closely. I believe that one can only achieve a lasting result either (1) if the attained chance possesses in itself the power of insinuating itself in the struggle for existence between the individual dynamisms of the central nervous system by having been transformed into autosuggestion or habit by means of a single or repeated suggestion; or (2) if the power which is wanting in this change is supplied to it by outside means. This latter can, however, be produced also by suggestion at times. One must always give the suggestion that the result will be permanent. But experience shows that this alone rarely acts completely without the outside means referred to.

Examples. Ad 1. - A child retained the bad habit of wetting its bed. It was compelled by means of suggestion to get up during the night and micturate into the chamber, and at length to hold its urine altogether. The bad habit was replaced by a good one, which at the same time was easy to secure, because it is a normal one. The child had accustomed itself to sleep quite comfortably in the wet bed. Now it has become accustomed to remain dry. It is awakened even by a dream of passing urine. We can obtain a definite cure in this case if no abnormality of the bladder or urethra or onanistic habits continue to act against the result of the suggestion later on.

Ad 2

A person suffered from migraine, sleeplessness, loss of appetite, tiredness, constipation, and frequent nocturnal emissions, and had become ameuiic and thin in consequence. I succeeded in supplying him with sleep, appetite, regular motions, and cessation of the emissions by means of suggestion. In consequence, the amaemia was soon lost, the hypnotized person gained in nutrition and weight, the sleep cured the nervous exhaustion, and thereby also the migraine. The latter can be, however, suggested away immediately. In this way the balance of the organism was regained, and the cure will remain a permanent one if the cause which produced the illness does not return or is not a permanent one.

I therefore believe that suggestion is frequently capable of removing acquired vices and bad habits as well as certain acquired ailments, especially if it is assisted by outside means. But it can never permanently alter inherited or constitutional individual characteristies. In such cases suggestion will only bare a transitory action, and the same applies to destructive and also to deeply rooted troubles.

But we do not always know in a concrete case how much of the disturbance is inherited and bow much is acquired - i.e.r individually adapted. It is often sufficient to remove the acquired factor in order to arrest or suppress the inherited disposition. In this case also suggestion is able to do good. This is what we do when we remove the hystero-epileptic attacks in an hysterical person, for example, by means of suggestion, electrotherapy, or hydrotherapy. The latter are based on an action similar to that of suggestion. The acquired attacks are cured in this way, but the hysterical constitution remains unchanged.

Every long-lasting result of suggestion, as long as it influences activities during the waking condition, is, eo ipso, posthypnotic. Thus it would belong, logically speaking, to Lie-geois's condition prime. For example, one may cite suggested menstruation, suggested cheerfulness, the cure of stammering and of constipation by means of suggestion, etc. If one were to push formal logic to the extreme, one would have to consider that a person who has been definitely cured would remain in the condition prime for the rest of his life. I only wish to point out clearly by this that there cannot be a line of demarcation between the altered condition of the mind during hypnosis and its perfectly normal condition of activity during waking. One can produce any stage or degree experimentally. To a certain extent, graduated transitions are observable in many perilous between spontaneous sleep and the waking condition without suggestion. Still, these are produced by the accident of autosuggestion, and are therefore not nearly so exactly graduated or so systematically divided as those produced by means of suggestion.

13. "Hallucination Retroactive," OR Suggested Falsification of Memory. - Bernheim calls the suggested remembrance of what has never taken place "hallucination retroactive." As one is not dealing in this case with an effective actual perception, nor yet necessarily with the recollection of perceptions - for it might just as well be the recollection of a thought or of a feeling or action - I cannot allow this term to pass. This is not the same, either, as that phenomenon which is called actual deception of memory in psychopathology, since the latter always refers erroneously a duplicate, or a remembrance into the past, in the place of an actual complex of perceptions. However, the suggested process is equivalent psychologically to the wider idea of deception of memory, taken in the sense in which Kraepelin has defined it. 1