Example

I said all of a sudden to a certain Miss X., just as a young man who was a stranger to her came into the room (she was awake at the time): "You know this gentleman. He stole your purse at the station a month ago and ran away with it," etc She looked at him, first somewhat surprised, but was soon convinced. She remembered it exactly, and even added l A. Delbrueck ("The Pathological Lie and the Psychically Abnormal Swindler": Enke, 1891] describes a case of deception of memory in a lunatic in the Burghoelzli Asylum. At first I bad regarded it as a simple hallucination; one used to think, erroneously, that one was dealing in such cases with effective hallucinations. This patient frequently suddenly appeared and explained, or wrote in great indignation, that the director or the assistant medical officer had done horrible things to him - had ill-used him, undressed him, etc. - on some past occasion (yesterday or early this morning to a stated hour). The important point of this is - and it can be proved easily - that he did not have the hallucination at. the time to which be referred it, but was quietly doing something ordinary, and was in good spirits. He explained the matter in this way: he had obviously been given some narcotic, so that the remembrance of the atrocity only relumed to him several hours later. Now, this is the purest form of Beniheim's "hallucination retroactive," only it was spontaneous and not suggested, and depended on a severe mental disturbance.

Another lunatic in the same asylum autosuggested negative deceptions of memory, which had given rise to the delusion of so-called "creative acts." For example, he said to me: "Doctor, ihis table only appeared this morning; it was not there before. This is an act of creation. You may say that 1 am mistaken, but you may only speak in that way if you have higher powers," etc. The table had stood for years in the same place in the recreation-room for the patients. But it was not difficult to prove that this patient had known the table long ago, and had always used it. Thus & real negative hallucination had not actually been present. This had only lain in the recollection, and took place at the time when he regarded the object (in the same way as with genuine deceptions of memory); only the object was blotted out from the past, instead of being again added to it. The same patient constantly had delusions of similar creative acts, as the result of this kind of negative deceptions of memory (retroactive negative hallucinations).

that there was a pound in the purse. She then demanded that he should be punished. If I can successfully suggest amnesia to a person for a certain past time, or for one of his brain dynamisms - e.g., for an acquired language - then I can just as easily suggest an artificial addition to his recollections, as long as I bring the corresponding conceptions into his brain. If I say to a hypnotized person, "You can speak Sanscrit," he will not be able to do so unless he has learned it. If I say to him, however, "You have experienced this or that, or done, said, or thought something," etc., he believes that he ha8 experienced, done, or thought it, assimilates the suggestion fully in the recollections of his past life, and complements in those places where I have left the details out (as in the case of the contents of the purse). A small boy, aged eight years, whom I showed at the meeting of the Law Society in Zurich, swore before God that one of the barristers present had stolen his pocket handkerchief a week previously, in response to my suggestion. He added of his own account, when he was asked, the exact place and time. Five minutes later I suggested to him that this had never taken place, and that he had never said that it had. He denied with just as definite boldness on his oath the charge which he had made a few minutes before, in spite of the indignant admonition of the lawyer.

It is greatly to Bernheim'a credit that he has explained these very important facts clearly by means of numerous examples. Bernheim has even given these retroactive suggestions collectively, and produced a number of false witnesses in this way, who gave their evidence with absolute conviction. He has pointed out that it is particularly easy to produce such deceptions of memory during complete wakefulness by means of suggestion, especially in children. These are instinctively inclined to accept, more or less, everything which is told them by grownup people in a decided tone. Since suggestion can be successful in many cases in which marked influences of imagination act without hypnotic sleep ever having taken place previously, and since this holds good especially for children and weakly persona, one understands how great the danger of the suggestion of a false witness is, and especially of false admissions in response to the suggestive questions of the examining judge. Bernheim Las called attention to the fact that such cases have not infrequently taken place in criminal procedures. For example, this was so in the supposed Tisza-Ezlar ritual murder case, in which a child, influenced suggestively in this way appeared as a witness for the Crown. Lawyers are no doubt in a position to find many such cases among the accounts of celebrated trials. Intimidation and also imitation act similarly in children. It is certain that there is scarcely a boy or girl who dares to refuse to submit to Church confirmation, although most of them would deny all that they had promised then a short time later. In this an undistinguishable mixture of intimidation, imitation, and suggestion, etc, takes part. This is mostly not a conscious lie.

A. Delbrueck 1 mentions a highly interesting tale of the poet Gottfried Keller, 2 which represents nothing else than an excellent example of suggested deception of memory or of retroactive hallucination. Keller's account is so true, and corresponds so exactly with all the details of the psychological phenomenon, that I am hound to believe with Delbrueck that the poet must have experienced the story himself. This appears to be all the more probable, since it is known that Keller, in the "Gruene Heinrich" (Heinrich Lee), has incorporated many experiences of his own life. Heinrich Lee was seven years old at the time of the story. I may add that every one can easily observe in little children, and especially in children of from two to four years of age, the boundless suggestibility and confusion of conception with reality. I have myself watched a girl between the age of eight and nine years who completely forgot to go home to dinner after she had come out of school. She thereupon suggested to herself a perfectly untrue story, according to which she had been invited to dinner by a lady, had been driven to the bouse in a carriage, etc. She told me the story in all its details, and with naive conviction. There was no onestion that she was telling willful lies. The child had no reason to do this, and, besides, she was not otherwise untruthful.

1 A. Delbrueck, loc. cil.