This section is from the book "Hypnotism, Mesmerism And The New Witchcraft", by Ernest Hart. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism, Mesmerism, and the New Witchcraft.
If now I touched the hair of the doll, which she was supposed not to see, she exclaimed, according to my notes, 'On touche les cheveux,' 'On les tire' - 'They are touching my hair - they are pulling it' - and as she complained it hurt her, we had to leave off pulling the doll's hair. Taking the doll to a little distance, I pinched it; she showed every sign of pain, and cried out 'I don't like to be hurt - je ne veux pas qu'on me fasse de mal.' I tickled the cheek of the figure, she began to smile pleasantly (I am still quoting from the notes). I put away the witness dolls, and we then proceeded to the effects of medicine tubes applied to the skin. I took a tube which was supposed to contain alcohol, but which did contain cherry laurel water. She immediately began, to use the words of M. Sajous's note, to smile agreeably and then to laugh; she became gay: 'It makes me laugh,' she said, and then,'I'm not tipsy, I want to sing,' - and so on through the whole performance of a not ungraceful griserie which we stopped at that stage, for I was loth to have the degrading performance of drunkenness carried to the extreme I had seen her go through at the Charite. I now applied a tube of alcohol, asking the assistant, however, to give me valerian, which no doubt this profoundly hypnotised subject perfectly well heard, for she immediately went through the whole cat performance I have already described as having been performed for my delectation by Mervel under the hands of Dr. Luys on the previous day.
She spat, she scratched, she mewed,she leaped about on all fours, and she was as thoroughly cat-like as was Mervel on the previous and Jeanne on the subsequent day. It would be tedious to go through the whole of the notes of the numerous sittings which I had with these five subjects, but I may say at once that we had the cat performance six times, twice with Jeanne, twice with Vix, once with Clarice, and once with Mervel. In no case by any accident was valerian used, but either sugar, alcohol, diabetic sugar, cherry laurel water or distilled water; nevertheless the performance never foiled when the subjects had reason to think it was expected of them.

Fig. 19. - A ' Witness' Doll used in Control Experiments.

Fig. 20. - A 'Witness' Doll used in Control Experiments.
Space will not permit me to reproduce the protocols of the various sittings in Paris, at which I tested the unreality of the hypnotic phenomena presented to me at the Charite. I retain for reference and for verification the original documents, signed by the various witnesses who were present, and who minutely watched all my counter-experiments. I had very numerous sittings, and carried out in the methods above described numerous and complete counter-tests, selecting always and only the patients who had been presented to me by Dr. Luys and Colonel de Rochas, and the subjects who had been operated on. Never by any accident did any one of these subjects show any power of discerning the effects of magnetised from non-magnetised iron; the pretensions of Br. Luys that they could distinguish between magnetic photographs so-called and non-magnetic were in every case ascertained to be unfounded; the communication of sensations or thought by contact never took place in any case unless the subjects knew precisely what was the nature of the comedy to be played, and then they played it more or less well.
The cat performance and the drunken scenes came off six times when the subject supposed that the tubes contained alcohol, but when they really contained divers substances, none of which were alcoholic; the scenes produced were acted in the same way under the influence of an empty tube, of a tube of alcohol, and of a tube of valerian. In order that there may be no doubt of the accuracy of these statements, I reproduce the letters of three eyewitnesses.

Fig. 21. - Clarice 'hypnotised' and attracted by a yellow glass ball.

Fig. 22. - Clarice ' hypnotised' and repelled by a blue glass ball.
I can testify that the experiments at which I was present took place exactly as you have described them. The methods which you employed to demonstrate the trickery on the part of the subjects - notably the changing of the dolls and the substitution of the glass of water and of the magnet - were so simple that one finds a difficulty in believing that the physicians who have made themselves the apostles of this new superstition are acting in good faith. I have myself made numerous experiments on Dr. Lays' subjects and of those of many other physicians; and I have always succeeded with the greatest facility in unmasking their frauds, which really can only deceive those who wish to be deceived. Either dupes or accomplices - there is no other alternative term for the adepts of the doctrines now tending to discredit medicine and to throw it back many centuries. I am entirely in agreement with what you have said as to the morality of the subjects who lend themselves to these grotesque experiments. This branch of the subject much more concerns the police des moeurs than it does clinical medicine.
I am quite ready to relate what I saw at the sittings which took place in your room in the Hotel Continental. There was no accord between the phenomena manifested by the hypnotised subjects and the production of the current of magnetisation, etc. You repeated the experiments of Dr. Luys and those of M. de Bochas, avoiding all suggestion, either involuntary or unconscious, which might vitiate the results. You took care to hide from the subjects the nature of the drugs tested, to which M. Luys attributes an action at a distance, and the moment of the closure or opening of the current of your electro-magnet. Under these conditions there was no longer any relation between the nature of the medicinal agent and the symptoms manifested; when the circuit was opened without their knowledge, the subjects said they experienced the varied sensations which they ordinarily attribute to the passage of the current. They were unable to distinguish the open from the closed state of the current. You repeated M. de Rochas' experiment of envoutement, employing without the knowledge of the hypnotised woman two dolls, one of which remained carefully separated from her. She uttered shrieks when I pulled the hair of the doll which she had not touched, etc.
These facts appear to me decisive in regard to the settlement of a question which I ought to say has been decided by the vast majority of the French scientific public in a sense absolutely opposed to the results proclaimed by MM. Luys and de Rochas. It is well that it should be known in England that the opinions of these two experimenters find no support in the French scientific world.
 
Continue to: