This section is from the book "Hypnotism, Mesmerism And The New Witchcraft", by Ernest Hart. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism, Mesmerism, and the New Witchcraft.
I have read with most lively interest in the 'British Medical Journal' your notes on the New Mesmerism, and I hasten to state that you have reproduced very faithfully the opinion of all those who were present at the Paris experiments, and that your judgment, although severe, is absolutely just.
I pass now to the consideration of the underlying substratum of fact on which this huge structure of imposture and credulity is built. As I have already sufficiently indicated, the artificially induced sleep known by the old-fashioned Latin name somnambulism, or subsequently as mesmerism, and rebaptized in Greek, hypnotism, as though it were a new thing, is a subjective phenomenon of great interest, and of some complexity. It is, perhaps, not altogether unworthy of the attention which has been bestowed on it by French and German physicians. On the other hand - and here I only express a purely personal opinion, which must be taken for just what it is thought to be worth - I at least have come to the conclusion, after carefully watching the course of events at the Salpetriere and Bicetre, and studying the enormously voluminous literature which owes its origin to the school of Nancy, to the Paris school, and to Belgian and Austrian writers, that the importance of these studies has been vastly exaggerated. I am disposed to think that it is more the picturesque eccentricity of the phenomena and the striking mise en scene to which human automatism lends itself and which has attracted so much attention, than the real medical or physiological importance of the subject.
Hypnotism, even as practised at the Salpetriere, Has, so far as I can see, taught us little, if anything, of the functions of the brain or of the organs of the mind that we did not know before. I find little in the writings of Charcot, of Bernheim, or of Janet but an excessively detailed development of facts and principles, already soundly, clearly and usefully laid down by Carpenter and Braid. With a lucidity, clinical power and picturesqueness beyond praise, M. Charcot has described, depicted and exemplified a most striking series of hysterical phenomena. He has shown that nearly, if not quite all hypnotics, are neurotic persons to whom the general classification of hysterics or neurasthenics may fairly be applied.
Of the intrinsic correctness of his classification of the stages of hysteria in its larger forms, I am sceptical; nor do I think it a permanent nosological classification which will endure in medicine. These various stages, so regularly produced in classical order, appear to be performances originating partly in the autosuggestion of an originally morbid patient, and then perpetuated by imitation, suggestion, ward training, and by habit in some. I am so persuaded that they are artificial, that I even venture to predict they will cease to exist when the succession, so to speak, of M. Charcot's trained patients is broken, and when the habit of performance in the wards and theatre of the Salpetriere is given up, as I am inclined to think it will be before long. Such patients and such stages of the greater hysteria are not found elsewhere, unless the patients are led up to them by training or by imitative instincts; they are non-natural, they have no real existence in medicine and will take no enduring place, so far as one can judge, in the history of medicine.
It was natural enough that one extravagance should lead to another, and the follies of La Charite can but be regarded as the offspring - illegitimate, perhaps, and repudiated - of certain extravagances into which even men so able, so lucid and so thoughtful as the School of the Salpetriere have allowed themselves to be led. Already there are, happily, signs of a reaction within the School of the Salpetriere itself. I believe that journalists and the public are now excluded from these performances; the grande hysterie, with all its stages, is much more rarely seen, and there is reason to hope that it will die out now that the first excitement of this scenic display has weakened and the performance is felt to be monotonous and wearisome. Thought transference is not now spoken of at La Salpetriere and the proceedings at La Gharit6 are there ignored with an intentionally contemptuous silence.
What remains, then, of practical value and of medical utility as the results of these lengthened studies? What are their mischiefs? Are these adequately balanced against their benefits? First as to their mischiefs. I will again let Dr. Luys speak, for although he is the most enthusiastic apostle of the presumed benefits, he is perfectly outspoken as to the resultant injuries.
'From the social point of view these new states of instantaneous loss of consciousness into which hypnotic or merely fascinated subjects may be made to pass deserve to be considered with lively interest. As I shall have to explain to you later, the individual in these novel conditions no longer belongs to himself; he is surrendered, an inert being, to the enterprise of those who surround him. At one moment in the passive stage in this condition of lethargy or of catalepsy, he is absolutely defenceless, and exposed to any criminal attempt on the part of those who surround him. He can be poisoned and mutilated. Where a woman is concerned she may be violated and even infected with syphilis, of which I have recently observed a painful example in my practice. She may become a mother without any trace existing of a criminal assault, and without the patient having the smallest recollection of what has passed after she has awakened. Sometimes, in the active condition, the state of lucid somnambulism, and even in the condition of simple fascination, the subject may be exposed to the influence of suggestions of the most varied kind on the part of the person directing his actions.
 
Continue to: