I ask Dr. Luys, then, to explain why, if he knew Jeanne and Clarice to be impostors, he presented them, together with Marguerite and Mervel, as witnesses of the truth only some weeks ago? How it is that he has not withdrawn those parts of his lectures which he bases on their performances; and I ask him further to state explicitly who it is among the subjects of my experiments, chosen from his own subjects as being the only persons produced by him, whom he now denounces as having long been known to him as untrustworthy?

I did not raise the question of good faith in respect of Dr. Luys; on the contrary, I expressly declared my belief in his good faith, alleging my conviction that, as these women themselves openly said to me in the presence of M. Cremiere and others, Dr. Luys was their dupe. The words of Jeanne were: 'Nous le flouons, tous.' I gave him credit, and still give him credit, for perfect good faith, although I charge him with incredible looseness in his method of experiment, and with incredible extravagance and error in the deductions which he has allowed himself to make from the false phenomena to which his mode of experimentation inevitably leads. He has now raised the question of his own good faith by alleging that he knew and has long known these subjects to be destitute of veracity, and he must settle that question with himself rather than with me. On that subject I am ready to accept whatever declaration Dr. Luys, after fall reconsideration of his position, may desire to make. I am satisfied that in such a matter he will be incapable of doing anything which is not fully worthy of his distinguished position as a member of the Academy of Medicine and a physician of one of the great French hospitals.

I am satisfied, too, and shall now produce the evidence, that neither Jeanne, nor Mervel, nor Clarice, nor Marguerite is worthy of the slightest credence in anything which they assert they saw or felt or did in respect to any of these performances. But when did Dr. Luys become convinced of this, and, being convinced of it, when and to whom did he first announce it, or first give the warnings due to himself as having acted before the world and to me and those who were with me so late as January 5, as the sponsor of their sincerity?

I turn now to my notes of the results of some of the tests applied by me to Dr. Luys's subjects. I repeated on Marguerite, in the presence of two witnesses, most of the experiments which had been performed on her by Colonel de Rochas in the wards of Dr. Luys and in his presence. Dr. Luys had reproduced with her the phenomena of the influence of medicines at a distance, and with her and Clarice jointly the transmission of drunkenness by contact of one patient with the other. On January 6 Marguerite came to my rooms in charge of a medical friend. We began by hypnotising her after the classic method of M. de Rochas and Dr. Luys, putting her through the successive stages already described. I had prepared an electro-magnet of considerable power, from which the current could be turned on or off with great rapidity by touching a button or by lifting the plates from the bath, or of course by detaching one or other of the wires. I had also a bar of iron resembling the magnetised bar which M. Luys had used, but which was not magnetic, a demagnetised magnet, and a set of needles variously and inversely magnetised. I had also two exactly similar wax dolls brought from a toy shop, and two exactly similar glasses of water.

We began the proceedings by the prise du regard, which was perfectly performed; we then used the magnets. I signalled to the assistant, and told him to put on the current, whereupon he turned it off. Accustomed, however, to believe that a magnet must be a-magnet Marguerite began to handle it. The note taken by Dr. Sajous runs thus: 'She found the north pole, notwithstanding there was no current, very pretty; she was as it were fascinated by it; she caressed the blue flames, and showed every sign of delight. Then came the phenomena of attraction. She followed the magnet with delight across the room, as though fascinated by it; the bar was turned so as to present the other end, or what would be called, in the language of La Charite, the south pole, then she fell into the attitude of repulsion and horror, with clenched fists, and as it approached her she fell backward into the arms of M. Cremiere, and was carried, still showing all the signs of terror and repulsion, back to her chair. The bar was again turned until what should have been the north pole was presented to her, she resumed the same attitudes of attraction, and tears bedewed her cheeks. "Ah," she said, "it is blue, the flames mount," and she rose from her seat, following the magnet round the room.

Again the pole bar was reversed, and once more she exclaimed that she saw "all red, all red." ' Similar but false phenomena were obtained in succession with all the different forms of magnet and non-magnet; Marguerite was never once right, but throughout her acting was perfect; she was utterly unable at any. time really to distinguish between a plain bar of iron, a demagnetised magnet, or a horse-shoe magnet carrying a full current and one from which the current was wholly cut off. In the latter part of this sitting Dr, Olivier entered the room and witnessed the second series of magnetic experiments as well as the experiments of externalisation. We took one of the dolls. We restored Marguerite to the perfectly hypnotised condition, and when she was profoundly plunged in the state which is described as profound hypnosis, I placed a doll in her hand, which she held long enough to sensitise it. I then, taking the doll from her, rapidly disposed of it behind some books, and proceeded to operate on another doll which she had not touched and which I had just taken out of the box in which it came from the toy-shop. The preceding illustrations show the witness dolls with which I operated (figs. 19 and 20). Holding her hand I placed her in contact with Dr. Sajous, that he might also be, to use the jargon of the school, en rapport with her, and I continued to hold her hand.