This section is from the book "Part. 6. Drink Restriction (Thirst-Cures), Particularly In Obesity", by Prof. Carl von Noorden and Dr. Hugo Salomon. Also available from Amazon: Clinical Treatises On the Pathology and Therapy of Disorders of Metabolism and Nutrition, Part 6.
We occupy the same standpoint in regard to the effect of diaphoretic treatment upon ascites due to hepatic cirrhosis as Leichtenstern, Matthes, H. Strauss (44), viz.: that as a rule the ascites does not permanently improve. We say "as a rule," for there can be no doubt that some cases derive extraordinary benefits from this treatment. Such isolated cases have recently been utilized by adherents of the "Naturheil-methode" (Nature's cure) for purposes of propaganda, and have been advanced as examples to show that puncture of the abdomen and Talma's operation (an operation, it is true, that has not so far altogether vindicated the claims of its advocates) are not to be recommended. Energetic diaphoretic, i.e., dehydrating, treatment of ascites is by no means so far removed from scientific medicine as the voices that clamor from the camp of the water-doctors would have us believe. One of the warmest advocates of this treatment was Carl Gerhardt, who used to emphasize again and again in his clinical lectures that many a puncture of the abdomen for ascites is rendered superfluous by diaphoretic treatment. He advised, in particular, to sweat the patient daily for two to three weeks, in order to prevent the reaccumulation of water in the abdominal cavity. Later von Noorden in the General
Hospital in Frankfort modified this method in such a way that in addition to employing diaphoretic measures the amount of liquids was restricted, or the latter plan alone was adopted. We have observed in a limited number of cases - too small a number, it is true, to justify us in drawing final conclusions - that continued restriction of liquids (to about 1 to 1 1/2 liters a day) caused a disappearance of the ascites, without subsequent recurrence. The case that was studied for the longest period was that of a merchant of fifty years who was punctured twice, and then refused a third puncture. He conscientiously followed the advice not to drink more than 1 liter of fluid a day for two years. At the expiration of the first six weeks he was quite free from ascites, nor was there any recurrence during the ensuing seven years, even though the patient during this period imposed no restrictions in regard to water-drinking upon himself.
 
Continue to: