This section is from the book "Part. 6. Drink Restriction (Thirst-Cures), Particularly In Obesity", by Prof. Carl von Noorden and Dr. Hugo Salomon. Also available from Amazon: Clinical Treatises On the Pathology and Therapy of Disorders of Metabolism and Nutrition, Part 6.
In some of the cases reported above it was found incidentally that in chlorotic girls the restriction of liquids caused a considerable increase in the specific gravity of the blood and serum; the percentage of hemoglobin and the number of red-blood corpuscles also rose, although not to the same degree. After the termination of the period of water-restriction these values remained at the same level, although abundant water drinking was again permitted. This finding recalls the discovery that von Noorden (40), and soon after him Romberg (41), announced, viz.: that in chlorotic subjects the water percentage in the tissues is high, and that the occurrence of an abundant diuresis with loss of much water is to be welcomed as an early sign of improvement. One is further reminded of the fact that certain other methods have been advised in the treatment of chlorosis that lead to a withdrawal of fluids from the body, viz.: blood-letting, combined with diaphoretic measures. There is some diversity of opinions in regard to the value of these methods. On the one hand we have very favorable, even enthusiastic, reports - Dyes, Schubert, Dehio (42); on the other skepticism - Scholz, Kunne, Paul Schmidt (43). Our personal experience with bloodletting and diaphoresis in chlorosis is limited. We failed to see that the results obtained were sufficiently favorable, as compared to the great inconveniences of the method and the discomfort that the patients are made to suffer, to warrant its adoption. For this reason this form of treatment was soon abandoned in our clinic.
One would undoubtedly have gained a clearer insight into the value of this treatment if a more careful study of individual peculiarities had been made and if the exact stage of the disease had been more carefully considered by the various observers who have reported on this method. As von Noorden has pointed out, not every case of chlorosis is hydraemic, i.e., the tissues are not overloaded with water. Moreover, the different authors who have written on bleeding, with diaphoresis, in chlorosis fail to inform us whether or not they attempted to prevent a rapid replacement of the water by restricting the liquid-intake.
It may be considered established that blood-letting at rare intervals may stimulate blood-formation in chlorotic subjects, and may in this way constitute the beginning of improvement (von Noorden [40]). It is, to say the least, doubtful whether diaphoretic measures, that are so popular in this day of physical therapy, are capable of exercising the same influence. Much that is written on the subject is vain hypothesis and unproved conjecture, but by no means physio logical truth. We do not want to deny at the same time that diaphoretic measures may not be of some benefit in chlorosis; we merely maintain that so far no explanation has been forthcoming for this phenomenon. We are particularly disinclined to deny the favorable general effect of diaphoretic measures in chlorosis, because we have found that the restriction of liquids to 3/2 or 4/2 liters a day, that acts in a similar manner as diaphoresis, exercises an excellent therapeutic effect in chlorosis and renders subsequent iron-therapy more effective. In favorable cases a mighty diuresis is seen during the period of water-restriction, so that the water-output exceeds the water-intake, just as von Noorden had previously described it. At the same time the patients' appetite and their muscular vigor increase in an extraordinary manner. On the other hand, this moderate restriction of liquids (to 1 1/2 to 2 liters) never exercises any appreciable effect upon the percentage of hemoglobin. Even if the restriction of liquids is carried still further (to less than 1 liter) the effect upon the hemoglobin percentage is only insignificant (see above).
We maintain that wise moderation in water-drinking is altogether rational in chlorosis, and that the same results are obtained therefrom in practice as from diaphoretic procedures that are much more severe. If one is unduly prejudiced in favor of diaphoresis, then one should at least support the advantage gained by restricting the liquid-intake to a certain degree. Unless this be done the one advantage that seems important to us (see von Noorden, Romberg), viz.: the dehydration of the organism, will not be gained.
 
Continue to: