In our opinion restricted water drinking in heart diseases is of inestimable value as a prophylactic measure. As soon as disturbances of compensation supervene this measure is to be considered merely as an adjuvant to treatment, and other means, digitalis, etc., become more important. We know of cases, however, from our personal experience in which a variety of heart-regulating and diuretic medicaments failed, and in which improvement did not set in until the liquids were restricted; often even after an energetic thirst-cure the heart and kidneys would begin to react to drugs. If one decides to institute an energetic thirst-cure - and this procedure is always somewhat heroic - it is best, according to our experience, to restrict or stop all solid food as well as liquids, i. e., to induce the patients to fast completely for a few days and to take no liquids whatever during this period.

It is an old and well-known fact (and one that has been demonstrated repeatedly in animals that were submitted to starvation as well as in human subjects who voluntarily underwent a prolonged period of fasting) that a fasting organism requires an extraordinarily small amount of water. Even if a fasting subject is allowed water ad libitum, it will be found that he rarely takes more than one liter a day, and frequently less. All observers, moreover, agree that hunger, with or without restriction of liquids, is borne far better than the restriction or the complete withdrawal of liquids alone. We have had the same experience in patients suffering from cardiac oedemas, and find our observations in a measure corroborated by the statements made by Karell, F. Hirschfeld, S. Laache (13) in regard to the therapeutic value of under-feeding in cardiac disorders.

Inasmuch as the older methods of blood examination (specific gravity, percentage of water, corpuscle count, haemoglobin determinations) had failed to offer a satisfactory interpretation for these good therapeutic results, newer methods of blood examination have recently been adopted in an attempt to solve the problem, chief among them the cryoscopy (freezing-point determination) of the blood and the determination of its electric conductivity. These methods have broadened the field of investigation, but have so far thrown no new light on the subject. Fr. Kraus (14), basing on these newer methods and their results, has recently submitted the theoretical justification of Oerters cure to a searching criticism, and has at the same time pointed out many promising paths for future investigations to follow. He claims, in particular, to have already found a chemico-physical index for the beginning of failing compensation; this moment, and with it the indication to restrict the ingestion of liquids, is said to have arrived when the quotient Cc/C (Cc=concentration of electrolytes, i. e., acids, bases, salts; Cc=total concentration) begins to be lowered in the urine.

Fr. Kraus, however, also agrees that for the present, practical experience is a much better criterion of the value of Oerters method than theoretical considerations of any kind.

We agree fully with this view and at the same time declare it very improbable that our understanding of this question will ever be considerably advanced by studies concerned, as heretofore, with determinations of the chemical and physical concentration of the blood. The disadvantages of abundant water drinking in patients with a weak heart must not be sought in an accumulation of the water in the cardio-vascular apparatus, but

(1) In the forced transputation of large quantities of liquid through the blood stream.

(2) In the diffusion of water into the tissues, thus causing swelling, compression of capillaries and an increased resistance of the blood stream.

The first case demands regulation of the ingestion of liquids whenever the heart is to be spared, that is, prophylactically before the onset of any compensatory disturbances.

The second case presupposes that the disturbance in the water equilibrium has already begun. The onset of this condition, in our opinion, can much more readily be estimated from fluctuations in the diuresis and of the weight of the patient than from examinations of the blood. Weighing the patient is even more important than searching for oedema. The patient may gain 5 or 6 kg. from an accumulation of water, before any oedemas become apparent, even in most careful search. During this prehydropic period, that is so important in the prognosis of the case and the treatment of the patient, the blood often does not show the slightest percentage change of concentration.

We habitually advise sufferers from heart disease to drink sparingly, even when compensation is in no way disturbed, and we recommend that they ingest no more than from 1250 to 1500 c. c. of liquid - including everything fluid in the diet. Precisely as a preventative of further trouble in cases showing incipient cardiac disturbances, e. g., arhythmia, contractions in arterio-sclerotic subjects, etc., does this means appeal to us. In fully developed hydrops we proceed more energetically, as a rule, but do not decrease the amount of fluid ingesta below 1000 to 800 c. c.

Von Noorden (15) some years ago applied Oertel's doctrine to renal diseases, and showed that in many cases of nephritis the restriction of liquids is an important postulate of rational treatment, particularly in contracted kidney.

In the latter disease the heart, above all, is affected, and there is always danger of early cardiac incompetency. Here the restriction of liquids is an excellent prophylactic, and even at a stage of the disease when cardiac dilatation and weakness are fully developed do we see good results from this method. The objections that H. Strauss (16) has formulated against this procedure, and that are largely based on blood examinations (increase in the molecular concentration of the blood in cases of contracted kidney), can hardly be considered valid in view of the positive therapeutic results that have repeatedly been obtained; they only show again how dangerous it is to attach dogmatic importance to one single method of examination. One is never justified in ignoring any fact for the sake of maintaining a theory, and it certainly is a fact that many cases of contracted kidney, although restricted in their water drinking, enjoy the best of health for many years, notwithstanding the fact that the molecular concentration of the blood is increased. We must conclude from all this that studies of the molecular concentration of the blood are no practical or reliable index of the subjective well-being or the progress of these cases; and one is certainly not justified in reversing the proposition and utilizing fluctuations in the molecular concentration of the blood to invalidate the usefulness of certain definite and well-established therapeutic rules. We call particular attention to the fact, moreover, that von Noorden expressly advocated the restriction of liquids for none other than cases of contracted kidney and for certain stages of acute nephritis.

Von Noorden in his first publication ("Congr. f. innere Medicin," Carlsbad, 1899) mentioned the fact that in renal disorders great care must be exercised lest the restriction of fluids lead to a decreased elimination of the urinary end-products of metabolism (urea, uric acid, organic bases, salts, etc.). Preliminary investigations, however, that were presented in Carlsbad and at the Manchester meeting of the British Medical Association, 1902, showed that in most cases of chronic contracted kidney the elimination of urinary solids was not reduced when the fluid intake was restricted to 1 1/2 or even 1 1/4 liters. Since then L. Mohr and C. Dapper (17) have reported exhaustive clinical and experimental studies on this subject from von Noorden's clinic that fully corroborate these preliminary findings.

Other clinicians have reported corresponding results - Pel, Roth and Kovoesi, Hale White (18); and in the discussion on Bright's Disease at the Oxford meeting of the British Medical Association all the speakers agreed with von Noorden's views.

As soon as the patients enter the proper uraemic stage of the disease, no further advantage can be expected from the restriction of liquids. The method has also proven futile in chronic parenchymatous forms of nephritis with oedemas, although - theoretically - we should expect good results a priori from dehydration of the organism.

We can add to this cursory review of the application of thirst-cures in various diseases the use of water-restriction for therapeutic purposes in Diabetes insipidus. The reports on the results obtained in this disorder are contradictory. According to our own experience the gradual reduction of the fluid intake gives excellent and permanent results in isolated cases, in other cases again absolutely no effect is seen. The factors that determine the result in this disease are still so obscure that it is hardly worth while to enter into a detailed discussion of the subject in this place.