It is a peculiar fact that the thirst cure that was so commonly employed in the Middle Ages in the treatment of cardio-vascular disorders was not rescued from oblivion even by Schroth's cure. For otherwise the book that Oertel (11) published in 1884, entitled "Therapy of Cardio-Vascular Disorders," could not have surprised the profession as it did, nor could it have become so epoch-making. The work that Korner (12) published some time before Oertel must, it is true, be considered a precursor of the latter's ideas, and some credit, therefore, is due this author, too, for having revived the idea of restricting the fluid intake as a therapeutic measure. Oertel proposed, in cases of serious failure of compensation, to dehydrate the organism by reducing the amount of liquids ingested and by stimulating the elimination of water through the skin and the lungs. The means that Oertel employed to this end were muscular exercise, diaphoretic baths and injections of pilocarpin. After a sufficient quantity of water had in this way been withdrawn from the body, this improved condition was to be permanently maintained by the ingestion of a diet that contained little fluid.

Some of the postulates upon which Oertel based his conclusions were, it is true, open to criticism. Thus he presupposed the existence of an hydraemic plethora in his cases of failing cardiac compensation, i. e., a condition of the blood in which the plasma was abnormally diluted and the total quantity of the blood increased; he claimed that it was due to these two factors that the weakened heart muscle was overtaxed. In order to determine whether or not the organism was in a condition of hydrostatic equilibrium, he proposed the so-called "determination of the difference" (Differ enzbestimmung) between the intake of water per os and the output of water in the urine. These determinations, as was later shown, did not grant a true insight into the water equilibrium of the organism, for they did not take into consideration the amount of insensible perspiration, a factor that to this day has never been accurately determined in cases of heart disease. Notwithstanding this defect, Oertel's "determination of the difference," combined with daily weighing of the patient, offers a convenient and practical means for studying the water economy of the body.

It is much more difficult to determine how much importance should be attached to the theoretically interesting postulate advanced by Oertel, that there is in these cases a condition of "hydraemic plethora." A large number of investigations have been published on this subject, the results of which are altogether contradictory. Without entering into the details of all these investigations, a resumé of all the results obtained may be given in this place:

We know nothing definite so far in regard to the volume of blood in the different vascular areas in cardiac disease, and, in particular, in cases of failing compensation, and we do not know positively whether genuine "plethora" occurs or not. All that we do know is that in compensatory derangement - and possibly without it in heart disease - the normal distribution of the blood in the arteries and the veins is changed, the arteries on an average containing less, the veins more, than normal. It is unnecessary to discuss the important question how this factor determines, on the one hand, a more forcible impulse of the diseased heart, on the other hand, progressive dilatation of the right side of the heart.

For well-compensated cardiac lesions the concen tration of the blood (removed in the ordinary way by a small cutaneous puncture or puncture of a vein) is normal. Occasionally hyperglobulia and increased concentration are formed, particularly in lesions of the right side of the heart, and in congenital heart-diseases. In all of the cases in which the blood was found abnormally dilute (anaemia or hydraemia), complicating diseases, insufficient nutrition, etc., could be incriminated.

In cases of disturbed compensation, the percentage of water in the blood was sometimes found somewhat low, but much more frequently it was found normal or a little increased (in part as a result of the decrease of erythrocytes and haemoglobin, in part as a result of genuine hydraemia, i. e., hypalbuminosis of the plasma). In the cases in which considerable degrees of hydraemia were found, the patients were, as a rule, very much reduced, or they were suffering from complicating diseases. One is not, therefore, justified in speaking of typical hydraemia, that is, the result of pure compensatory disturbances, the existence of which Oertel has postulated.

It will be seen that the results of objective blood examinations are not favorable to Oertel's theory. The fundamental question is not, however, touched by this result, for it is immaterial what becomes of the water, i. e., whether it remain in the blood vessels, causing plethora and hydraemia, or whether it diffuses into the tissues or is excreted through the lungs, the skin or the kidneys; the fact remains that the daily task imposed upon the heart is greater if much water is ingested than if small quantities only are taken. All the water that enters the stomach must pass through the heart and arteries before it reaches the emunctories of the body. Even if the quantity of water that enters the blood at any one time is too small to be estimated by our means of measurement, we know nevertheless that the surplus water must circulate several times through the heart and the arterial tree before it can be eliminated from the blood. No one will, therefore, seriously argue that the total labor performed by the heart is not greater if large quantities of water are ingested than if the amount of water drinking is restricted to a minimum - this even when hydrostatic equilibrium is fully maintained and the average concentration of the blood remains normal.

Moreover, all objections (based on blood examinations) to the contrary notwithstanding, the validity of Oertel's claims has been fully borne out by practical experience: restriction of fluids signifies sparing the heart. We consider Oertel's procedure to be a therapeutic achievement of the first rank. If, recently, several writers have again formulated objections against the method that are based upon blood examinations alone, and if these authors declare the restriction of liquids to be useless, then this merely shows how dangerous and how short-sighted it is to base therapeutic suggestions upon a single clinical method of examination.