The amount of water to be allowed patients with contracted kidneys is an important question to be solved. In all previous works on the subject this question has either been altogether neglected or has merely been touched, without due recognition of its great significance.

Three years ago I was the first to call attention to this subject. The main object had always been to produce free diuresis in cases of contracted kidneys; it was believed that this plan was as correct in this form of nephritis as it undoubtedly is in acute nephritis (with certain exceptions). This object was accomplished very easily, because the patients, if left to themselves would drink very much water. As a matter of fact an increase in the excretion of urine above normal was almost considered a diagnostically important sign of contracted kidneys. Free diuresis under these circumstances was usually favored by giving large quantities of milk and mineral waters. It was by no means rare to find a daily excretion of from 3 to 4 liters of urine. The consumption of large quantities of fluid seemed to be justified, and was carried out willingly by the patients, because together with the increased diuresis the percentage of albumin in the urine usually decreased. The reputation that many watering places enjoy in the treatment of contracted kidney is due to this factor. As a rule increased diuresis in contracted kidney following the consumption of much mineral water causes nothing more than a dilution of the urine. The percentage of albumin becomes lower, whereas the absolute total quantity excreted during the day remains the same, or may even increase. There are cases of course in which the increase of the urinary excretion diminishes not only the percentage but also the absolute quantity of albumin excreted.

It is questionable, however, whether these slight and inconstant fluctuations in the degree of albuminuria are very important, and whether they are not insignificant as compared with certain other factors that may act detrimentally. The flooding of the vascular system with water over-taxes the heart to an extraordinary degree, and ultimately damages the organ. The water that is absorbed from the intestine can only be excreted by the kidneys if the blood pressure is increased. It is difficult to demonstrate directly that the heart actually is damaged by excessive water drinking; but indirectly this can be shown, for many cases of weak heart are on record that give a history of having indulged in abundant water drinking for long periods of time. In cases of this kind improvement may frequently be witnessed if the amount of water is limited. Three years ago I was able to report favorable results from this method of treatment; since that time I have had more experience with this subject, and I can testify to the fact that even in cases of dilatation of the heart, or in patients suffering from occasional stenocardiac attacks, the restriction of water may lead to marked improvement. This improvement is not only transitory but is permanent, as shown by the following two case reports. I quote these reports from the Proceedings of the Congress of 1899. The two patients are alive today, and are enjoying good health, notwithstanding the fact that both of them (particularly the first one) suffered attacks of cardiac insufficiency many years ago. I need hardly mention that this complication is ordinarily considered a very bad prognostic sign in contracted kidney.

One of the earliest cases I observed occurred in a gentleman who is now (that is, in 1901) forty-seven years old. This patient consulted me three and a half years ago (in the summer of 1898). He was positive at the time that he had been suffering from kidney trouble for at least five years; up to three months before this time no serious symptoms had appeared. For a few months he had been suffering from dyspnoea and painful sensations of pressure in the region of the heart. These symptoms had been increasing so that within the last few weeks he had experienced a feeling of severe nocturnal oppression that caused him to awaken every few nights and forced him to stay out of bed for hours at a time. In two cases these attacks were accompanied by vomiting and bloody expectoration. On examination I found among other things that the left heart was considerably dilated, extending beyond the anterior axillary line; in addition I wish to call particular attention to this sign - there was retinitis albuminurica. He had been accustomed to take between three and a half and four liters of water a day, an amount that had been prescribed by his physician. This amount was contained in one and a half liters of milk, and about five-fourths of a liter of mineral water; I may add that he was in the habit of alternating Fachinger and Neuenahr Waters. The only prescription that I gave him was to limit the amount of fluid to five-fourths of a liter a day; at the time I allowed the patient to determine how much of this fluid was to consist of milk, water, soup and fruit syrups; I even permitted him occasionally to take a small glass of light wine or of beer. The result of this treatment was that the attacks of cardiac asthma ceased in the course of a few days and they have never reappeared to this day, although the patient is leading a very active life, and is the head of a large industrial establishment. To this day he conscientiously follows my prescriptions, and has never suffered from stenocardiac attacks since. I may mention as a curiosity that this patient, while suffering from some mild digestive disorder on a trip was assured by the physician who took charge of his case that he would kill himself in a short time unless he immediately resumed his milk diet. I saw this patient about half a year ago for the last time and found the apex of the heart two fingers further towards the median line than three years before. I also failed to find anything of the former retinitis; albuminuria of course continued as before.