The second case was a gentleman of fifty, who was sent to me from England with the positive diagnosis of contracted kidney, and who came to take a bathing and water cure at Neuenahr. From the history of the case and from the very careful report of his physician it appeared that the patient had never developed any signs of cardiac weakness, nor any considerable degree of cardiac dilatation up to the time he left home. In Neuenahr this gentleman, who was rather corpulent, led a very quiet uniform life, drank much milk, and very much of the water; it may be imagined how much he took when I mention that he occasionally passed nearly four liters of urine. The urine had been frequently analyzed in Neuenahr, and the physician had determined with much pleasure that the percentage of albumin had decreased greatly (naturally, for the urine was very di lute), but no attention was paid to the heart. When this gentleman returned after his course in Neuenahr I examined him again, and found that both ventricles were greatly dilated, that the pulse was rapid and weak, and that the patient developed dyspnoea on the slightest exertion. This distension of the heart had apparently developed in the course of a few weeks. The heart resumed its normal boundaries, decreasing in dimension from day to day, within two weeks, as soon namely as I changed the treatment and forbade excessive water drinking, even restricting the amount of fluid.

A third case is mentioned in the first pages of this monograph. These examples may suffice; in the meantime observations of this character have multiplied and I feel justified in saying that in many cases of contracted kidney (as in cases of cardiac disease) sensible restriction of water may save life.

Naturally we must not wait until the cardiac strength has become impaired. However good and apparent the results in many cases of advanced disease may be, the most important part of therapy is after all intelligent prophylaxis; and I should like to recommend (in connection with other measures directed toward shielding and exercising the heart muscle the plan of accustoming patients with atrophic nephritis to restrict the ingestion of fluids, even with the heart is still perfectly strong.

According to my experience it is well to limit the quantity of fluid to one and a quarter liters both in the earlier and in the later stages of the disease - this amount to include everything taken in liquid form. It is my custom to ignore the water contained in the solid food; with an average diet it measures about 500 to 700 c.cm. If the ingestion of fluid is restricted to this extent about 1,300 to 1,500 c.cm. of urine are excreted daily.

I may conclude this portion of my essay by calling attention to the fact that it is often difficult in practise to limit the fluids to only one and a quarter to one and a half liters. This regulation is much more difficult to enforce in cases of atrophic nephritis than in cases of cardiac disease and in obese patients. Patients with contracted kidney suffer much more from thirst than the latter class of patients; and it is moreover far more troublesome to insure the ingestion of sufficient quantities of other nourishment when the amount of fluid is kept relatively small.

The difficulty of treating many of these patients at home is often so great that I have been forced to admit them to the hospital or private clinic for one to three weeks; or else to send them to sanitoria which follow a course of treatment similar to mine. A large number were admitted into the sanitarium of Dr. Dapper of Kissingen, and his experience with the method of restricting the fluids has been as satisfactory as my own. Naturally the difficulties are much more readily overcome in an institution than they can be at home.

In several of the cases undergoing hospital treatment metabolic experiments were made for the purpose of determining, at least approximately, whether the limitation of water did not impair the elimination of urinary substances (see below).

After the first obstacles have been overcome the further restriction of fluids is not especially difficult. After two to four weeks thirst is no longer complained of. It only returns to a marked degree after the disease has progressed further, after incurable cardiac weakness has finally appeared in spite of the restriction of fluids, or at the onset of the terminal stages of uraemia. In these stages of the disease, in which hope is no longer possible, there can be no object in torturing the patients by limiting the amount of fluid.

Although in all therapeutic questions experience and bedside observation are most conclusive, I may nevertheless be permitted to add the results of some clinical experiments. The point to be decided more especially was how far, in atrophic nephritis, the elimination of excretory substances is dependent upon the ingestion of water. If it were found that urea, uric acid and urates were less completely excreted when small quantities of water were being ingested than when the kidneys were being flushed, this fact would have to serve as a warning, for the accumulation of urinary products in the body must in no way be encouraged. As a matter of fact the custom of prescribing large quantities of milk and water for these patients and sending them to well-known watering places for systematic drinking cures, originates in the assumption that abundant drinking facilitates the elimination of metabolic products of all kinds. I have carried out numerous lines of investigation on this subject. The first of these clinical experiments date back some time and were made in connection with certain metabolic investigations on nephritis that I published eleven years ago together with Ad. Ritter of Carlsbad. Later they were continued partly by myself and partly by my pupils, Dr. Dapper of Kissingen and Mr. von Rzetkowski of Warsaw, and finally, in a more elaborate form, by my assistant, Dr. L. Mohr, who will collect and publish all the material in the near future. We found that a restriction of the fluid did not, as a rule, diminish the elimination of the solid urinary constituents. Where this did occur transiently (in only one case), the accumulated excretory material was easily removed from the body by allowing the free ingestion of fluids for one day in the week. I should like to advise this expedient in practise, viz., to permit the patient to drink as much water as he chooses on one day of each week. I also follow this custom in patients with cardiac disease, unless they happen to be in the stage of failing compensation, and allow them to drink water freely on one day of every week; I think that this plan has worked well both in cardiac and in nephritic patients. Furthermore it is important, according to the results of our observations, that the quantity of fluid should not be suddenly diminished to the minimum of one and a quarter liters, especially if it was previously large. I always determine during one or two days how much fluid the patient voluntarily takes, then I gradually diminish the amount by with drawing about 150 to 250 c.cm. a day until the quantity is reached at which I mean to keep the patient.

Just as the occasional insertion of a "drinking day" may be welcome and useful, so in the long continued course of atrophic nephritis "drinking cures" may occasionally be useful; and there is no objection to their being taken in places with natural springs producing suitable mineral waters. As a rule I go further, and in many cases prescribe a "flushing-out cure" at home once in two or three months, using two or three liters of fluid per day for about fourteen days. Such transient drinking cures do no harm, at least not in the early stages of atrophic nephritis; they differ essentially from continued flooding of the circulatory system; but the cases must be carefully selected. When appreciable dilatation of the left heart is present I should advise against the use of the drinking cure under any circumstances; damage may often be wrought that can later only be overcome with difficulty, or not at all. Among patients who have not yet developed cardiac weakness there are many who, as soon as they become accustomed to the restriction of fluids, are loud in their praises of this method; they feel markedly improved; but as soon as they resume abundant water drinking even for a short time they complain of all kinds of mild symptoms, such as headache, fullness, heaviness of the limbs, drowsiness, and feelings of oppression.

The same question that I have asked myself will undoubtedly be raised by others, viz. : whether the restriction of fluid is permissible and useful in those not infrequent cases, in which atrophic nephritis is combined with gout or the uric acid diathesis (gravel). In these diseases free water drinking and flushing of the tissues as well as dilution of the urine serve as important therapeutic measures. Extended clinical experience alone can answer this query. In cases of atropic nephritis complicated with true gout (arthritis urica) I have for many years employed the same measures as in cases without gout. In no instance have I witnessed any bad results such as more frequent and more severe attacks of gout, or increase of the tophi. On the other hand, several of the gouty and nephritic patients whose heart had become weakened, improved markedly and permanently when the use of water was restricted. Consequently I see no objection to my method even in those cases of atrophic nephritis that are complicated with gout. The method seemed to me to be less promising in patients inclined to lithiasis. In such cases the insertion of a "drinking day" and of a "drinking week" every two months was tried. The patient was further advised to drink 200 c.cm. of hot water containing alternately every month from three to five g. of uricedin, or one g. of urotropin, or three to four g. of a mixture of sodium carbonate, calcaria carbonica and lithium carbonate, in suspension, every morning; in some cases the same dose was repeated every evening at bedtime. By the use of these precautions my patients never suffered any harmful effects nor any exacerbation of the uric acid diathesis as a result of the restriction of the fluids.

As patients with atrophic nephritis who are suffering at the same time from gout or the uric acid diathesis are especially liable to disease of the blood vessels and cardiac weakness, I advise against depriving them of the advantages accruing to the circulatory organs from the restriction of water.