This section is from the book "Part. 2. Nephritis. Clinical Treatises On the Pathology and Therapy of Disorders of Metabolism and Nutrition", by Prof. Carl von Noorden. Also available from Amazon: Clinical treatises on the pathology and therapy of disorders of metabolism and nutrition Volume pt. 2.
Heretofore only those substances have been discussed that are known to have a harmful effect upon patients with contracted kidneys, or that at least are, more or less correctly, believed to do harm. We will now enter into a discussion of the dietetic treatment proper.
First of all I should like to repeat the statement frequently made in this treatise, that in consideration of the extraordinarily long duration of the disease and the natural craving for variety in diet, not as much, but as little, as possible should be forbidden the patients.
I mean that qualitatively speaking we should be satisfied to prohibit the above named irritants and spices, or to restrict their use. This rule should be supplemented by a warning against the regular use of strong meat broths and extracts, because the extractives contained in them are irritating to the heart and perhaps also to the kidneys, when taken in concentrated form. In the same way nephritic patients are to be warned more than healthy persons, against the use of spoiled food stuffs (especially meats, so called "hautgout meat"). Among the symptoms which appear after poisoning with meat or sausage, mild kidney irritation is not rarely met with (albumin and blood in the urine); if from the outset the kidneys are a locus minoris resistentiae, the danger of acute kidney irritation from the toxines of decaying food is naturally greater.
Aside from these precautions, the choice of food should not be further limited. I know that I am expressing views that are in many ways opposed to the teachings of ordinary practise. For, as has been previously stated, many physicians still cling to the practise of supplying patients suffering from atrophic nephritis with the necessary amount of albumin in the form of milk-proteids, and where this cannot be strictly adhered to or carried out the patient is usually restricted to the use of white meats (fish, veal, white fowl, fresh pork and usually also calves' brains, calves' feet and calves' thymus).
I have arrived at the conclusion, not theoretically and not from a spirit of contradiction, but from actual observation in practise, that the above mentioned rule in the treatment of patients with atrophic nephritis must be given up. This view is in no sense new; it has been frequently advanced by others in hand- and textbooks on kidney diseases (see the review of the literature of Offer-Rosenqvist and L. Mohr); but it is important to emphasize it anew, because it has not sufficiently influenced physicians in their actual practise, and because most of the patients with atrophic nephritis, whether in the early or late stages of the disease, whether young or old, man or woman, rich or poor, carry about in their pockets the same routine prescription: eat only white meat. As a matter of fact this direction does an extraordinary amount of harm, because patients who really carry it out and avoid dark meat as they would poison - and their number is by no means small - in time develop such an aversion to white meat that they reduce the consumption of all meat to a minimum. As eggs are also as a rule forbidden or decidedly restricted, and as very few people can take large quantities of milk for any length of time, and since finally the patients are not sufficiently instructed as to the choice of vegetables that they can and should eat in order to substitute animal proteins, the prohibition of dark meat leads, in many cases, to the long continued adoption of a diet that is very poor in proteins.
In the course of the last two years I have studied several patients with contracted kidneys, who by the order of their physician had eaten no dark meat at all for some time (at least for several months). For two successive days, while continuing their regular diet, i.e., before making any dietetic changes, I had the total twenty-four hours' urine collected in order to determine the amount of proteid metabolism. Only in one case did the excretion of nitrogen for the twenty-four hours exceed 10 g.; as a rule it remained decidedly below this amount. The separate values were as follows:
FIRST | DAY | SECOND | DAY | |
7.2 g. | N. | 7.8 | g. | N. |
6.8 " | " | 8.2 | " | " |
9.1 " | " | 7.1 | " | " |
9.8 " | " | 7.6 | " | " |
10.0 " | " | 6.9 | " | " |
9.0 " | " | 7.7 | " | " |
6.5 " | " | 6.8 | " | " |
9.8 " | " | 9.4 | " | " |
8.7 " | " | 8.1 | " | " |
8.6 " | " | 6.8 | " | " |
7.9 " | " | 6.7 | " | " |
10.8 " | " | 9.9 | " | " |
As is well known, the statement has frequently been made of late that the normal daily amount of proteids, which C. v. Voit placed at 118 g. (calculated for 70 kg. of body weight), is much too high. Some ten years ago it was said that 20 per cent, might be deducted from Voit's proteid figures, without causing permanent injury to a healthy organism; nowadays it is even claimed that 40 per cent, and more can be deducted. I should be very sorry if this view, which tends to vegetarianism, were to gain ground, for it would be reactionary. As far as healthy persons are concerned, I will not enter further into this question. In sick people I have never seen any benefits accrue from the long continued restriction of proteids; on the contrary, I have frequently noticed very harmful effects during the fifteen years I have been studying this question. I should like to formulate the rule that N-metabolism, measured by the excretion of urinary nitrogen, may be transiently (that is, for days or weeks), but never permanently, lowered below 12 g. (calculated for 70 kg. of body weight). This necessitates the ingestion of about 85 g. of proteids (mixed diet), after deducting the loss through the faeces. I regard this amount as the extreme lower limit, and it is better to remain above than below it. In the nephritic patients reported upon in the above table, the ingestion of proteids was estimated at from 50 to 70 g. a day.
That a very low proteid diet prolonged for months or for years exercises a harmful influence upon nephritic patients is shown by the fact that these patients, who are weak and delicate, are easily tired and incapable of performing any real muscular work. As soon as they are given a greater variety of food and poteids with the free use of dark meats they recover rapidly. I emphasized the success of this method of treatment in badly nourished nephritic patients some years ago (at the Carlsbad Congree for Internal Medicine), and, after a larger experience I can fully confirm what was said at that time.
It is true of course that theoretically an appropriate and ample diet can be readily arranged without including dark meat; practically, however, the matter is not so simple. In view of these difficulties and the objectionable features they give rise to, the question arises whether or not dark meat as opposed to white is really so harmful in nephritis as practitioners in general seem to assume. The objections to dark meat are based on the supposition that it contains considerably more of the nitrogenous extractives that are injurious to the kidneys. How unfounded this supposition is and how little it is supported by chemical analysis, is shown by the observations made and published by Th. Offer and Rosenquist at my request. In numerous analyses, the nitrogenous extractives were sometimes found to be more abundant in dark, and sometimes in white meat. Greater differences were found in the same class of animals and between several samples from the group of white meat on the one hand and of dark meat on the other, than between the average amount contained in white and dark meat. Certain kinds of white meat (poultry, hare) were even found to be richer in extractives, on an average, than beef.
Any differences that may be found in rare meats may disappear completely after the meat has been prepared in the kitchen. Meat, that may have been relatively rich in nitrogenous extractives in the raw state, will as a rule contain less of the extractives after boiling than meat that may have been relatively poor in such substances after roasting. Since nephritis patients should not eat large quantities of meat in any case, and since in the course of preparation a large part of the easily soluble extractives are lost, it makes a difference of only a fraction of a decigramme (calculated per day) whether meat relatively rich or comparatively poor in extractives is given.
Senator tried to raise objections to the methods employed by Offer and Rosenquist, but his objections have been refuted by these two authors in a second monograph that they have published.
I have tried in still another way to determine what effect different kinds of meat exercise on the function of the kidney. My two assistants, Kaufmann and Mohr studied the elimination of urinary substances after the ingestion of equivalent portions of white and of dark meat. They attempted to determine whether the ingestion of dark meat interfered with the excretory powers of diseased kidneys, and whether it increased albuminuria. In one series of experiments they found that white meats, in another that dark meats gave better results. No definite conclusions could be drawn from these very difficult investigations; the results were certainly ambiguous. Another author has recently communicated some experiments that may be utilized in determining this question. A. Pick namely, found that the intensity of the albuminuria is not to any great extent dependent on the form in which the proteid is eaten.
It appears to me that clinical experience is much more important than all the investigations that at best extend over very short periods of time. I have been studying numerous cases of nephritis for many years, and I have found that there can be no reasonable objection to the administration of dark meat to patients with contracted kidney. I have also found that it is much easier to feed these patients in a rational manner and to raise their general strength if the diet can be selected so as to include dark meats. It is certainly much easier to feed these patients correctly by allowing them this latitude than by telling them that white meat is non-injurious and dark meat is injurious. A statement of this kind is based on false premises in the first place, and in addition does not take into consideration the actual practical conditions of every day life, nor the comfort of the patients.
 
Continue to: