"False accusations of medical men and hypnotists for sexual misdeeds are much more frequent than proved real immoral acts on hypnotized persona. Even in the case of actual seduction, the excuse that they were the victims of a suggestive impulse is not uncommon. Altogether, false accusations of immoral offenses are very common.

"The assistant medical officer of a large Munich hospital hypnotized the thirteen-year-old Magdalena S. for medical purposes in his room without any witnesses, and was thoughtless enough to pass urine in the presence of the hypnotized girl during the time when she was asleep. Shortly after this occurrence he was charged by the Public Prosecutor with having put his genital organ into the mouth of the hypnotized child, and having micturated into her mouth. The accusation depended on the statement of the thirteen-year-old child. On being asked to give my opinion on this case, I soon came to the conclusion, after a careful examination of the facts, and on examining the child, that the matter dealt with a dreamy, illusionary warping of conceptions during the hypnotic condition; this took place in connection with the passing of the urine. The retroactive pseudo-reminiscences had been exaggerated in the waking condition by imagination and by discussing the matter with her relatives. And thus the simple product of false autosuggestive interpretation of conceptions in hypnosis and of reactive falsification of memory became the basis of a heavy charge, which threatened to ruin the whole future of our colleague. The result of my report, as I have already said, was that the charge was withdrawn."

Von Schrenck continues: "Opinions and judgments which we read unconsciously infiltrate our thinking, govern the direction of our ideas, and have a powerful influence over the molding of our memory. A confusion of what has been personally experienced and of that which has been heard or read takes place all the more easily if the contents of the subject in question had previously absorbed our interest. The truth of reproduction suffers when there is a want of critical deliberation, when there is a lively imagination, and also at times when psychical excitement (emotions) or tiredness are present. If the elements of a momentary situation are carried over to the impressions of memory the situation may be easily falsified in the sense of a new perception (cf. the influence of the appearance of Berchthold's photograph on the remembrance of the suspicious visitor). These external stimulations may exercise a suggestive influence, and may offer a suitable site for sources of error in our memory. A complete picture can be made up of fancy and truth in this way, as it was with several of the witnesses in the Berchthold trial, without it being possible for the psychological expert always to detect the correct cause for the individual portions of the impression of memory.

" One must therefore regard it as an error in judicial examination if the details of the remembrances in the evidence of witnesses are too much overrated. Altogether, the sources of error of memory receive much too little attention in the court of law. An intimate knowledge of them would protect the judge from falling into the dangerous mistake of confusing perjury and falsification of memory. He would thus be capable of distinguishing more easily the nucleus of truth from the product of suggestion. Apart from this, he would impose greater reserve in hearing of witnesses, so that no details in the evidence would be suggested to them. A careful estimation of the doctrine of suggestion would cause the organizations for the safety of the public to limit the influence of the press on criminality, which is still greatly undervalued.

"The judging of the conditions in foro becomes difficult if, as in the Sauter case, the intellectual originator (in this case the fortune-teller, Frau Gaenzbauer) has absolutely no conception of the lawlessness of her actions, and of having committed a crime. We are therefore dealing with unintentional, unnoticed influencing. For Frau Gaenzbauer was obviously not cognizant that she had excited in Frau Sauter the trend of ideas aiming at the removal of her husband and of other persons by her superstitious humbug. She was completely ignorant that on the occasion of the demonstration before the hidden detectives she had, so to say, dictated the whole murder plan to her victim, and that she conducted the whole conversation in this way, according to the procedure agreed to by the police. The court of justice is not in a position, under these circumstances, to punish either the originator or the person who has carried out the deed, since it is impossible to prove a criminal intention.

"There is scarcely a sphere of human error which offers such a favorable basis for the development of suggestive action as does superstition. This always presents itself, as Loewen-stimm has so ably described, as a product of the ignorance and undeveloped condition of whole classes of people, and leads not infrequently to the committing of extraordinarily cruel crimes."

The results of von Schrenck's account are summarized as follows:

"1.Crimes committed on hypnotized persons and those committed with the help of hypnotized persons (posthypnosis) are almost entirely limited -

"(a) To sexual misdeeds (e.g., Czynski case, 1894).

"(b) To the dangerous abuse of hypnotized persons (public shows, the exhibition of the mysterious).

"2. Suggestion in waking condition possesses a medico-forensic importance, which has hitherto not been realized in its full extent. For -

"(a) It is capable of causing persons who are mentally perfectly normal to give false bond fide sworn evidence (e.g., the eighteen false witnesses in the Berchthold trial, 1896; influence of the press; psychical epidemics).

"(b) It can impel persons who are specially susceptible to suggestive influence to commit criminal acts (Sauter case, 1899).

"3. Generally speaking, criminal suggestions are not dangerous for normal individuals with well-developed moral resistance, but, on the other hand, the following fall an easy prey to it: childish, psychopathically inferior, hysterical, psychically weak, ethically defective individuals, in whom the possibility of resistance is diminished by a feeble cultivation of the moral balance."

I am in full agreement with von Schrenck-Notzing that legal measures are required against unauthorized hypnotizing by non-medical persons. A person who is particularly gifted in hypnotizing might be allowed to hypnotize for scientific or therapeutic purposes under the supervision and responsibility of a medical practitioner.

But the mischief that is done by hypnotism by careless or greedy persons under the name of spiritualism, telepathy, clairvoyance, fortune-telling, and the like, as well as for fun and for show, is increasing into dangerous dimensions. One ought not to be allowed to interfere at will with one's neighbor's brain, any more than with the rest of his body or with his money. Unfortunately, one gives the laity a perfectly free hand, and is always prepared to blame the medical man.

As a matter of fact, the harm done by, and the crimes which are ascribed to, suggestion are mostly the work of the laity, and especially of the spiritualists. These persons do not realize that they work with the brain of their usually hysterical mediums, and impose things on these latter which in time do grave damage to health, even when deceit and assaults are not coupled with it. Regular epidemics of hysterical attacks, autohypnoses, and the like, have been produced in this way. The laity fails to understand how to avoid autosuggestions and how to remove them.

It is not my duty to make suggestions for laws. But we must insist that more attention be paid to this subject in the future than has been paid in the past, and that at least a medical supervision be introduced.