"Whether one believes that Berchthold was guilty or innocent, the trial indisputably showed up the fact that part of the evidence of witnesses was inspired by the newspapers. In what other way can one explain, e.g., the curious circumstance that, during the fourteen days' proceedings, not less than seven persons surrendered themselves with the statement that they had committed the murder of the Roos family? Among the two hundred and ten witnesses called there were eighteen whose evidence could be referred to the influence of the newspaper notices. One of these, for example, stated ' he had noticed the accused in the neighborhood of the house in which the deed had been committed (a house in Karl Street) three times at a certain hour on a Friday afternoon, and had recognized him again at once, after the publication of the photograph.' But the fact that the same witness had been present at a trial in the courts at the hour mentioned on that particular Friday contradicted the evidence, which was given on oath. As he could not have been in two places at one time, the value of his evidence could be judged from this. Six other witnesses - all female householders of the town of Munich - stated on their oath independently that they had been visited by a suspicious-looking man, who had attempted to gain admission on the pretext of having to do something to the arrangements of the water-closets. They only recognized the suspicious person as the accused Berchthold when his photograph had been published. More than this, one of the papers represented Berchthold wearing some clothes which he had never worn. One of the witnesses said that she noticed these clothes on the suspicious person, although they were only in Berchthold's possession in the imagination of the artist, and not in reality.

" In short, the result of this proceeding, which is so very interesting for the doctrine of suggestion, teaches that the authorities still lack a proper knowledge of the suggestive factor in law cases; that the number of persons who give evidence on oath in good faith untruthfully and inexactly is much greater than one usually supposes. Above all, it has brought new proof of the suggestive power of the press."

"On October 2, 1899, the wife of the butcher Sauter was charged before the Upper Bavarian Criminal Court in Munich with attempted murder, and with inciting to murder nine persons.

"German law punishes attempts and incitations to crime, even if they are undertaken with inefficacious means. The prisoner was accused of having attempted to kill her husband, with whom she had lived unhappily, by strewing gentian root into his socks. This, in her opinion, was supposed to be a means of killing; it had been advised to her by a fortune-teller. Apart from this, she was charged with having incited the fortune-teller to kill by magic means nine persons who stood in her way, among whom were three of her children, two former servants, etc.

"The prisoner was at her menopause, suffered considerably from pelvic troubles, and showed marked signs of hysteria. Being extremely superstitious, she regarded the fortune-teller, whom she consulted on every important occasion, as a person endowed with supernatural capabilities and with the power of determining the fate of persons and of life and death. The fortune-teller, on the other hand, stimulated the imagination of Frau Sauter by all sorts of humbug, and was able to profit materially, and systematically to fleece her victim. This fortune-teller, it was proved, had been convicted twenty-one times previously for serious offenses. The court had no doubt that the fortune-teller was really the guilty party. She had been able, by her swindling, to convince the credulous prisoner, who had fallen entirely under her influence, that it was very easy to cause all persons who stood in her way to die a natural death, and it was she who had in this way first suggested to her the whole plan of the murder, albeit unintentionally. As these ideas took hold of the prisoner, the prophetess informed against her victim to the police, and induced Mrs. Sauter to discuss the whole murder plan once more, and to make up a list of the people whom she had determined to remove, so that the detectives, who were hiding in the adjoining room, could hear it all, and could appear as the principal witnesses for the prosecution.

"While the reports of Messerer and Focke came to the con-elusion that Frau Sauter was in possession of the exercise of her freewill at the time of the deed ascribed to her, the report which I gave led to the proof that the accused, fascinated by the fortune-teller, had carried out the ideas of the latter while in a condition of suggestive dependence; that her responsibility had been materially diminished as a result of hysteria, as a result of her menopause, and as a result of superstitious conceptions.

"The jury acquitted the prisoner on both charges.

"The Sauter case represents the first acquittal of an accused person who had committed a breach of the law under the suggestive influence of another person, and is therefore of principal and lasting importance for the doctrine of the relationship of suggestion to criminal law."

"About seven years ago a five-year-old girl was placed under my treatment. This child suffered from 'destructiveness,' which extended itself in the most cunning way to the most valuable possessions of the family. The parents never succeeded in catching the child red-handed. The deeds always took place when their backs wore turned or when they were absent. Once the child was found in flames in bed. The numerous frequently repeated thefts and destructions, which were carried out in a very cunning manner, caused the parents considerable material losses. Educational influencing and punishments failed to improve matters. The child cried, and confessed fresh misdeeds. At last the child was chained up and treated hypnotically, but the criminal deeds nevertheless continued. After nine months an accidental circumstance disclosed the truth. The child went into the country with her parents, while her nurse stayed in town. From this moment the destructions ceased. It was now discovered that the child was absolutely innocent, but that the hysterical nurse had committed the deeds, or had caused them to be carried out. She knew how to continuously suggest the consciousness of guilt to the child placed under her care in such a way that the latter had stood all the punishments for nine months without a murmur, and repeated the confessions, which had been suggestively dictated to her, without ever betraying her tyrant."