Following up our definition of consciousness as the subjective side of concentrated cerebral activities, we find that it is the latter which contains the power of reasoning. But this must not be accepted in the sense of Hartmann's "clairvoyant uncon-ceived," which this philosopher believed that he could detect in instinct. Instinct is a secondary automatic product, or, as Darwin, Delboeuf, and others have expressed it, a crystallized, fixed intelligence. The plastic power of modification, with its concentration and its laborious combining work of adaptation and revival, comes first. It is this power of modification which accommodates itself as a plastic capability of reaction of the nervous system adequately and with increasing complicated-ness (more reasonably) to the world and the nervous functions of other beings. Instinct is phylogentically a crystallized product of the plastic nerve work, which is automatically intimately adapted to a given complex of energy which is fixed, and which, taken as a whole, cannot be further adapted. Habit is that mechanism of the individual central nervous system by means of which an automatizing and organizing of the plastic activity of the brain takes place with increasing loss of plasticity. This occurs with the help of memory and of repetition of similar reactions of the said plastic activity of the brain. The instincts are (probably by means of the suitable natural selection of engrains, which have, in the course of generations, gradually been inherited, accumulated, and later ecphorized) further developed automatisms gradually fixed by the law of inheritance. That a human being at his birth scarcely possesses any complete instincts, but only unalterable (walking, speaking) or alterable inherited dispositions, is explainable by the fact that at birth the brain is still quite embryonic, and the nerve fibers in parts have not yet got their medullary sheaths. Those inherited dispositions which are unavoidably realized later in every normal individual should be placed on the same level as the instincts. Just as a reasoning conscious human being possesses his habits and instincts, an insect possesses, besides its extraordinary fixed and complicated instincts, its meager, weak, plastic reasoning power, which always shows itself in its full poverty when one experimentally places unfor-seen obstacles, such as do not exist elsewhere in Nature, in the way of the sequence of actions of the instinct. I have carried out a series of such experiments.1 Fabre,2 who was misled by the great chasm lying between the seeming intelligence of the instinct and the boundless weakness of the plastic reasoning reaction of insects, fell into the error of denying the latter, although a careful reader can himself diagnose them from the magnificent observations of this author. In his last essays he does, however, at last withdraw this, and allows a discernment in insects. Memory, perception, association of remembrances, and simple conclusions arising from these, have been incon-testably proved to exist by me,3 by Wasmann, and by Buttel Reepen.

1 For furthei particulars I refer the reader to my lecture on "Brain and Mind," delivered at the Viennese "Naturforscherversammlung," and published by E. Strauss, in Bonn (6th edition, 1899).

All the logical conclusions which our brain activity forms below the level of the reflection of our chief consciousness are what we call intuition, instinctive reasoning and the like. These conclusions are more rapid and safer than those which we are conscious of, but they can go astray and err, especially when they come into contact with an unknown territory. We must regard pure central (abstract ideas, emotion) and coordinating activities of the brain as well as those activities which are bound by centripetal elements (perceptions) or by centrifugal elements (impulses) as conclusions of this kind or associations of an intuitive nature. For example, we form many more abstract ideas below the level of our superconsciousness than we imagine. To repeat, it is not permissible to place unconccived and conceived activities in contradistinction. One may only compare the actual plastic activity of reason or the power of adaptation, which is usually superconceived, with the more or less fixed automatic, crystallized intelligence which one calls instinct, and which is for the most part hypoconceived; but even this comparison may only be relative - i.e., gradual.

1 Loc. cit.

2"Souvenir Entomologiques."

A psychologically interesting instance of the phenomenon of consciousness is met with in conceived and unconceived deception. Let us take the case of John Smith A., who impersonates Lord X. for the purpose of obtaining a sum of money, and of John Smith B., who through a delusion believes that he is Lord X. What is it that is conceived by A. and unconceived by B. ? It is simply the difference ratio between two chains of association - firstly, the chain of association of the really experienced self-personality; and secondly that of the representation about Lord X. The sharper this difference ratio of the two dynamic association chains is marked, the sharper will be, as a rule, the reflection of consciousness, and the less often will confusion between reality and imagination be met with.

But it is clear that the attempt on the part of John Smith A. to falsely create in the mind of others the impression that both representation chains are identical must produce in his own brain an intensely associated work of both representation chains which aspires toward rendering them relatively identical. If John Smith A. possesses a strongly marked imagination, this identification will prove easy for him, and the working of the difference ratio will be weakened, for well-marked impressions of the senses and accentuations of feelings will increase the likeness and blot out the differences. The deception will become at the same time naturally better and more unconscious, but may perhaps fail through carelessness. If he possesses a very critical, objective, speculative mind, on the contrary, the difference ratio of both chains will be very sharply accentuated, and thereby the identification of these rendered more difficult. The deception in this case will be less natural, less skilled, and more conscious; but it may he better cloaked by great precaution. But other combinations could lead to similar results. For example, imagination and criticism could exist simultaneously, and the latter would correct the deception. On the other hand, the want of ethical conceptions and impulses can increase the becoming accustomed to the lie. This would gradually weaken the referred to ratio of difference. Or an exaggerated superficiality and want of criticism could lead to the same results without the assistance of a particularly well-developed imagination. There are people in whose brains only very indistinct and weak difference ratios exist between that which is imagined and that which has actually taken place. This might not be due to the want or excess of any one special characteristic When the difference ratio is apparently absent - or, at least, not recognized - this may be due to a want of the association of both chains of activity or of the illumination of consciousness of the same. The one is illuminated by the super-consciousness, while the other is illuminated by the hypocon-sciousness. We can observe this especially well in dreams and in the hypnotized. One can then see that the imaginative liar and the pathological swindler take an intermediate place between the critically conscious deceiver and the madman (or the dreamer or the completely hypnotized person). One can further see why they play their parts much better than the conscious deceiver. The French call this jouer au naturel (Tartarin). But when the tendency toward a more or less complete identification of chains of imagination and chains of reality frequently occurs in the form of an inherited disposition for lying, deceiving, or even for exaggerating, one must not forget that this disposition (which exists in some degree even in the best of us) can be increased by habit or practice, or can be conquered by the reverse practice. But, above all, I wish to point out that the chief difference in the degree of the antithesis - that is, of the more or less sharp qualitative and quantitative differentiation of both chains of activity - lies in the brain, and does not depend on whether the identification or the non-identification is subjectively more or less conceived or unconceived. The stronger or weaker illumination of consciousness of the difference is actually only a result of the degree of intensity of the difference ratio itself. I would advise all who are interested in this very important and absorbing question to study Del-brueck's excellent work, "The Pathological Lie and the Psychically Abnormal Swindler" (1891).