This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
The phenomenon of introspection is only an internal reflex of that which has taken place, the exterior of which appears to us as the moving matter with its energy. No one has ever been able to separate the interior from the exterior, and no one will ever be able to do so. All attempts resolve themselves into the employment of empty words. Everyone only knows the interior in relation to himself.
Pure scientific monism (the hypothesis of identity) may, it is true, not generalize so widely as metaphysical monism, of which we have just been speaking. It is content to accept the identity of being of every psychical phenomenon, which is available for direct psychological observation, with its so-called brain-physiological correlative, and must leave the hypothesis of the "soul" to metaphysical speculation, in spite of the fact that it is inclined toward it.
1As soon as one employs the term "soul" for inanimate things, a storm of opposition is raised: "Fancies!" "Nonsense!" "Talk of world-souls!" and the like. This is due to the fact that people are kept captivated in anthropomorphism, and cannot grasp or understand, that the element of the introspective (psychical) reflex must be just as simple in relation to a human mind as an atom is in relation to a living human bruin.
It is not difficult to understand that the dispute on the questions detailed above has nothing to do with the metaphysics of religion directly. The first beginning and the ultimate aim - free evolution or fatalism - all remain just as untouched as does the question as to the being of a God. It is true that God, in personal relationship to ourselves and to the rest of Nature, as it appears to us, is not particularly easy to reconcile with the monistic interpretation. But even from other points of view the picturing of God in human form can scarcely be consistent with the conception of omnipotence.
A number of dogmata of various creeds obstruct the monistic view, in the same way as they formerly obstructed Kopernik's teaching of the solar system. These dogmata have taken up scientific questions, which are accessible to the capabilities of human knowledge, and have utilized them for their religious creeds. Their advocates cannot get over the fact that at the present day it is just these dogmata which have been disputed from the point of view of scientific knowledge. Herein lies the pith of the whole thing.
However, there is something which has furthered the scientific aspect of the question of "monism" or "dualism" enormously, and that is simply the investigation of the human and animal central nervous system and of its normal and pathological functions.
That which the former hazy doctrines regarded as immaterial human souls (somewhat as the savage regards lightning as Deus ex machina) is now incontestably proved from first to last to be the interior of the mental life. All attempts to separate a part of the "soul" as a "soul nucleus" from the mental life, as independent from the living brain substance, becomes lamentably frustrated by the observations daily becoming more exact and more numerous on the absolute inseparability of all normal as well as pathological phenomena of the mind from the integrity of its organ.
One chief difficulty, however, appeared still to remain in the obscure field of the so-called unconscious mental life. The law of Fechner-Weber cannot be brought into line. There are incompatibilities between the phenomena of consciousness and the observed and measured physiological results.
This is simply due to the fact that complicated apparatus (brain centers) lie between the physiologically measured results and those parts of the cerebrum in which our superconceived (psychical) life is enacted. The hypoconceived activity (which is unrecognized by our superconsciousness) of these apparatus can inhibit or facilitate, disturb or further. It thereby necessarily introduces an error in the results of psychophysiological measurements, which are based on Fechner's law. One must especially avoid drawing too definite conclusions from these measurements. Among others, the following reasons may be given: (1) The more marked concentration of cerebral activity, which undoubtedly corresponds to the process of attention, is accompanied by the most intense and clear consciousness; (2) undoubtedly the intensity and (3) duration of the brain activity assist in producing that part of our consciousness which is subjectively recognized by us or remembered. That this is extremely likely is shown by the fact, that known psychical measurements of time have proved how much more rapidly apparently unrecognized reactions take place than do recognized ones. (4) Everything which is unusual, everything which finds the brain activity unprepared, everything for which the said activity is not yet adapted or not yet sufficiently adapted, produces such reactions of the brain activity, which are accompanied by more marked superconsciousness. One could almost say that shock, quarrels, antagonism, plastic remodeling of the dynamics of the brain, call forth the phenomenon of superconsciousness, or render it more acute. It would thus appear that the more unstable forms of nerve activity are accompanied by reflections of superconsciousness. (5) Every action of the brain appears in the mirror of the consciousness - i.e., subjectively - as a unit, as that which philosophers called "the condition of consciousness." But a deeper study of psychology, and especially of psychophysiology, teaches us that the apparent units are extremely complicated, and are made up of components, which, albeit very widely apart as far as time and place are concerned, are yet linked together. One has only to think of what we call an observation - e.g., that of a watch - no matter whether it is caused by a hallucination or by the actual regarding of a real watch. The example of a visual observation is particularly convincing, because of that which one has learned from persons who have been born blind, and who have only gained the sense of sight later in life through the help of an operation for cataract. At first these persons have no visual perception, but only a medley of color impressions, and they take a long time before they learn to see - i.e., to perceive. They never learn this as completely as they do perception and observation by means of the other organs of special sense, and thus they continue to find their way about chiefly by feeling and sound. Even the sense, which is the simplest for us, depends, without doubt, on a large physiological complex (Hoeffding). One knows that the subjective sensation of the color white, although it seems to be single, depends on a mixture of the sensations of all colors. This can. be proved by means of a wheel, which is suitably painted all colors. If such a wheel is made to revolve increasingly fast, a point is reached when our retina can no longer differentiate the single colors, and the wheel then appears to be white. In order to study really primitive simple sensations, we should have to go back to the newborn infant (apart from the case of the congenital cataract mentioned above), and, of course, that we cannot do.
 
Continue to: