Exactly the same comparison holds good for the theory of dualism - the mind and the brain regarded as two separate things - and that of scientific monism - identity theory - which regards both as one and the same reality. Dualism can be com-pared to the theory of Ptolemy, because it leads to a deduction ad abaurdum, and because, in order to explain facts, it has to make the most unlikely mystical suppositions, which do not find support anywhere, but lead to the most glaring contradictions. On the oilier hand, with the help of the identity theory, everything can be clearly explained without contradictions, just as the movements of the stars are explained by Kopernik's theory. It is possible here, also, often to measure psychological reactions and to prognosticate, according to the quality of the brain and to the kind of stimuli and disturbances which act on it. When the psychology of the superconsciousness fails, the condition can be explained by amnesia - that is to say, by the want of connection on the part of the psychology of the super-consciousness with that of the hypoconsciousness. For these very simple reasons one must accept the identity theory as correct as long as it corresponds with facts and with its surroundings; this is not the case with dualism.

The word " identity," or psychophysiological monism, thus means that every psychological phenomenon creates with the molecular or neurokyme activity of the cortex, causing the phenomena, something which is real and tangible. This can only be regarded in two ways. From the point of view of dualism one only realizes the appearance, but from the point of view of monism it is the actual thing which one observes. If it were not so, there would be an excess of energy from the conjunction of purely psychical to bodily or cerebral factors, which excess would contradict the law of the preservation of energy. This has never been demonstrated, and would set at nought all the experiences of science. In the phenomena of our introspective or psychological mental life, which has been so exactly observed in the biology of the human race, in spite of the fact that they are extraordinary, there is absolutely nothing which contradicts natural laws, or which would justify the assumption of a mystic, supernatural, psychical complex.

For this reason I speak of monistic identity, and not of psychophysiological parallelism. A thing cannot be parallel with itself. Still, the modern psychologists only wish to express a presumptive parallelism of phenomena, and leave the question of dualism or monism undecided. Since many processes of the central nervous system are neither available for physiological nor for psychical observation, those phenomena which can be approached by both methods of investigation are not parallel; they are unevenly divided from one another by intermediate processes. Thus parallelism could only be a theoretical supposition. As the dualistic hypothesis is untenable scientifically, it is necessary to start from the identity hypothesis.

It is absolutely clear that the same action of the nervous system of an animal - let us say of ray own nervous system - must appear totally different to me if 1 observe it by means of physiological methods from without to what it would if it were reflected in my consciousness. It would be wasted energy to try to translate the physiological quality into psychical terms, or the reverse. One cannot even translate one psychical quality into another, in relation to the reality, which is depicted sen-sorily by both. An example of this is found in the vibrations of a deeply pitched tuning-fork when acting on the three senses of sound, sight, and touch. But we can accept inductively that the same fact, the same vibration, is depicted sensorily in these three ways, which are qualitatively absolutely different, or, expressed in other words, produces in us these three different impressions, which are not translatable psychically. These impressions take place in different parts of the brain, and taken as impressions, or nenrokymes of the brain, are naturally actually different from one another.

One speaks of psychophysiological identity only in relation to the cortical nenrokymes, which directly cause the known phenomena of consciousness on the one hand, and, in relation to these, phenomena of consciousness on the other hand.

Dualistically, a mind can only be conceived to be either without or with energy. If it be conceived as being free from energy - i.e., independent of the law of energy - we arrive at a condition of faith in miracles, which would interrupt natural laws at will, and throw them over. If it he conceived as containing energy, one merely is changing one word for another with the same meaning, since a mind which obeys the laws of energy is only a portion of the brain activity which has been willfully taken from its surroundings. One accredits it with mental life, but immediately after deprives it of this. Energy can only be qualitatively transformed, and not quantitatively. If it obeyed the laws of energy, a dualistically conceived mind should be capable of being completely transformed into another form of energy; but then it would no longer be dualistic: it are only realized by me, in spite of all science, by my subjective perception, and by my mode of viewing things, which depends on a combination of the various senses. This has led me to accept the existence of the outer world. The same applies to my thinking, my feeling, and my will, to a pain, a resolution, to "love," and so on. The "psychological," is a direct phenomenon in both cases, but the "physiological," or "objective," only an indirect one, which is controlled by other senses and considerations, and is, therefore, an opened-out chain of conceptions. Since the study of the brain and of psychophysiology has brought forward the proof that a direct phenomenon of consciousness does not exist, save in connection with an action of the brain, and since we can actually observe the efforts and actions of our brain in thinking, feeling, and willing, it is obvious that every purely psychological phenomenon possesses its physiological side - the movement of a material element in the brain. In one word, nothing is "psychical" without being at the same time "physical," and, if we could observe the "non-ego," we should, in all probability, find that in the same way nothing can be "physical" without being "psychical." Metaphysical monism teaches further: as there is no "matter" without "energy," and no "energy" without "matter," bo there certainly can be nothing sonlless1 (Unbeseelles) in the world.