This section is from the book "Hypnotism Or Suggestion And Psychotherapy", by August Forel, Dr. Phil. Et Jur.. Also available from Amazon: Hypnotism; Or, Suggestion and Psychotherapy.
I now come to the celebrated experimentum mirabile of Athanasius Kircher, which the keen-sighted Padre had already entitled "On the Power of Imagination of the Hen." It is true that the experiment, in which a hen was bound tightly and rendered rigid by means of a chalk line, had been carried out by Daniel Sehwenter (Numberg, 1636) before Kircher performed it. Schwenter ascribed the rigidity of the hen to fright. This has been reported by Preyer (Hypnotismus, 1890).
The physiologist, Professor Preyer, took up these experiments again in 1872-1873, according to Czermak, employing several animals, and, adopting the views of Schwenter, referred the rigidity to fright, because the animals are said to show trembling, peristalsis, panting respiration, and anemia of the head. He called this condition, therefore, cataplexy, or fright rigidity. I have never been able to reconcile myself to this Schwenter-Preyer theory of cataplexy, chiefly because tame animals, like guinea-pigs and hens, are the most easily rendered "cataplexic," without it being necessary for one to frighten them; while frightened wild animals do not fall into this condition so easily. Further - and this is of great importance - there is an unmistakable analogy between these conditions and hypnosis.
In attempting to prove cataplexy and his lactic acid theory of sleep, Preyer made the statement that there is no instance in which ordinary sleep sets in suddenly - that it always sets in gradually. This is certainly incorrect; in certain persons sleep sets in with very marked suddenness; and I can further prove to every one who will visit me that I can hypnotize a person as quickly as lightning, without allowing a trace of fright to appear, and Charcot, Liebeault, Bernheim, and others have done the same.
Professor Preyer goes on to say that he had intentionally examined animals, because they do not malinger. I am sorry to be compelled to contradict him again in this. We have not inherited simulation, together with so many other minor qualities, from our betailed ancestors in order to dispute them away now. Animals simulate very nicely; even insects know how to pretend to he dead, and do not by any means need to be rigid from fright - according to Preyer, cataplexic - for this purpose. I have watched the method of life of insects very closely, and am absolutely convinced, from innumerable small incidents, the value of which is only recognized after continuous exact biological observations, that the rigidity of insects pretending to be dead is never due to fright, which would render them incapable of moving. It certainly is due to artfulness - although this may he an instinctively automatized (organized) artfulness - which, being associated with the idea of self-preservation, is set into action when danger looms near. I may remind the reader of the cunning of mammalian animals. I might almost say that it is easier for the psychologist, at all events, to detect simulation in the majority of persons than in animals, since one can get at the matter later on by means of speech quite easily with human beings, which is impossible with animals. Apart from this, we have seen that one has to he very careful as to how one deals with the idea of malingering, and that it is foolish to suspect everybody of conscious malingering in order to jeer at us. One will be misled a hundred times by unrecognized suggestion to every one time when one is duped by conscious malingering.
Professor Danilewsky, of Charkow, 1 has carried out extensive experiments on hypnosis in animals, from the crab to the rabbit. The abnormal position in which one places the animal and the continuous mild but consistent overpowering on the part of the hypnotist are most effective in producing this condition. Danilewsky proves that fear itself is often absent, and ascribes hypnosis of animals beyond doubt to suggestion. He says that, of course, one cannot talk of verbal suggestion in these cases. But the influence on the more simple conceptions of the animal is absolutely homologous to that of suggestion. The animal understands intuitively the suggestive command, subjects to it, and becomes hypnotized. Danilewsky has determined a number of symptoms of human hypnosis in this way in animals; not only the muscular rigidity, but also, e.g., extreme anaesthesia, and so on. The hypnosis of man, says Danilewsky, has the same basis phylogenetieally as that of animals; one is dealing with the same psychophysiological mechanism, only it is much more complicated in man. The action of the fixed look of a person - e.g., on a lion - is distinctly of a suggestive nature. Danilewsky's experiments are to be published in extenso separately. I must add that all suggestive actions in animals possess a much more instinctive, more reflex character than in man, since the activity of the lower nerve centers in the former is much less governed by the activity of the cerebrum. They (animals) are much more directly under the influenee of peripheral sensory stimuli. This is not a difference in principle, but only in degree, for the cerebral activity is not different in principle from that of other nerve centers (cf. the experiments of Isidor Steiner with fishes).
1 Professor Danilcwsky, "Compte rendu du congres international de psy-chologie physiologique de Paris, seance du 9 aout," 1889, p. 79. (Pans, 1890.)
I must therefore refuse the theory of cataplexy, and ascribe, with Danilewsky, hypnosis of animals to a simplified, more automatic suggestion mechanism, which mechanism can be induced at times by means of fixation of the look and the like. In reference to this mechanism we, too, are undoubtedly automatons to a greater or smaller degree. The lethargic sleeping condition of the dormouse and several other mammalian animals is a simple physiological cataleptic condition, which is induced or introduced by the action of suggestion, phylogenetieally adapted to a definite purpose and inserted into the linkings of instinct (see O. Vogt's theory of sleep).
 
Continue to: