The Pennsylvania Railroad

The Pennsylvania Railroad is, as I have stated, an example of railway finance in its best form; but in the United States, as elsewhere, all kinds are to be found - good, bad, and indifferent. It would be too difficult a task to make even an approximate classification; but I think we may with safety put three of the railways in the first rank - namely, the Pennsylvania, the Illinois Central, and the New York Central Companies. Each of them possesses all the qualifications required to make their obligations thoroughly sound investments. There are, of course, many other well-secured American railway bonds, and while it is impossible to lay down any definite rules for selection, it will be useful to note a few of the points to be kept in view when considering the eligibility of American bonds generally.

In the first place, there is the question of margin, which in this, as in all other classes of security, is the main point to be kept in view. Are the earnings from the railway sufficient to pay the interest on all its fixed charges and leave a margin for dividends? If the bond proposed is part of a first mortgage over an important part of the railroad, and if the subsequent mortgage or mortgages are of relatively large amount, the necessity for a margin sufficient to provide substantial dividends on its ordinary capital is not so essential as in the case of bonds with little or no backing of postponed mortgages. A railroad, however, that has little margin over and above its fixed charges may have to be reconstructed, and in the reconstruction even the earlier bonds may suffer. It is well, therefore, to confine your investments to railroads which pay good dividends. In making your calculations the inquiry should not be limited to one or even two years, but should embrace a considerable period, and if possible a period of depression rather than one of good trade; for, as I have already mentioned, railroads in America are subject to great fluctuations, and some pay handsome dividends in one year and have to be reconstructed the next. For instance, the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, which some years ago was able to pay a dividend of 4 1/2 per cent on its ordinary capital, and to carry forward a surplus of $639,000, found itself unable to pay its debts and had to undergo reconstruction. It is therefore necessary to average the figure for several years if you wish to know the true position of the railroad.

In the second place, the railroad should be of sufficient magnitude to guard against the possibility of its falling into the hands of unscrupulous speculators. This has often happened in the case of small railroads, and on some occasions even of railroads of considerable importance. Having obtained the control it is easy for the clique to manipulate the accounts to suit themselves. If they wish to sell the stock they show increased profit, and if they wish to buy they show a loss. In the latter event they are not likely to go so far as to cause deficiency in the interest on the first mortgage bonds; but their action may tend to depreciate the selling price and cause serious loss to any who may be compelled to realise their holding. Now, a risk of this kind is not likely to be incurred where the railroad is of sufficient magnitude to ensure honest management. There is the additional advantage in the line being large, that it is not likely to be replaced by a competing line over the whole or the greater part of its system. In the case of the bonds of a small line it may quite well happen (and it has happened in the past) that one of the large railroads of the country absorbs a competing line, and by starving the first practically render its bonds valueless. For this reason it is advisable to avoid the bonds of a leased line, unless these bonds have a definite guarantee by an important railroad company, and unless the position of the guaranteeing line itself is unquestionable.

It is also well to have in remembrance that a railway debenture in America is a very different security from a railway debenture in this country. An American railway debenture carries the obligation of the railroad company, but it does not carry a charge over the railroad itself; and I do not think I am going too far in advising that you should not be satisfied with a mere obligation of an American railroad company, or with anything less than a bond secured by mortgage over the railroad property.

To summarise the different points: the American railway bond suitable for a thoroughly safe investment should consist of either a gold currency mortgage bond or a sterling currency mortgage bond secured over a railroad (1) of sufficient extent, and so situated as to be necessary for the traffic of the country; (2) whose earnings for a series of years show a considerable surplus over fixed charges; and (3) which has, at any rate in the recent years, been honestly managed.