In passing upon decisions of state courts overruling their prior decisions and thereby invalidating contracts entered into in reliance upon such prior decisions, there is a sharp distinction drawn between those cases in which the cause comes before the federal courts because of the citizenship of the parties thereto, and thence by appeal to the Supreme Court and those coming to the Supreme Court by writs of error to the highest state courts.

In the latter class of cases the only ground of federal jurisdiction is that the obligation of a contract has been impaired; that, in other words, a right guaranteed by the federal Constitution has been violated. In McCullough v. Virginia, as in an unbroken line of previous cases, the members of the Supreme Court all agreed that federal jurisdiction exists only in case the decision of the state court appealed from has given effect to a state legislative act impairing a contract previously entered into. Their only disagreement in that case was as to whether, in fact, the decision of the Virginia court had given effect to legislation of this character.