Tax laws, or, indeed, any other laws of a State discriminating against non-resident traders or against the products of other States are void as interfering with interstate commerce.

60 136 U. S. 104; 10 Sup. Ct. Rep. 881; 34 L. ed. 391.

61 Three justices dissented in this case upon the ground that the interference with interstate commerce was not sufficiently direct to bring it within the operation of the Commerce Clause.

62 See post, Section 330.

In Ward v. Maryland63 the court held void a state law by which persons not permanent residents in the State were prohibited from selling or offering for sale within a certain district of the State, any goods whatsoever other than agricultural products and articles manufactured in the State.

In Welton v. Missouri64 the same doctrine was declared, the court saying: "The commercial power continues until the commodity has ceased to be the subject of discriminating legislation by reason of its foreign character. That power protects it even after it has entered the State, from any burdens imposed by reason of its foreign origin."

In Guy v. Baltimore65 was adjudged invalid a municipal ordinance establishing certain wharfage rates to be paid by vessels carrying goods other than the productions of the State, the court. after a review of the authorities, saying: "In view of these and other decisions of this court, it must be regarded as settled that no State can, consistently with the federal Constitution, impose upon the products of other States, brought therein for sale or use. or upon citizens because engaged in the sale therein, or the transportation thereto, of the products of other States, more onerous public burdens or taxes than it imposes upon the like products of its own territory."

In "Webber v. Virginia66 a state license law was again held invalid because dependent upon the foreign character of the articles dealt with. " If," the court say, "by reason of their foreign character, the State can impose a tax upon them or upon the person through whom the sales are effected, the amount of the tax will be a matter resting in her discretion. She may place the tax at so high a figure as to exclude the introduction of the foreign article and prevent competition with the home product. It was against legislation of this discriminating kind that the framers of the Constitution intended to guard when they vested in Congress the power to regulate commerce among the several States."

63 12 Wall. 418; 20 L. ed. 449. 64 91 U S. 275; 23 L. ed. 347. 65 100 U. S. 434; 25 L. ed. 743. 66 103 U. S. 334; 26 L, ed. 565.

In Walling v. Michigan67 was held void, because discriminative, a state law which imposed a specitic tax on persons, not having their principal place of business in the State, engaged in selling liquors at wholesale, or in soliciting or taking orders for such liquors to be shipped into the State from outside the State, without imposing a similar tax upon persons engaged in the selling of liquors manufactured in the State.

In Darnell & Son Co. v. Memphis68 the authorities are carefully reviewed, a law.of Tennessee being held void which, while imposing a tax on the products of the soil of other States, exempted those produced from its own soil.