While the states may exercise a large discretion as to the purposes for which taxes shall be imposed, the property from which they shall be derived, and the methods in which they shall be levied and enforced as against such property, there are limitations in the federal constitution on the exercise of these powers which must always be borne in mind. The provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment to the federal constitution prohibiting states from depriving any person of property without due process of law, and from denying to any person the equal protection of the laws, are applicable to taxation as well as to other forms of the exercise of state power. " Due process of law" in this connection means that taxes must be for a public purpose, and imposed and collected in the usual methods applicable to the raising of revenue. These usual methods will be briefly described in a subsequent section of this chapter. But an attempt by the state in any method to exact taxes from persons or property not within its jurisdiction, or for a purpose not essentially public in its nature, would be an attempt to take property without due process of law, and therefore unlawful. The state cannot under the pretence of taxation impair fundamental individual rights to property. It cannot exact money from one person to pay it over to another for purposes which are not public, for this would not be a legitimate exercise of the power of taxation.

The very nature of the power to raise money by means of taxation involves the idea of an apportionment of the burden in accordance with some principle of uniformity. Absolute uniformity is impracticable and it would be equally inexpedient. The legislative power may, in its discretion, adjust the burdens of government so as to make them fall in some measure in accordance with the benefits resulting and the protection afforded. Different classes of property may be taxed in different methods, and different classes of persons may be required to contribute to the maintenance of government in different ways; and as long as the classifications made are reasonable and general, they will not be objectionable, though they may result in some measure of inequality. But if the lands of non-residents are taxed on a higher valuation, or at a higher rate than the lands of residents; or if some persons are required to pay a higher charge for the privilege of pursuing a particular occupation than other persons, the uniform operation of the law required by the Fourteenth Amendment is denied, and the distinctions thus attempted would be invalid.

The principle of uniformity requires some correspondence between burdens and benefits. The general advantages of government as to the protection of persons and property constitute all the benefits necessary to sustain a general tax applicable to persons and property within the jurisdiction of the state; but as to municipal taxes and special taxes for improvements, the question may sometimes be raised whether the person or property taxed is within the benefit of the tax in such sense as to authorize its imposition. Thus general municipal taxes may properly be laid on all property within the municipal limits; but if it is attempted to bring within the municipal limits agricultural land, which is not in any way benefited by the municipal government, it may well be said that the owner of such property does not belong to the class of persons, and his property does not belong to the class of property, which can properly be subjected to such taxes; and that the tax is not therefore levied according to the principle of uniformity. (See Kelly v. Pittsburgh)

Similar considerations apply to special assessments for public improvements, such as the paving of streets, the construction of sewers, and the like. These objects are sufficiently public in their nature to justify a general municipal tax therefor upon all property within the municipality. But property deriving a peculiar advantage from such improvements may properly be required to pay a special tax therefor by reason of such special benefit (see French v. Asphalt Co.), and the question often arises whether specific property is justly included within the class of property deemed to be especially benefited, and whether the tax is apportioned according to the benefit enjoyed. These are questions to be primarily determined by the taxing power, but it is for the courts to say ultimately, in any particular case, whether the determination reached is reasonably consonant with the requirement of uniformity.

License taxes on occupations are a proper means of raising revenue, but they are often imposed as a means of police regulation of occupations or forms of business which are properly subject to such regulation, and as thus imposed, the same restrictions as to uniformity are not applicable as where the object is to raise revenue only. Licenses to sell intoxicating liquors may be restricted to a limited number of persons in the city and refused to others; or licenses to practice medicine or dentistry or pharmacy may be denied to those not having certain qualifications; or licenses may be exacted from those engaged in certain kinds of business, although not required of those engaged in other kinds of business. An example of an exaction in the form of a tax which is properly imposed for other reasons than to raise revenue is the federal tax on the currency of state banks. As an exercise of the taxing power, such an exaction could not, perhaps, be justified; but the power of the federal government to regulate the currency is a sufficient justification for an exaction, the result of which is practically to prevent the issuance of paper money by corporations chartered by a state, and to limit the use of such money to the notes issued by the federal government directly, and national bank notes issued by corporations chartered under its authority ( Veazie Bank v. Fenno).