This section is from the book "Constitutional Law In The United States", by Emlin McClain. Also available from Amazon: Constitutional Law in the United States.
The judgment of a court is sometimes spoken of as an implied contract and if the judgmeut is for the performance of a duty arising by contract no doubt its obligations are protected as against subsequent legislation by the constitutional provision. A judgment, however, may also be for the enforcement of an obligation not arising out of contract but by general law, and in such cases the judgment itself cannot be said to be a contract (Morley v.Lake Shore, etc. R. Co.). In applying the constitutional provision as to impairment of the obligation of contracts it will be safe, therefore, to say that so far as contract obligations have been embodied in a judgment they are still protected as against subsequent legislation, but that the effect and enforcement of a judgment rendered with reference to obligations not arising out of contract may be regulated by subsequent legislation.
A rule or principle of law established by judicial decision is for some purposes as much a part of the law as a rule established by statute; but the decision of a court is primarily the law only as between the parties to the case decided, and with reference to the rights involved (see above, ch. xxiv) and while such a decision is a precedent, and will usually be followed in other cases in the same jurisdiction, it is not binding on the court in other cases in the same sense that a statute is binding upon the court. Therefore, the change of a rule of law established by a judicial decision is not the impairment of the obligation of a contract (Mobile Trans. Co. v. Mobile), although it may be that the parties making the contract have assumed that the first decision would be followed in other cases and therefore are prejudiced by the subsequent refusal of the court to follow the former decision.
 
Continue to: