This section is from the book "Constitutional Law In The United States", by Emlin McClain. Also available from Amazon: Constitutional Law in the United States.
By the provision of the federal constitution, that "no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise re-examined in any court of the United States than according to the rules of the common law " (Am. VII) it was simply intended to prohibit a review by a court sitting without a jury, of the conclusion of fact reached by a jury in the trial of such a case; that is, a trial judge cannot set aside the verdict of the jury and render a judgment on his own conclusions of fact, nor can an appellate court review the conclusions of fact reached by a jury and render a judgment on the evidence disregarding the verdict which the jury has reached on the facts. Although this specific provision is not usually found in state constitutions, the same rule is necessarily involved in the guaranty of jury trial. The appellate court in a case tried at law before a jury can review the rulings of the trial judge and can reverse the decision rendered on the verdict of the jury for errors of law committed, and on such review it may determine whether the judge has committed an error of law in refusing to set aside the verdict on the ground that such verdict is without support in the evidence, or is the result of passion or prejudice, or on similar grounds, but it cannot review the evidence for the purpose of determining whether the jury reached a correct conclusion. In equity cases, however, the appellate court may review the judgment of the trial court, both as to law and as to the facts, and it is usually provided that on appeal in an equity case the appellate court shall try the case anew on the evidence submitted to the trial court, and render such decision as should have been rendered under the evidence.
 
Continue to: