This section is from the book "Constitutional Law In The United States", by Emlin McClain. Also available from Amazon: Constitutional Law in the United States.
Complete religious liberty is not, however, secured by exemption from religious tests as a qualification for voting and holding office, nor by guaranteeing toleration and freedom from restraint as to religious beliefs. Any exaction of support for religious organizations or observances by way of taxation would also be an interference with religious liberty. The same causes which forbid restraint or compulsion of the person with regard to religion would also forbid compulsory contribution of property for its support, and the various state constitutions generally contain some prohibition of this character. Such a prohibition not only prevents the establishment of a state church to be supported by taxation, but also precludes the support by public taxation of educational institutions devoted to the promulgation of any particular form of religion.
The controversies which have actually arisen in the courts as to religious liberty have related for the most part to the use of public money in aiding the schools under the control of some particular religious sect or the introduction into schools supported by public taxation of some form of religious worship or instruction. (See Pfeiffer v. Board of Education and State v. District Board.') No satisfactory rule can be derived from the decisions of the courts with reference to these questions, for the reason that they have been made in applying the particular provisions of the different state constitutions, which are by no means uniform in their requirements; but this, perhaps, may safely be said, that the reading without comment of portions of the bible in the public schools is not an interference with religious liberty, provided attendance at such exercise is not made compulsory on the part of the scholars who desire to be excused, or whose parents desire to have them excused, on account of conscientious scruples. With regard to the use of public money in aiding sectarian schools a similar principle must be applied, and if attendance in the school is permitted only to those entertaining some particular form of religious belief, or if the school gives some form of religious instruction, or if it imposes any conditions which exclude pupils on account of religious belief or want of belief, it cannot properly be given appropriations or support from the funds raised by public taxation.
Similar questions have been raised as to the constitutionality of exemptions from taxation of property devoted to religious purposes. It might reasonably be argued that to exempt property devoted to sectarian purposes from taxation is in effect to promote such purposes at the public expense, but it may be said, on the other hand, that such property is devoted to a benevolent purpose and a purpose which the state may legitimately encourage in the same way that property devoted to the use and support of private educational institutions, libraries, charitable societies, and other like objects is devoted to a use beneficial to the public, and may be exempted from taxation on the same general grounds. The amount of taxation of which the state is deprived by the exemption of property devoted to religious purposes is so small as compared with the total amount realized from general taxation, that the increase of burden thus thrown on other property owners may reasonably be disregarded. Moreover, the exemption of such property is not directly but only indirectly and remotely the imposition of any pecuniary burden, and such exemptions are generally sustained as proper when authorized by law.
 
Continue to: