The jurisdiction of the federal courts in the classes of cases placed within their jurisdiction by the federal constitution may be exercised, however, not only by trial in a federal court but also by means of an appeal from a state court to a federal court, and such an appeal is authorized by statute where the construction of the constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States is involved, or some right, privilege, or immunity, is claimed under such constitution, laws, or treaties (Cohens v. Virgbiia and Martin v. Hunters Lessee). It is evident that there would be no proper occasion for such an appeal unless the decision of the state court should be against the party who makes some claim by reason of the constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States or is asserting some right, privilege, or immunity by virtue thereof. The theory is that it is only when a state court has put a construction on some provision of the constitution, laws, or treaties which is contrary to that which the unsuccessful party claims should have been put upon it, and such construction is injurious to him; or when the state court has denied some right, privilege, or immunity claimed under federal authority, that an appeal to the federal courts is necessary. Such an appeal can only be taken after the unsuccessful party has carried the case through the state courts to the court of last resort, and is still unsuccessful.

Such an appeal from a state court can only be taken to the Supreme Court of the United States. None of the lower federal courts have authority to review on appeal the decisions of the state courts, and, as will appear from what has been said, the Supreme Court exercises such appellate jurisdiction only with reference to federal questions. In cases which are declared to be within the jurisdiction of the federal courts in order to provide a fair court for their trial, and which might have been originally brought in or removed to a federal court, no right of appeal from the state to a federal court is provided for. If the parties have seen fit to submit their controversy to a state court, neither of them can afterwards complain that such court did not afford him a fair trial.