This section is from the book "Constitutional Law In The United States", by Emlin McClain. Also available from Amazon: Constitutional Law in the United States.
The provision giving to the federal courts power as to "controversies to which the United States shall be a party" simply authorizes Congress to provide for trial in the federal courts of suits brought by or against the United States. Prosecutions for offences committed against the laws of the United States are of this character, as are also suits by the United States government to enforce penalties and forfeitures for violation of the revenue or postal laws, or similar statutes. A suit against a federal officer and his sureties to recover a penalty under his bond for breach of duty would come within the same description. As plaintiff the United States may also under this provision sue in the federal courts to recover damages for breach of contract, or to enforce any other legal obligation.
It is important to notice in this connection that a sovereign government cannot be sued in its own courts, and it was evidently not the intention of this clause of the constitution to change the rule in this respect as to the United States. Therefore, a suit against the United States cannot be maintained, even in the federal courts, unless under some express authority. The rule is this: that the ordinary statutory provisions conferring jurisdiction on the courts in certain classes of cases do not authorize suits against the United States, for it is to be presumed that a sovereign government will do justice without the compulsion of a court; and that, moreover, it was not intended to give to any tribunal a coercive power with reference to the government itself.
Yet, as it is within the legislative authority to provide for the payment of just claims against the government, Congress may, if it sees fit, authorize such claims to be prosecuted in courts specially designated for that purpose, and, accordingly, it has created a Court of Claims in which persons claiming that the United States is justly indebted to them may prosecute their demands, and have the justice of such demands legally investigated. It has been further especially provided by statute that the general courts of the United States may exercise much the same jurisdiction as to claims against the government as was conferred upon the court of claims. But these special provisions authorize only the determination by the court of claims, or other court having the same authority, of the legality of a claim; they do not authorize the enforcement of any judgment which may be rendered against the United States, and it still remains for Congress in its discretion to appropriate the money necessary to pay such judgments.
The immunity of the United States from suit in its courts does not extend to its officers or agents claiming to act under its authority (United States v. Lee). If, as matter of fact, they act without authority, they may be sued in the federal or state courts, and held liable as individuals. And the validity of the authority which they claim to be exercising as officers or agents of the federal government may be investigated. The executive or legislative department cannot, by action in excess of its authority, confer upon any officer or agent the power to violate the law.
 
Continue to: