Being compacts between governments, treaties are not usually regarded as a part of the internal or municipal law of either of the governments which are the parties thereto. But it is expressly provided in the federal constitution that "all treaties made or which shall be made under the authority of the United States" shall be, like the federal constitution and the laws of the United States made in pursuance thereof, "the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding" (Const. Art. VI, ¶ 2). Therefore, rights and duties of persons, as well as the rights and obligations of the government, may be directly affected by treaties; and such rights and duties, so far as they are granted to or imposed upon individuals, may be protected and enforced in the courts. The provisions of a treaty which it is within the power of the federal government to make will be superior in authority to any state statute relating to the same subject-matter.

Thus, as the rights of the subjects of foreign governments to acquire by purchase or inheritance property within the limits of the United States is a proper subject to be regulated by treaty between this government and such foreign governments, the states cannot by legislation deprive the subjects of foreign governments of property rights guaranteed to them by treaty. It is within the general power of the states to determine to what extent, if at all, aliens may acquire and enjoy property rights under state laws. In many states non-resident aliens are forbidden from acquiring real property by purchase or inheritance. Nevertheless, so far as such state statutes may interfere with the rights of an alien under a treaty between this government and the government of which such alien is a subject, the state law must give way, and if under the treaty the alien is entitled to acquire or own property, by inheritance or otherwise, he may enjoy that right, and it will be protected by the courts, although it is in contravention of the law of the state where the property is situated (People v. Gerke).

Another result of declaring a treaty to be the law of the land is that it stands on the same footing in this respect with an act of Congress. It is the general rule, as between two statutes which are in conflict, if they are enacted by the same authority, that the one later in time will control, being deemed in this respect and to the extent to which the two are in conflict to be a repeal of the former. Likewise, as between two treaties, made between the same contracting powers, the later in" time will control or supersede, so far as they are inconsistent, the former. It is to be borne in mind that a statute enacted by Congress is not a part of the law of the land unless it is consistent with and enacted under the authority of the constitution, so that there are no doubt some subjects, such as the right of an alien to acquire or inherit property, which cannot be regulated by Congress, although they may be controlled by treaty. In such a case there could be no conflict between the treaty and the statute, for the statute would be unconstitutional.

As between a treaty and a statute which is enacted by Congress in the exercise of some express or implied power conferred upon it, the later in point of time is controlling, and this will be true even though in the enactment of the statute Congress has violated the treaty obligations of the government to the foreign power with whom the treaty is made. Thus, if there were a treaty between this government and the Chinese government by which the subjects of the latter were entitled to come freely into the United States, Congress would have the power, notwithstanding the treaty, to exclude Chinese subjects. (See Chinese Exclusion Case.) As between this country and China such a statute would be a violation of treaty obligations; but redress for such breach of faith would be secured by diplomatic negotiations between the two countries. The courts would recognize the statute, being later in point of time, as controlling so far as any judicial questions could arise. On the other hand, the treaty-making power may abrogate a statute and the courts would be bound to recognize the treaty, being later in point of time, as superseding the statute, so far as it was applicable to the subject-matter controlled by the treaty.

It is apparent, therefore, that while the executive department is supreme in determining the relations between this and foreign countries, it may not be able to carry out its agreements so far as they involve either legislation by Congress or the action of the states. This inability of the executive department in its relations with foreign governments to carry out its obligations is due to the fact that no one department of the federal government is sovereign with reference to the other departments, and the further fact that the federal government is in itself a government of limited powers. With reference to the latter point it has already been noticed (see above, § 49) that the general protection of persons and property within state limits depends upon the laws of the state. If, therefore, an alien is denied in any state the proper protection of the law, his government may justly make complaint to the federal government, but the federal government can give no redress unless it be by way of payment of damages to the subject of the foreign government who is thus denied the protection of the law. Perhaps Congress might and should by statute give protection to aliens in their personal and property rights; but thus far it has failed to do so in any effectual manner.