This section is from the book "Constitutional Law In The United States", by Emlin McClain. Also available from Amazon: Constitutional Law in the United States.
"To promote the progress of science and useful arts," Congress is authorized to secure "for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries" (Const. Art. I, § 8, ¶ 8). In the exercise of this authority, Congress (in 1790) passed patent laws and copyright laws, the term "patent " being used to describe an invention or discovery, and the term "copyright" to signify the exclusive right of an author to publish his writings.
The word "patent," as originally used in English law, signified the grant of some privilege, property, or authority made by the government or sovereign to an individual or individuals. The term derived this meaning from the fact that the sovereign in making such grant issued "letters patent," that is, an open or public instrument, bearing the great seal, in which the right or privilege granted was set out. Titles of nobility were thus conferred as well as estates, corporate privileges, the exclusive right to carry on a particular trade or deal in a particular commodity, and the like. In this country the instrument by which the government conveys title to land to a purchaser is still called a patent. It would be proper to speak of the grant of the exclusive privilege to manufacture an invented article, or to make use of a valuable discovery as a patent, but in common usage the term, as employed with relation to inventions and discoveries, signifies the privilege itself rather than the grant of the privilege, and is, in ordinary parlance, frequently used to designate the invention or discovery, or even the manufactured article or other thing manufactured or used under or in pursuance of such privilege.
In enacting the patent laws under the authority of the constitution to promote the progress of science and useful arts, Congress has but followed the custom of other governments. In all civilized countries there are now some such provisions for the promotion of invention and discovery in the useful arts. According to the method provided for by Congress, the discoverer of a useful invention or process makes application to the patent office, which is a branch of the Interior Department of the government, for a patent, that is, for the exclusive privilege of using and transferring to others the right to use his invention or discovery. The proper officers of the department investigate his claim, and upon becoming satisfied that his invention is new and useful, letters patent are issued to him granting such exclusive privilege. These letters are, however, only prima facie evidence that he is entitled to a patent, and the question whether the invention or discovery is such as entitles him to an exclusive privilege with reference thereto under the laws of Congress, is ultimately to be determined by the courts in an action brought by or against him for infringement on the part of some one making a conflicting claim, or by the United States against him to determine the validity of his claim. In short, the right granted is treated as a property right to be determined and protected in the courts.
The power to authorize the granting of exclusive privileges of using, manufacturing, and selling an invention or discovery can be granted only by the federal government. The states cannot exercise such power, for in doing so they would necessarily interfere with the authority of Congress. But a patent right like any other property is owned and held subject to law, and the states may make such regulations with reference thereto as they see fit, so long as such regulations do not directly or unreasonably interfere with the privileges acquired under the patent laws. (See Patterson v. Kentucky.) Thus the state, in the exercise of its police power, might prohibit the sale of toy pistols to children, even though the pistols were manufactured under a patent; and it has been said that a state may by statute regulate the negotiability of notes given for patent rights. (See Herdic v. Roessler.)
A copyright is the exclusive privilege of publishing or copying an original writing or composition (Wheaton v. Peters). The statutes passed by Congress on the subject provide that the author or composer shall file with the librarian of Congress a printed copy of the title of the book, map, chart, etc., or a description of the painting, etc., and at the time of publication, deliver to the librarian two copies of the book or other publication, or in the case of a painting a photograph of the same, and announce by printing on the title-page or page following of every copy the fact and date of the copyright claimed. A copyright differs in at least one important feature from a patent right in that in the case of a patent the letters issued constitute prima facte evidence of the privilege, while in case of a copyright there is no formal document, but the author or other person claiming the right may assert it in the courts, proving the facts necessary to entitle him to such privilege as provided by the statute. Like the patent laws, the copyright laws are modelled after those which had previously been in existence in England and other countries. Exclusive privileges to authors have been recognized in all civilized countries, and recently provisions have been made by Congress for an international copyright, so that a book copyrighted in one country cannot be published in another except under the authority of the owner of the original copyright. Without a copyright, the writer or composer of an original literary or musical or artistic production may retain the exclusive use and enjoyment of it; but he cannot publish it without giving to every one the general right to make such use of it as he sees fit, including republication, unless he secures at the time of such publication an exclusive privilege under the copyright laws.
No express authority is given to Congress with reference to securing to manufacturers and dealers the exclusive use of trademarks. It was attempted to provide for such exclusive use under the copyright law, but it was held by the Supreme Court of the United States in the Trade-Mark Cases that Congress could not provide for the copyrighting of trade-marks. Under the authority to regulate interstate and foreign commerce, Congress has, however, authorized the registration of trademarks on goods destined for interstate or export trade, and interference with or infringement upon the lawful use of a trade-mark is illegal.
 
Continue to: