(y) Land Transfer Rules (1903), 83, 84, 86.

(z) Above, p. 405 & n. (l).

(a) Above, pp. 370, n.(m), 1100.

(b) Land Transfer Rules (1903), 85.

(c) Above, p. 409.

(d) Land Transfer Rules(1903), 256.

(e) Ibid. r. 29.

(f) See ibid. r. 145.

(g) Above, pp. 393 sq.; see p.

396 & n. (I).

(h) Land Transfer Rules (1903), 146, quoted above, p. 1112.

(i) Above, p. 1113.

(k) Above, p. 405 & n. (l).

Here it may be observed that the above-mentioned enactment of the Land Transfer Act, 1897 (l), providing that the register shall be rectified where a registered disposition would if unregistered be absolutely void, appears to be very far-reaching in its effect, and to introduce into dealings with registered land an element of uncertainty against which a purchaser has no protection. Thus a purchaser of land from a vendor registered as proprietor with an absolute title is precluded from inquiring into the earlier title; he must accept the present entries in the register as conclusive evidence (m). If however the vendor had been so registered under a transfer which if unregistered would have been void (as from a corporation in excess of its powers or from trustees prohibited from selling without the Charity Commissioners' consent (n) ), it appears that those entitled by virtue of the nullity of such transfer would have the right to have the register rectified; that is to say, they might insist that the vendor was not the lawful registered proprietor of land, and procure the removal of his name from the register. But if it can be so maintained that the vendor is not the registered proprietor of the land, it appears to follow that he cannot validly exercise the powers of disposition given to the registered proprietor, so as to extinguish outstanding interests. The transfer to the purchaser therefore, though duly registered, would appear not to vest in him an indefeasible estate in fee simple (o), but to give him only an estate voidable at the instance of those entitled to the rectification of the register. It is true that the purchaser would be entitled to an indemnity under the Land Transfer Act, 1897 (p); but, as was recognised in founding the jurisdiction to decree specific performance (q), pecuniary damages are not an adequate compensation for being deprived of land purchased with the expectation of an indefeasible title. Other instances of registered dispositions, which if unregistered would be absolutely void, are forged transfers (r), and transfers void for mistake (s) or for non-compliance with the statute regulating the assurance of land to charitable uses (t). It should be noted that, in the above respects, a person taking or deriving title under a registered transfer of a registered charge made by a registered proprietor, whose title was acquired under a void disposition, appears to stand in a more favourable position; as it is enacted in the Land Transfer Act, 1897 (u), that a registered transferee for value of a charge and his successors in title shall not be affected by any irregularity or invalidity in the original charge itself, of which the transferee was not aware when it was transferred to him. But the like protection is not accorded to the original chargee himself, nor to persons claiming under a void transfer of a valid charge. Thus it has been decided that in the case of a forged transfer of a charge, the name of the person misled by the forgery must be removed from the register, but he is entitled to the indemnity provided by the Act (x).

Effect of a registered disposition which if unregistered would be void.

(l) Above, p. 1113.

(m) Above, p. 1059.

(n) Above, pp. 1113, 1114.

(o) Above, p. 1073.

(p) Above, p. 1113 & n. (q).

(q) Above, p. 988.

29 (2)

Protection of persons claiming under a transfer of a charge made by a proprietor entitled under a void disposition.

The title may be registered to an undivided share in land, or to mines and minerals severed from the surface, or to cellars, flats, or chambers, in the same manner as to the entirety (y). But we have seen (z) that nothing in the Land Transfer Act, 1897, shall render compulsory the registration of the title to an undivided share in land, or to mines and minerals apart from the surface. This exemption, however, is not extended to cellars, flats, chambers, or similar hereditaments (a).

Undivided share in land; mines apart from surface.

(r) Above, p. 754.

(s) Above, p. 671 & n. (m).

(t) Above, pp. 394 sq., 396, 1114.

(u) Stat. 60 & 61 Vict. c. 65, First Schedule, amending stat. 38 & 39 Vict. c. 87, 8. 40.

{x) A.-G.v. Odell, 1905, W. N. 81.

(y) Stats. 38 & 39 Vict. c. 87, s. 82; 60&61 Vict. c. 65,s. 14(1); Land Transfer Rules (1903), 71 - 77.

(z) Above, p. 370.

Copyholds cannot be registered as such under the Land Transfer Acts; nor customary freeholds in any case in which an admission or any act by the lord of the manor is necessary to perfect the title of the tenant (b). But freeholds intermixed with and indistinguishable from copyholds or customary freeholds may be so registered: though in such case notice is to be entered on the register of the facts relating to the tenure of the land, and the tenure of that portion of the land, which is not freehold, will remain unaffected by the registration (c). We have seen that nothing in the Land Transfer Act, 1897, is to render compulsory the registration of the title to freeholds intermixed with and indistinguishable from lands of other tenure, or to corporeal hereditaments parcel of a manor and included in a sale of a manor as such (d). The title to a manor or a seignory may be registered (e).

Copyholds and customary-freeholds.

Manor; seignory.

The purchase of registered land from a mortgagee exercising his power of sale is a matter demanding special notice. A mortgagee of registered land may occupy one of four different positions. First, his mortgage may be a registered incumbrance, prior to first registration with an absolute title, whereof the proprietorship is not registered (f). Secondly, the mortgagor may have registered, after the mortgage, with a possessory title, when the mortgage will have been an estate, right or interest then subsisting as adverse to or in derogation of his title (g). Thirdly, the mortgage may be a registered incumbrance, prior to first registration with an absolute title, whereof the proprietorship is registered (h). And fourthly, the mortgage may have been made subsequently to the registration of the land (i).