R. Manwaring

Manwaring's "genteel" furniture is just what we should expect furniture to be to which that objectionable adjective was applied by its designer and maker. It was without grace, inspiration, banal and frumpishly respectable. It was the logical outcome of a period when invention and originality were dormant. Like Ince and Mayhew's tortured frivolities and spineless fatuities, Manwaring's furniture serves to show how really great and worthy Chippendale's work was. Indeed, it is not until we compare the pieces designed and sent out by such men as Ince and Mayhew or Manwaring with the chairs and cabinet-work made after Chippendale's patterns that we can sufficiently appreciate and value the sagacity and residuum of sound taste to be found among the rank and file of eighteenth century British cabinet-makers and their patrons evidenced in their general preference for the designs of the latter.

In 1765 appeared the Cabinet and Chairmaker's Real Friend and Companion, wholly the work of Man-waring himself, and in the following year was published the Chairmaker's Guide by Manwaring and some associates, which, with a few additional plates, is mainly a reprint of portions of a book previously published by the Society of Upholsterers and Cabinetmakers, entitled One Hundred New and Genteel Designs, being all the most approved Patterns of Household Furniture in the present taste.

The last-named valuable contribution to the cabinet-maker's art was probably published before Chippendale's Director, and is full of gauche, clumsy and fantastic anomalies, most of which, if ever actually executed, have happily not survived. The other two books with which Manwaring was chiefly, concerned, though printed after the appearance of the Director, gave evidence of a spirit of envious rivalry towards the Cabinet-Maker of Saint Martin's Lane and a strong desire to furnish new and original designs for chairs and cabinet-work quite as good as his, a desire the fulfilment of which Manwaring's limitations of invention and taste absolutely precluded. In his Cabinet and Chairmaker's Real Friend Manwaring says that "though the art of chairmaking as well as cabinet making, has been brought to great perfection, notwithstanding which it will be ever capable of improvement, and though there have appeared of late years several treatises and designs for household furniture, some of which must be allowed by all artists to be of the greatest utility in assisting their ideas for composing various designs, yet upon the whole the practical workman has not been much instructed in the execution of these designs, which appear to him so rich and beautiful.

The intent, therefore, of the following pages is to convey to him full and plain instructions how to begin and finish with strength and beauty all the designs that are advanced in this work." As one able critic has pointed out, he "unfortunately omits to inform the workman how he is to add the beauty in which the designs are so singularly deficient," 2 contenting himself by observing that "they are calculated for all people in different stations of life" and "are actually originals and not pirated or copied from the designs or inventions of others, which of late hath been too much practised" - this last shaft of sarcasm being a dig at Chippendale, whom his rivals loved to accuse of plagiarism.

Manwaring and his associates could not follow Chippendale in his mixing and adapting of styles because they lacked judgment and were utterly wanting in his sense of form and refinement of contour. A perception of essential symmetry they had not and when they tried to emulate his achievements the best they could do was to overload and obscure the outline with senseless elaborations.

Manwaring's plainer chairs are his best and his best are passable. His worst are quite beyond words. Nearly all are squat, ungainly and dumpy in proportion, and compared with chairs patterned after Chippendale's designs they are loutish and bourgeois in aspect. His cabinet-work, also, is lacking in any desirable individuality and merely suggests inferior Chippendale. His "Rural" furniture, "made with the limbs of yew and apple trees as nature produces them," is frankly hideous, the painted landscapes on his rustic seats and the floral wreaths around the square legs of Chinese chairs are quite as bad, while the simpering curves of his French designs are nauseating.

In one particular, however, we must yield him due credit. He seems to have been the originator or, at any rate, the first to use the fretted bracket between the legs and seat rail of chairs. This item of design Chippendale incorporated and frequently made use of with excellent effect.

2 Clouston: Chippendale.