We will now discuss clinical acetonurias. The first of these is febrile acetonuria. Von Jacksch was the first to determine that considerable quantities of acetone, and at times of diacetic acid, are regularly found in a large number of diseases that are accompanied by high fever, as for instance, scarlatina, typhoid, pulmonary tuberculosis, etc. B-oxybutyric acid has also been frequently found in the urine of patients suffering with these diseases, both during the course of the disease and during convalescence. As a rule there is a certain proportion, though not a regular one between the height of the fever and the amount of acetone that is excreted in the urine; acetonuria has, however, been observed in cases of typhoid fever that ran their course without much elevation of temperature.

In order to illustrate the influence of the diet on the excretion of acetone in typhoid fever, two patients suffering from this disease and both with temperature between 39 and 40 degrees were placed on a different diet. The one received a diet that contained little carbohydrate, the other a diet that contained much carbohydrate. Patient A, on three successive days received ten eggs, 3/10 ths of a liter of cream (with 30% of fat) 50 grm. of oatmeal flour, 100 grm. of butter and in addition a little meat broth and tea (about 82 grm. of albumen, 39 grm. of carbohydrate, 228 grm. of fat; all in all, about 2600 calories). The urine gave Gerhardt's ferric chlorid reaction and contained an average of 0.8 grm. of acetone a day. Patient B on three successive days took two liters of milk, 150 grm of oatmeal flour made into soup with milk, 200 grm. of sugar (about 90 grm. of albumen, 70 grm. of fat, 380 grm. of carbohydrate, all in all about 2,600 calories). This patient excreted only about 0.05 grm. of acetone, on an average during the course of these three days. Now the two patients reversed the diet. As a consequence the amount of acetone excreted by patient A dropped to 0.1 grm. a day, whereas patient B excreted 0.7 grm. The food was well absorbed in both cases, there being only one soft evacuation of the bowels a day.

Von Engel who together with Seiftert and others examined the urine of a large number of febrile cases for acetone, states that apparently the location of the disease and the individuality of the patient determines the excretion of acetone more than the height of the fever. A large number of investigators soon formulated objections against the idea that febrile acetonuria was a specific manifestation of fever. Attention was called in particular to the acetonuria occurring in fasting, and Von Noorden was the first to emphasize the fact that insufficient ingestion of food must be considered to be the cause of febrile acetonuria. Hirschfeld later circumscribed this theory of von Noorden's and others by claiming that the absence of carbohydrates from the food of febrile cases was chiefly responsible for the excretion of acetone in these cases. As a matter of fact, one can easily determine that febrile acetonuria and diaceturia disappear in a short time in patients with fever if they are placed on a carbohydrate diet.

Essentially the same applies to carcinomatous acetonuria a form of acetonuria that is by no means rare. Sufferers from carcinoma frequently die in a condition that greatly resembles diabetic coma, while at the same time acetone appears in the urine, consequently many investigators have attributed this terminal condition in carcinoma to an intoxication with acetone. It is also claimed that the appearance of acetone and of diacetic acid in carcinoma is a particularly bad prognostic sign, but aside from the fact that the quantities of these bodies that are excreted are so small that they do not compare with the quantities excreted in diabetic coma, there are, moreover cases of coma in carcinoma in which no acetone bodies whatsoever are excreted in the urine. As, in addition, these bodies are never found in the early stages of the disease, when the ingestion of food is still normal, and are only found in the later stages of carcinoma, I am much inclined to the belief that the acetonuria is not related to the carcinomatous process per se, but is merely the result of insufficient nutrition - above all of inadequate ingestion and assimilation of carbohydrate during the terminal stages of the disease. This view is borne out by a number of cases in which acetonuria and the excretion of B-oxybutyric acid was stopped as soon as a sufficient quantity of carbohydrates was administered. The following is a particularly striking case of this kind: A girl of 26 was admitted to the hospital suffering from constant vomiting. She was greatly reduced in strength. The result of the objective examination of the patient rendered the diagnosis of carcinoma of the pylorus very probable, and this diagnosis was later corroborated by an autopsy. During the first days an average of 3 grm. of acetone, an abundant quantity of diacetic acid and 10 grm. of oxybutyric acid (determined according to the method of Magnus-Levy) were excreted. It was possible on two successive days to administer 120 to 150 grm. of carbohydrates to this patient in the form of clysmata of dextrose, and of oatmeal by mouth. On the third day the excretion of acetone fell rapidly and only 0.6 grm. were eliminated. At the same time the ferric chloride reaction and all traces of oxybutyric acid disappeared from the urine. We have seen a number of such cases and could in addition quote several from the literature (Klemperer, von Noorden and others)

The last named observation is also of fundamental importance in another from of acetonuria, namely, gastro-intestinal acetonnria. Lorenz found this form of acetone excretion in a large number of diseases of the stomach and intestine, particularly in acute cases. This fact has recently been repeatedly corroborated, and has been variously utilized in constructing theories on the origin of acetone. But even these observations, studied in the light of our present knowledge, completely lose any symptomatologic or pathognostic importance. In these cases we are apparently not dealing with specific disease processes that lead to the formation of acetone, but with acetonuria from inanition that is produced by loss of appetite, vomiting, diarrhoea and decreased ingestion of food.

Even the rapid appearance of the acetone bodies so soon after the onset of the disease can hardly be considered a specific sign of the intestinal origin of acetone and its congeners. It is remarkable how rapidly acetone appears in the urine as soon as the diet is one sided and insufficient, and the administration of carbohydrates is greatly reduced. We do not think that the appearance of acetone in the vomit and in the intestinal contents speaks in favor of the gastro-intestinal origin of acetonuria in these cases, for the quantity of acetone that is found is rarely larger than the amount normally found in the gastric and intestinal contents. At the same time, one can readily understand how the entrance of a large quantity of acetone and B-oxybutyric acid into the circulation, as described in the above cases, might very well lead to the excretion of more acetone bodies than normal into the stomach and intestine. It is further possible that in catarrhal conditions of the stomach and intestine, in which there is fermentation of carbohydrates, acetone might be formed in the intestine, just as traces of acetone are occasionally formed as a bi-product in fermentative processes outside of the body. But even this formation of acetone is only very slight, and in the cases quoted by Lorenz in particular no indications are given that large quantities of fermenting carbohydrates were present in the intestines. On the other hand, it has repeatedly been demonstrated - and we have shown this in numerous cases of gastritis, enteritis, carcinoma of the stomach and intestine, poisoning etc., - that the excretion of acetone bodies is always decreased (even in those cases in which undoubtedly the gastrointestinal function is greatly perverted) as soon as sufficient quantities of carbohydrate can be administered and absorbed.

On the basis of Lorenz' observations a number of other morbid states that are accompanied by acetonuria have been attributed to intoxication with this body, and the theory has been advanced that here this poisonous acetone was formed in the intestinal canal. Here belong, for instance, certain psychoses that are accompanied by acetonuria and that Wagner has recently designated as acetone autointoxication. In addition, certain spasmodic states that have been described by von Jacksch as epilepsia acetonica and finally certain disease pictures occurring in children and characterized by spasms with acetone excretion; such cases have recently been described by Baginsky. A number of these observations were published before the colossal influence of the diet on the secretion of acetone was understood. None of the older observers and - remarkable to say - none of the newer ones have paid sufficient attention to this point. It is a well known fact that the ingestion of food is reduced in insane people and in sick children. In the cases of nervous disease, accompanied by somnolence, that von Jacksch has described, the acetonuria is apparently due to the insufficient administration of carbohydrate.

One should be just as skeptical in regard to asthma acetonicum condition that was first described by Pawinski. His particular case is especially instructive, for it shows how careful one must be in interpreting a symptom complex that is per se very complicated. In this patient there was a combination of nephritis with cardiac hypertrophy and apparently stenocardiac attacks that were attributed to the action of acetone by the author. He felt justified in doing this because during the asthmatic attacks the excretion of albumen was slight, while at the same time the excretion of acetone was very considerable, and because, furthermore, in the interims between the attacks the conditions were exactly reversed. This in itself seems to indicate that the nutrition of this patient was the determining factor in the production of the acetonuria, for the increased excretion of albumen and the decrease in the acetonuria can very well be attributed to the increased ingestion of food. Consequently, the sequence of events in Pawinski's case would seem to be as follows: the primary event was the stenocardiac attack, accompanied, of course, by decreased ingestion of food, i. e., of carbohydrates; the secondary event, then, was the excretion of acetone.