This section is from the book "The Newer Knowledge Of Nutrition", by Elmer Verner McCollum. Also available from Amazon: The Newer Knowledge of Nutrition: The Use of Food for the Preservation of Vitality and Health.
Beri-beri is a disease of great antiquity, which was for a long time confined to Japan, the Dutch East Indies, Malay Peninsula, Philippine Islands, India and Southern China. It was at one time believed to be a tropical disease, but this view has been disproved by its frequent occurrence in recent times in certain other localities, especially in the subarctic regions, notably Newfoundland, Labrador and Norway. It results from faulty nutrition and will occur in any part of the world if man restricts his diet to certain articles of food. In 1914 there was an outbreak of typical beri-beri in the jail at Elizabeth, New Jersey, caused by the poor diet of the inmates (1).
Beri-beri is a form of peripheral neuritis, the nerves of motion and sensation being chiefly affected. It occurs in two distinct forms, the wet and the dry. Its incipiency is manifested by fatigue and depression, numbness and stiffness of the legs, and more or less edema of the ankles and face. In the dry type, wasting, anesthesia and paralysis are the chief manifestations. The most marked symptom in the wet type is edema, which is sometimes excessive, affecting the trunk, limbs and extremities. In both forms there is generally tenderness of the calf muscles and a tingling or burning sensation in the feet, legs and arms. The mortality in this disease is usually high.
Various theories have been advanced to explain its etiology. Since polished rice is very poor in protein, fat and phosphorus, the prevalence of beri-beri among rice-eating peoples was by some attributed to the low protein content of the diet, by others to fat starvation, to starvation for organic forms of phosphorus, or to intoxication caused by a poison present in rice stored under unfavorable conditions. Climate, arsenical poisoning and specific infection were likewise proposed as factors in the etiology of the disease. It was impossible to determine the true cause of beriberi until after it had been experimentally produced in animals subsisting on an inadequate diet. It is now generally accepted that the disease is the sequel to specific starvation for a substance of unknown chemical nature, but a very small amount of which is necessary in the diet. This is variously designated as the anti-neuritic substance, anti-beri-beri vitamin, water-soluble B, etc. Beri-beri is, therefore, like scurvy, a dietary deficiency disease, due to lack in the food of a specific substance. The history of the study of this disease by various investigators forms in preventive medicine a chapter of absorbing interest.
The most notable among the early investigations relating to the etiology of beri-beri is the work of Takagi Kanehiro, Director-General of the Japanese navy. About the year 1880 the disease became a scourge among Japanese sailors. Between 1878 and 1883 the average number of cases treated medically in the navy was 323.5 per 1,000 per year. The incidence of beriberi during these years average annually 324 per 1,000 men.
During this period the diet of the sailors consisted of polished rice and fish as the principal components, the remainder being derived from a number of vegetables. Takagi, suspected, as the result of a visit to Europe, during which he was impressed with the differences in the diet and in the health of the British sailors as compared with those of Japan, that beri-beri might be due to faulty food. He, therefore, commissioned a training ship to make a nine months' cruise on which the diet of the common sailors included 91 grams of protein per day. The better fed officers did not suffer from the disease, whereas the men were sorely afflicted. There were 169 cases of beri-beri among 276 men during this cruise.
Another ship was then commissioned to make a similar voyage with the protein content of the diet for the common sailors raised to 155 grams per man per day. There was almost no illness during the second voyage, as contrasted with a frightful incidence of beri-beri on the first. Among the crew of 276 men there were but 14 cases of beri-beri. This experience led to a marked improvement of the diets of the personnel of the navy, and the disappearance of beri-beri from the service. The improvement was due to the addition of more meat and vegetables, a reduction of the amount of rice, substituting in part wheat or barley. A pint and a quarter of milk a day was also furnished each man. This was made possible through the employment of condensed milk. The successful condensation of milk on a commercial scale began in England in 1856. As a result of these changes in the diet, beri-beri became very rare. Diseases of the digestive tract and of the respiratory system became less prevalent and diseases of the eyes were diminished to one half the former incidence (2). The Japanese officials were of the opinion that the increased meat consumption was responsible for the protection against beri-beri.
For many years this experience of the Japanese navy was regarded as a demonstration of the importance of a protein rich diet. That this was not the true explanation of the cause of the immunity of the Japanese sailors to beri-beri, is clear from the history of the disease among the crews of Norwegian vessels. In the invigorating climate of the northern seas, beri-beri suddenly became common among the Norwegian sailors after 1894, whereas before that time it had been quite unknown. Before 1894 the diet of these men consisted of bread made from rye flour, milled without the removal of the germ, peas and salted meat mostly fat pork. After that year it consisted of white bread made from bolted wheat flour, peas, salt pork once or twice a week, preserved meat and fish three or four times a week, and dry fish once a week. Here was a case in which the addition of meat and fish in liberal amounts, although increasing greatly the protein consumption, was nevertheless followed by the sudden appearance of beri-beri, a new disease in that part of the world. It is reported that one sea captain refused to accept the white bread, and provided for his own table a supply of the customary rye flour bread. When beri-beri attacked his crew he was able for a time to afford his men relief by sharing his brown bread with them, but because of the limited supply was forced, finally, to deny it to them to save himself (3). These observations show clearly that meat and bread in abundance, together with some peas, does not constitute a satisfactory diet. When bread is made of bolted flour, and is used as the main article of the diet, the deficiency of the latter in water-soluble B will be sufficiently pronounced to cause beri-beri. Muscle meats and fish also contain very little of this protective substance.
 
Continue to: