This view is reflected in the publications of Johns and his co-workers (50), who have emphasized the importance of discovering among the vegetable foods sources of proteins rich in the basic amino-acids, arginin, histidin, and lysin, and especially the latter. The logic of such a view is apparent, and is amply justified by the known peculiarities of the cereal proteins which form so important a source of protein in the nutrition of man and animal. These peculiarities have been brought to light by the studies of Osborne and Mendel, who have shown that the cereal proteins are especially deficient in this group of protein-building units.

The view that any generalization regarding the cause of the low biological value of the proteins of any series of natural foods is possible, is, however, without foundation. While lysin is the limiting factor in some proteins it appears not to be more frequently so than certain other amino-acids. While it is logical on theoretical grounds to combine a food which is known from the results of chemical studies to be low in lysin, or any other essential amino-acid with another food especially rich in such compound, it is not safe to place much confidence in the results of chemical analysis in this special field of inquiry. This is well illustrated by the deductions regarding the special importance of lysin in foods. McCollum, Simmonds and Pitz (51) have shown that, poor as are the proteins of the maize kernel in lysin, this is not the essential amino-acid which is present in smallest amount in proportion to the amount required for the formation of new tissues during growth. It is not the limiting factor in determining the value of the maize kernel proteins. It would not be out of place to describe the procedure which established these facts. A food mixture consisted of a single grain so supplemented with inorganic salts and butter fat as to be satisfactory for the promotion of growth and prolonged well-being, except that the protein was too low in amount to promote growth at the normal rate. In all cases the diets were shown to be made highly efficient for growth by the addition of a purified protein alone, when that protein was casein of milk. This is a complete protein for the nutrition of an animal. Rations of this type in which wheat, maize or oat kernel were employed, were fed to young rats, and the same rations supplemented with gelatin or zein were fed to other groups. Zein, the most abundant protein in maize, is entirely lacking in trytophane and lysin, whereas gelatin contains about 6 per cent of lysin.

Obviously, if lysin were the limiting amino-acid in each of these three grains, the addition of gelatin should enhance the value of the proteins in all cases and the nutrition of the animals should be correspondingly improved. The addition of zein, on the other hand, should not lead to improvement. The outcome of the experiments showed that zein does not supplement the proteins of the wheat or maize kernels, but does improve the proteins of the oat kernel in a fairly effective manner. Later investigations have caused McCollum and Simmonds to question these conclusions so far as the oat kernel is concerned. Lysin may possibly be the limiting factor in the oat kernel. Hogan found that the addition of lysin and tryptophane to maize did not enhance the nutritive value for growth of swine (52).

Gelatin supplements the proteins of both the wheat and oat kernel in a very efficient manner, but does not enhance the value of maize kernel proteins. Since gelatin is rich in lysin, the latter amino-acid is not the limiting factor in the proteins of the maize. The improvement of diets containing maize gluten, which Osborne and Mendel (53) observed to follow the introduction of lactalbumin or cottonseed proteins, was not as the authors believed, the result of the addition of the amino-acid lysin.

Some further deductions are possible from these data. These support the view, but do not prove it adequately, that lysin is the limiting factor in wheat kernel proteins. Since gelatin contains no tryptophan or tyrosin and but a trace of cystin, it suggests that none of these three amino-acids are the ones present in minimal amounts in wheat or oat proteins.