Chittenden's conclusions were not accepted by many students of human nutrition. A critical discussion of his experimental data and conclusions was presented by Benedict (7). He interpreted the digestion data obtained with the soldiers with whom Chittenden experimented, as indicating that the low protein intake had influenced adversely the absorption of protein from the alimentary tract. He further called attention to the fact that animals fed low protein diets do not thrive so well as on more liberal quantities. Benedict pointed out, as did Sir James Crichton-Browne, that dietary studies all over the world had shown that in civilized communities where productive power, enterprise and civilization are at their highest, man has instinctively and independently selected liberal rather than small quantities of protein (8).

It should be stated that in 1917, when there was a food shortage brought about as the result of the World War, Benedict conducted an experiment on twelve men, all students of the Y. M. C. A. College at Springfield, Mass., to see what the effects would be of rapidly reducing the body weight by about 10 per cent by a sharp reduction in the amount of food ingested. This was accomplished in four to six weeks. Thereafter the food consumption was so regulated as to maintain the weight at the new level. Each man lost approximately 150 grams of nitrogen, equivalent to about a kilogram of protein. Their metabolism was, therefore, reduced to a distinctly lower level than normal during the greater part of a school year. From the results of his observations he was led to modify his former view and to become a convert to the idea that the abstemious diet best promotes physical well-being (9).