This section is from the book "Human Vitality And Efficiency Under Prolonged Restricted Diet", by Francis G.BENEDICT, Walter R. Miles, Paul Roth, And H. Monmouth Smith. Also available from Amazon: Human Vitality and Efficiency Under Prolonged Restricted Diet.
Von Noorden's1 very interesting and suggestive discussion of underfeeding collects the literature on the subject up to the time of publication and shows the singularly deficient evidence with regard to total metabolism as measured by the respiratory exchange under conditions of chronic undernutrition. As von Noorden points out, the experiments on complete withdrawal of food are relatively numerous. These have been supplemented by observations from the Nutrition Laboratory and thus metabolism under complete fasting is fairly well pictured. To what extent the evidence obtained during complete fasting may apply to chronic undernutrition must be considered carefully in this discussion, von Noorden very properly distinguishes between complete starvation and partial undernutrition, but the heat measurements or measurements of the gaseous exchange have rarely been made on conditions other than complete starvation. He points out that Rubner's experiments2 show that there is a diminishing heat production per kilogram with a progressive loss in weight, but contends that:
"Es muss einstweilen dahingestellt bleiben, ob die bei fortschreitender Abmagerung gelegentlich eintretende Verringerung des Energieumsatzes (pro Kilo) von einer geringeren Lebhaftigkeit der Bewegungen, die mit der Schwachung des Korpers einsetzt, zusammenhangt (Rubner), oder ob das zersetzende Protoplasma, sich der bedrangten Lage anpassend, sparsamer arbeitet."1
1 von Noorden, Handbuch der Pathologic des Stoffwechsels, Berlin, 1906, 2 Aufl., 1; Metabolism and practical medicine, 2, Pathology, pp. 1-61, Chicago, 1907. 2 Rubner, Die Gesetze des Energieverbrauchs bei der Ernahrung, Leipsic, 1902, p. 296.
Although the main object of the investigation of Falta, Grote, and Staehelin2 was to study the specific dynamic effect of individual proteins and the physiological utilization of hydrolyzed protein, certain of their experiments and conclusions have a bearing upon the question of undernutrition. In one series various amounts of meat were fed to a dog weighing approximately 24 kg. The ingenious Jaquet respiration apparatus was employed, but with unfortunately small differences in carbon-dioxide increment and oxygen deficit in the expired air; the errors of gas analysis were therefore greatly magnified. Furthermore, for our purpose of studying the influence of undernutrition, the results are more or less contaminated by the inclusion of the increased metabolism due to the stimulating effect of the meat. Although the experiments are so subdivided as to give measurements in the latter part of the 24 hours, it is questionable whether, when meat was given in large amounts, the entire influence of the food had disappeared even at the end of 24 hours. Several series of experiments were made, each consisting of 3 days. On the first day there was a basal experiment when only water was given. On the second day varying amounts of horse flesh were fed; on the third day there was a second basal experiment. Three such series of experiments were made. Falta, Grote, and Staehelin argue that since during each week the dog was fasting 3 days and fed 4 days he was more or less in a condition of chronic undernutrition.
The authors compare the fasting value on the first day of the first series of experiments with the fasting value on the third day of the third series of experiments, and note that there is a distinct decrease in the heat production per square meter of body-surface per 24 hours amounting to 8 per cent, i. e., from 918.3 to 844.5 calories. They cite this decrease as evidence of the accommodation of the body to the smaller food intake, and point out that this assumption has heretofore lacked definite proof. In explaining some of the differences found in the results obtained with the various proteins - differences that were, to be sure, very small - they argue that it is possible, inasmuch as there is a reduction in the total heat production in the fasting experiments during a condition of chronic undernutrition, that there may likewise be a lessening in the intensity of the specific dynamic action under conditions of chronic undernutrition.
Two criticisms must be raised against the method of computation used by Falta, Grote, and Staehelin. In the first place they have evidently made an error in computing the body-surface of their dog at the end of the third day of the third period. The initial weight was 23.8 kg. and the final weight 22.8 kg., while they report the corresponding body-surfaces as 0.997 and 0.9916 square meters, respectively. Making corrections for this error in the body-surface, the difference in the heat production per square meter of body-surface is slightly under 7 per cent. With such a subtle factor as the influence of undernutrition upon metabolism, it is highly important that only periods of complete muscular repose be compared. Unfortunately the authors had no record of the degree of repose and in their comparisons include the activity for the whole day. The apparent minimum value for the first day of the first experiment is obtained from two periods with an average oxygen consumption of 11.15 grams per hour. That this is probably an approximate minimum value is shown by the fact that the lowest hourly values for carbon-dioxide excretion are likewise found during these periods. The respiratory quotients for the two periods average 0.72. On the third day of the third experiment we have two periods that also give low minimum values, and these again are in a sense controlled by the fact that the lowest carbon-dioxide excretion per hour appears in the same periods. For the oxygen consumption the values are 10.28 and 10.23 grams, with an average of 10.25 grams per hour; the average respiratory quotient is 0.73.
1 von Noorden, Handbuch der Pathologie dea Stoffwechsels, Berlin, 1906, 2 Aufl., 1, p. 486. 2 Falta, Grote, and Staehelin. Beitr. z. chem. Physiol, u. Path., 1907, 9, p. 333.
 
Continue to: