This section is from the book "Vital Factors Of Foods - Vitamins And Nutrition", by Carleton Ellis, Annie Louise Macleod. Also available from Amazon: Vital Factors Of Foods: Vitamins And Nutrition.
The same argument may be advanced for the generous use of fruits. These are particularly valuable for their antiscorbutic properties, but most common fruits contain a small amount of B. Bananas contain some A, but little or no B.
Common varieties of edible nuts appear to be of little value as a source of A, although walnuts are said to contain some of this factor. On the other hand, nuts in general appear to contain considerable quantities of B. Information is lacking as to their antiscorbutic value.
Suggestions by Delf (Science Progress, 15, 601, 1921) are useful to dietitians when considering foods from the vitamin standpoint. If butter, milk or animal fats are scarce the quantity of lightly-cooked green vegetables and also carrots, or raw vegetables served as salads, should be increased. Fat fish such as herring, mackerel and salmon, if available, are recommended. Cod liver oil is especially useful for children. Germinated pulses or cereals may replace fruits and vegetables when the latter are scarce. One-half pound of vegetables supplies the daily needs of a man doing full work. The juice of an orange or lemon, or a fairly large fresh tomato daily affords sufficient vitamin C for an adult.
Yeast has been highly recommended as a source of vitamin B, but in order to be efficient it must be used liberally, the amount ordinarily used in bread-making being insignificant. Hawk 2a recommends the use of flour containing 5 per cent of yeast powder for bread making, stating that the product is palatable and much more nutritious than ordinary bread, both the vitamin B and the protein of the white flour being supplemented by the yeast. Rcnshaw 2b has obtained some evidence indicating that yeast is effective in increasing the utilisation of other foods.2c Excellent results have followed the therapeutic use of yeast in disorders of the blood, and so far no deleterious effects have been observed from its consumption on a liberal scale. On the other hand, where the diet can easily be regulated at will it is a simple matter to arrange palatable combinations of the ordinary foods which will supply an abundance of vitamins of all three classes without the addition of yeast.
Evidence is not yet complete as to the amount of destruction undergone by the three vitamins on heating. Certainly there is strong probability that more or less deterioration takes place at high temperature, and consequently that larger quantities of cooked foods will be required to supply the necessary factors than of the same foods in the raw state. As the antiscorbutic is the most sensitive of the vitamins to temperature a diet made up entirely of cooked foods is likely to be deficient in this respect, a danger which is, however, easily avoided by the addition of salads and raw fruits to the menu.
2a Hawk, Smith and Bergeim, Am. J. Physiol. 56, 33, 1921.
2b Rensh&w, Am. Naturalist 45, 73, 1921.
2c White mice were fed on a basal diet with varying amounts of yeast. The diets prepared were: (a) casein 17.5%, starch 49.5%, lard 18%, butter 9%, salts 5%, yeast 1%; (b) casein 16.5%, starch 48.5%, lard 18%, butter 9%, salts 5%, yeast 3%; (c) casein 15.5%, starch 47.5%, lard 18%, butter 9%, salts 5%, yeast 5%. On diet (a) in unlimited amount the net loss of 12 mice in 13 days was 2.93 g. They were then fed diets (b) or (e) in limited amounts when the net gain was 1438 g. in 10 days.
As has been shown the destruction increases rapidly with temperatures above 100° C. Consequently baked or fried foods may be expected to be poorer in vitamins than boiled foods. On the other hand, exposure to a low temperature for a long period has been found more destructive to the antiscorbutic factor than a higher temperature for a shorter time. It is therefore desirable that foods which are relied upon to furnish the vitamin C in the diet should be cooled as rapidly as possible, if they must be cooked at all. In several cases outbreaks of scurvy in military camps which occurred in spite of a daily ration of fresh vegetables have been traced to the fact that these vegetables had been subjected to long slow cooking or stewing which entirely destroyed their antiscorbutic value. Chick and Daly ell3 have reported an outbreak of scurvy which affected 40 children out of 64, between 6 and 14 years of age, who were under treatment for tuberculosis. Fresh vegetables were supplied regularly in generous amount, but it is assumed that the long cooking to which they were subjected had destroyed the greater part of the vitamin present. They suggest4 that chopped cabbage and tomato be added to soup a short time before serving, in order to reduce the heating of these vegetables to a minimum.
Or, when fresh fruit or vegetables are difficult to obtain, turnips and carrots might be grated and the juice set aside, adding the grated vegetable to the soup to cook for as long as necessary, but pouring in the juice just before the soup is served. Cabbage and cauliflower should be steamed instead of boiled, in order to retain the vitamin which would otherwise be lost in the water.**
The Medical Research Commission 5 has pointed out in this connection that food cooked in a tireless cooker will lose much more of its antiscorbutic factor than it would if cooked in the ordinary way. This is not necessarily an argument against the use of fireless cookers, however, nor against the eating of baked or roasted foods, but points to the necessity of supplementing such food with some other source of C.
3 Chick and Dalyell, Brit. Med. J. 1920, 2, 646.
4 Chick and Dalyell, Ztsch. f. Kinderh. 26, 267, 1920.
4a Delf deplores the practice of over-cooking or "keeping hot" so frequently employed by the housewife in preparing fruits and vegetables. These should be heated only to an extent sufficient to sterilize and soften the tissues. (Science Progress 15, 601, 1921).
5 Report 38.
The stability of the vitamins may vary considerably according to the source in which they occur, and, on the other hand, different foods differ as to the amount of heat necessary to ensure their preservation. It is at present impossible therefore to make an entirely satisfactory general statement as to the vitamin content of canned and preserved foods. According to Steenbock and Boutwcll, heating under pressure for three hours does not cause any noticeable destruction of A in corn, chard, carrots, sweet potatoes or squash. McCollum asserts that there is not the slightest danger of destroying this vitamin in any vegetables or fruits by the ordinary canning process. Dclf, on the other hand, reports a serious amount of destruction of the A vitamin in cabbage after heating to 130° for two hours.
Chick and Hume have stated emphatically that all canned and sterilised foods are likely to be deficient in B, and although a few observations are not in accord with this, it is wiser not to depend on such foods for our supply of antineuritic.
It is the general concensus of opinion that the antiscorbutic factor is likely to be seriously depleted by heating for long periods or to a high temperature, and that canned goods cannot be depended upon to furnish this vitamin. Tomatoes are a marked exception to the general rule, however, canned tomatoes being still very satisfactory sources of the three vitamins.
There is very little evidence; as to the effect of drying on vitamin A, but it is probable that this factor will not be seriously injured by the drying process. B appears to be little if any affected by drying at moderate temperatures. There is considerable variation in the stability of C in different foods, and a few dried foods retain some antiscorbutic power, but it is usually considerably reduced, the deterioration increasing on storage. The majority of fruit juices are rather exceptional in this respect, retaining their potency for months if dried under suitable conditions. For the most part, then, dried foods may be expected to supply practically the same amount of B, and possibly as much A as the same foods when fresh, but are not to be relied upon for antiscorbutic. They may be used to give variety and palatability and have a certain amount of nutritive value, but they cannot take the place of fresh vegetables and fruits.
From the point of view of economy it is doubtful whether the preservation of vegetables by canning and drying is generally profitable. It is possible to obtain all the vitamins required from those vegetables which keep without deterioration throughout the winter months in their natural state, such as potatoes, turnips, carrots, parsnips, cabbage, and celery, and the winter fruits, apples, oranges, lemons, and grape fruit. By restricting ourselves to these in the winter and eating the more perishable products only in summer when they can be obtained young and fresh from the garden much fuel and labor would be saved without the sacrifice of any nutritional advantage. As already mentioned, however, tomatoes occupy an exceptional position, as they are preserved much more easily than the majority of vegetables and retain their vitamin content practically unchanged.
The probable future development of vitamin concentrates of uniform reliable quality may make possible the enrichment of our favorite foods by the addition of vitamins. Those favoring vegetable fats can have nut-butter vitaminized. Some persons dislike milk and others refuse butter. Vitamin A . could be administered through the addition of a concentrate to soups or other foods. The Jap rejects rice which is not white. If "off color" it does not satisfy his expectations. But when his ankles swell and pains are felt in the calves of the legs, due to incipient beriberi, he has learned to drop rice from the diet temporarily and to eat whole wheat. He does this most reluctantly and a means for cheaply adding vitamins to polished rice should be popular in Japan.
 
Continue to: