Howe found that deficiency in C may also cause serious defects in the teeth. Guinea pigs which have been kept on a scorbutic diet for a considerable period of time show effects which simulate pyorrhea more closely than does any other condition that has been produced in animals by experimental conditions. The teeth become elongated, irregular, and very loose; the gums become red and spongy, and extensive absorption of the alveolus occurs; the dental pulps show changes before the grosser indications appear. Other effects produced are loss of luster by the hair, and sensitive, slightly swollen, rheumatic joints. He believes that a scorbutic diet may produce the same effects in man.

Various attempts have been made to relate the vitamins A and B with phosphorus metabolism, but direct and satisfactory experimental evidence is lacking.64

The close association of A with fats in nature suggests that this vitamin might function in fat metabolism, but no direct connection could be traced by Drummond,65 who found that rats on a diet lacking A are capable of absorbing large amounts of free fatty acids and of effecting synthesis of these into neutral fats over a considerable period of time. He concludes, therefore, that this factor plays no important part in the synthesis of fatty acids into fats following absorption. The power of absorbing fatty acids and effecting fat synthesis is apparently retained after the animal has begun to show the characteristic symptoms of lack of A. Drummond 66 suggests that fat is dispensable in the diet and only useful for supplying A, a hypothesis which finds support in the experiments of Osborne and Mendel67 in which rats on a diet containing mere traces of fat if any, but supplied with an adequate amount of A, grew normally and appeared as well nourished as the control animals which received liberal quantities of A. These experiments would seem to indicate that fats in themselves are dispensable constituents of the diet, except in so far as they serve as carriers of A.

That vitamin B is concerned, directly or indirectly, in fat metabolism is indicated by the experiments of McCarrison with monkeys, already mentioned, and by those of Punk and Dubin,68 who showed that the growth of rats on a high fat diet was inhibited more completely by lack of B than was the case with those on a carbohydrate diet, and these in turn grew more slowly than a group on a protein (meat) diet. Of the two carbohydrates, sugar and starch, the latter appeared to require more vitamin for its metabolism than did the former. With pigeons on the contrary a high fat diet delayed the appearance of polyneuritis while a high percentage of carbohydrate had the greatest effect in hastening its onset. This effect of carbohydrate in increasing the antineuritic requirement has been repeatedly observed by Funk" and was confirmed by Braddon and Cooper,70 but is denied by Eikjman and Vedder.

64 Funk, J. Physiol. 44, 60, 1911; Simpson and Edie, Ann. Trop. Med. Par. 5, 313, 1911-12; Osborne and Mendel, J. Am. Med. Ass. 69, 32, 1917; Padua, Phil. J. Sci. 14, 481, 1919; JeUiffe, J. Nerr. Ment. Dis. 49, 522, 1919.

65 Drummond, Bioch. J. 13, 95, 1919.

66Drummond, Bioch. J. 13, 95, 1919.

67Osborne and Mendel, J. Biol. Chem. 45, 145, 1920.

68 Funk and Dubin, Sci. 52, 447, 1920.

Vedder71 asserts that the rapidity with which polyneuritis develops bears no relation to the amount of rice eaten but depends on the idiosyncrasy of the fowl to this deficiency. "Experiments performed to determine the relation of the antineuritic vitamin to carbohydrate metabolism by hand-feeding birds with varying amounts of carbohydrate foods are fallacious if the amounts fed are too excessive or too minute. The birds receiving too much die from overfeeding and the birds receiving too little die of starvation. Fowls fed on sterilised meat or sterilised egg will develop neuritis. When fowls are fed on equal parts of sterilised meat and rice or sterilised egg and rice, they develop neuritis more slowly than when fed on sterilised egg or meat alone. These experiments indicate that the antineuritic vitamin is not concerned in carbohydrate metabolism".

Cramer72 has observed that when the vitamins are withdrawn from the diet the peculiar glandular adipose tissue (which appears to be functionally related to the thyroid and adrenal glands) disappears, although if vitamins are supplied this is retained even under the conditions which bring about the disappearance of the ordinary adipose tissue.

Punk73 has stated that all animal organisms on a diet deficient in vitamins will in time come into a negative nitrogen balance, even though the diet is entirely adequate in regard to its amino acid content, and Degrez and Bierry 74 assert that in order to maintain nitrogen equilibrium in absence of vitamins it is necessary to reduce the protein and increase the sugar in the diet, the minimum protein, fats, and carbohydrates permissible in a diet deficient in vitamin being controlled by the chemical nature of the particular class of nutrient and the ration of the other two classes present. Drummond,75 on the other hand, reports that the only deviation from the normal nitrogen metabolism shown by rats on a diet deficient in B was the appearance of creatinuria which accompanied the wasting of the skeletal muscles. Karr76 has recently found that the nitrogen utilization in the digestive tract is unaffected by the absence of B and that the intermediar metabolism of nitrogen is apparently not materially affected by this lack.

69 Funk, Proc. Physiol. Soc. J. Physiol. 47, xxv, 1913; Ibid Z. f. physiol. Chem. 89, 378, 1914; Funk and Schonborn, J. Physiol. 48, 328, 1914; Funk, Ibid., 53, 247, 1919.

70Braddon and Cooper, J. Hyg. 14, 351, 1914.

71 Vedder, J. Hyg. 17, 1-9, 1918.

72 Cramer, Brit. J. Exp. Path. 50, 184, 1920.

73 Funk, Die Vitamine, Wiesbaden, 1913; J. Biol. Chem. 27, 173. 1916.

74 Degrez and Bierry, C. r. 170, 1209, 1920.

75 Drummond, Bioch. J. 12, 25, 1918.

76 Karr, J. Biol. Chem. 44, 277, 1920.