This section is from the book "Vital Factors Of Foods - Vitamins And Nutrition", by Carleton Ellis, Annie Louise Macleod. Also available from Amazon: Vital Factors Of Foods: Vitamins And Nutrition.
Drummond, Emmett and Alien27 had previously reported that they could find no outstanding pathological effects from deficiency of A.
It has been suggested that the so-called " war oedema " may be due to lack of vitamins; and there is evidence which seems to indicate that the vitamin A may be the factor involved,28 although Madsen 29 was inclined to regard this disturbance as a rudimentary form of beriberi.
Hess, McCann and Pappenheimer29a fed young rats a diet complete except for a lack of the fat-soluble vitamin. They invariably failed to grow and generally developed keratitis. The keratitis developed less frequently when the ration included orange juice. If this diet is continued for a period of months the animals die, either of inanition or, more often, of some intercurrent infection. The skeletons of such rats show no gross changes whatsoever. Microscopic examination of the bones of twenty-two rats on a ration of this character presented definite signs of a lack of active osteogenesis, but in no instance lesions resembling rickets. In view of these results and their conformity with previous experience in regard to infantile rickets, Hess, McCann and Pappenheimer are of the opinion that this vitamin cannot be regarded as the antirachitic vitamin, and that, if the diet is otherwise adequate, its deficiency does not bring about rickets.
27 Drummond, Bioch. J. 12, 05; Emmett and Allen, Proc. Soc. Biol. Chem. J. Biol. Chem. 41, iii, 1020.
28 McCarrison, Ind. J. Med. Res. 6, 275, 560, 1010; Bigland, Lancet, 1020, 1,243.
29 Madsen, Ugesk. f. Laeger, 80, 613, 1018.
29aHess, McCann and Pappenheimer, J. Biol. Chem. 47, 306, 1021.
Harden and Zilva30 fed monkeys on a diet free from A and low in fat, but complete in all other respects. Of three monkeys one died, showing signs of malnutrition and very emaciated; while a second lost weight and displayed symptoms of oedema 289 days after the experiment had been commenced. McCarrison has observed that oedema is invariably associated with massive enlargement of the adrenals in pigeons fed on autoclaved rice, and that fresh butter contains some substance which tends to protect against oedema, and which was not present in a coconut oil. This hypothetical substance appears to exert its protective action by maintaining the adrenaline content of the adrenals at a low level. Butter is richer in this substance when cows are fed on green fodder than when fed on dry fodder.
Kohman31 discounts the influence of vitamins in the etiology of oedema and asserts that a combination of low calories, low protein, and excessive fluid intake is sufficient of itself to produce symptoms corresponding in all respects to those of war oedema.32
The relation between lack of vitamin B and the nervous disorder known as beriberi in man and polyneuritis in the lower animals is well recognized, but it is very probable that this acute stage is much less serious on the whole than the less obvious disorders which may find their origin in the same cause. McCarrison,33 who has made a very extensive study of the results of deficiency in this factor, asserts that complete absence of vitamin B from food is of less practical importance from the point of view of the production of disease in human beings than its subminimal supply. The former leads to rapid dissolution and death, the latter to slow dissolution and disease, suggesting perhaps some explanation of the great mass of ill-defined gastro-intestinal disorders. From his observations, involving detailed post-mortem examination on some hundreds of pigeons, and from his clinical experience, McCarrison has been led to draw the following conclusions:
30 Harden and Zilva, Lancet, 1919, ii, 780.
31 Kohman, Am. J. Physiol. 51, 378, 1920.
32 Bee also Bigland, Lancet, 1920, i. 243; Menxies, 26, 350, and Mayer, J. Am. Med. Assoc 74, 931, 1920.
33 McCarrison, Ind. J. Med. Res. 6, 375, 550, 1919; 7, 167-325, 633, 1920; Brit. Med. J. 1919,1,177; II, 36; 1920,1, 249; 822; II, 236; Proc. Roy. Soc. 91B, 103, 1919-20.
" The absence of certain accessory food factors, improperly termed 'antineuritic,' from the dietary, leads not only to functional and degenerative changes in the central nervous system, but to similar changes in every organ and tissue of the body. The morbid state to which their absence gives rise is not to be interpreted as only neuritis. The observed effects are due to chronic inanition, derangement of the function of the organs of digestion and assimilation, functional disturbance of the glands of internal secretion, malnutrition of the nervous system, and hyperadrenalinemia. Certain organs undergo hypertrophy, other atrophy." 33a.
Those which atrophy, and in order of severity named, are thymus,34 testicles,35 spleen, ovary,36 pancreas, heart,37 liver, kidneys, stomach, thyroid38 and brain. The pituitary gland showed in adult birds a slight tendency to enlargement in males only.
Funk and Douglas report that a large number of the secretory cells of the pituitary gland are destroyed. The enlargement of the adrenals is a true hypertrophy in so far as it is associated with proportional increase of the adrenaline content of the gland.39 The quantity and quality of adrenaline in the hyper-trophied organ is, area for area, approximately the same as that found in the adrenals in health. The hypertrophy is equally well marked in both sexes. McCarrison found that oedema was invariably accompanied by great hypertrophy of the adrenal glands, while 85 per cent of all cases having great hypertrophy of these organs had oedema in some form. The amount of adrenaline, as determined by physiological methods, in such cases has been considerably in excess of that found in cases not presenting this symptom, and greatly in excess of that found in normal adrenals. Inanition gives rise to a similar state of adrenal hypertrophy and to a similar state of atrophy of the other organs, the brain itself possibly excepted. The oedema of inanition and of beriberi is believed to be initiated by increased production of adrenalin, acting in association with malnutrition of the tissues.
Failure of circulation and venous stasia may subsequently contribute to it, and age is an important factor determining its occurrence. This finding is held to account in a great measure for the occurrence of war oedema among prisoners of war in Germany.
33a Osborne and Mendel (Proc. Soc. Exptl. Biol. Med. 17, 46, 1919) conducted experiments on rats in whose diet fruits and fruit juices furnished the sole source of vitamin B. More than 5 g. per day of fresh apples and pears avert the characteristic decline in weight observed where vitamin-free diets devoid of this vitamin are used. Fruits are too bulky to permit the feeding of more than 10 g. per day. Ten c. c. of orange juice per day suffice to promote considerable growth. The inner peel of the orange apparently contains both kinds of water-soluble vitamin.
34 See also Emmett and Allen, Proc. Soc. Biol. Chexn. J. Biol. Ghem. 41, liii, 1920; Funk and Douglas, J. Physiol. 47, 475, 1914.
35 See also Dutcher, Proc Nat. Acad. Sci. 6, 10, 1920. See also Funk and Douglas, L c.
36 See also Funk and Douglas, 1. c.
37 See also Dutcher, Proc Nat. Acad. Sci. 6, 10, 1920.
38 See also Funk and Douglas, 1. 0.
39 See also Bmmett and Allen, 1. c.
 
Continue to: