This section is from the book "Vital Factors Of Foods - Vitamins And Nutrition", by Carleton Ellis, Annie Louise Macleod. Also available from Amazon: Vital Factors Of Foods: Vitamins And Nutrition.
Food with a low vitamin content fed to cows has a deleterious effect on the offspring and according to the observations of Hughes, Fitch and Cave,14a in some cases calves nursed on substances deficient in vitamins become blind. In one test four calves were under observation.
Two were from cows which had received a feed low in vitamin during the entire gestation period; the other two were from cows which had received normal feed. During the first week the two calves from the experimental cows received their mothers' milk. At this time one of these cows died and her calf was then given the other experimental cow's milk. The two calves from the cows receiving normal feed were fed on herd milk exclusively. All four calves wore muules so they could get no other feed. All the calves seemed to be normal for the first five weeks, at which time one of the calves receiving the experimental milk became blind. It died when it was forty-two days old, showing nervous symptoms very much like an animal with beriberi. The other experimental calf became blind when seventy-eight days old and died nineteen days later with symptoms like the first. A calf from a cow receiving normal feed was placed on the experimental milk at the time the first calf died. It did not become blind but died at the end of nineteen weeks. The two calves receiving the herd milk were still normal after a period of eight months. The vitamin content of the feed received by the experimental cows and the milk they produced has been tested by experimental animals.
The milk is much lower in its water-soluble and fat-soluble vitamin content than the herd milk, but is equal to the herd milk in its antiscorbutic vitamin content. The experiment shows that although a cow receiving a feed low in vitamins may give a fairly abundant supply of milk, it is of such poor quality that it is not an adequate food for her young.l4b.
The question of how far the results obtained from observation on one species of animal can be used in drawing conclusions as to the requirements of another species has already been considered briefly.15 Unquestionably there are certain differences between the different species in this respect. McCollum and Kennedy 16 assert that the maintenance requirement of pigeons for A is less than the growth requirement of the rat. On the other hand, Steenbock, Kent and Gross17 found that the requirements of birds for B were far greater than those of the rat.
14a Am. Food Jour., Oct., 1921.
14b Hume (Bioohem. J. 15, 163, 1021) carried out an investigation on the antiscorbutic value of full cream sweetened condensed milk. Full cream milk was heated in a vessel with continuous inflow and outflow at a temperature of 80° C. The milk remained at this temperature for about three and one-half minutes. The sugar was next added, and at this point there was access of air. The milk next passed to a vacuum condenser where it boiled at about 60° for 3 hours and was drawn off after it passed a certain viscosity test. It was then cooled in bulk, and here again it was exposed to the air. The experiments indicated that there is no loss of antiscorbutic potency in this condensed milk. The result is attributed to the fact that the milk is concentrated in vacuo.
15 Chapter 2.
16 McCollum and Kennedy, J. Biol. Chem. 24, 407, 1916-16.
17 Steenbock, Kent, and Grots, J. Biol. Chem, 36, 61, 1918.
The most striking difference between the species would seem to lie in the antiscorbutic requirement. The ease and rapidity with which scorbutic symptoms can be produced in a guinea pig by a diet deficient in C shows remarkable susceptibility to this lack. Man and monkeys appear to be almost equally dependent on this factor, while rats can be grown and maintained over long periods without any appearance of scorbutic symptoms on diets which contain too little antiscorbutic, if any, to have any effect in delaying the onset of scurvy in the guinea pig, and the requirement of the prairie dog apparently resembles that of the rat in this respect.18
Harden and Zilva and also Drummond19 have concluded that this independence of the rat is apparent rather than real, since rats supplied with orange and lemon juice in addition to a diet containing A and B were distinctly better nourished than those to which this addition had not been given. With reference to this consideration, Osborne and Mendel 20 suggest that the fruit product fed as a supply of C may have functioned merely as an additional source of B, which is present in such products, and thus promote the rate of growth by the increment of a factor other than the antiscorbutic. Improved growth in rats has been observed when the supply of vitamin from yeast was increased. Without a demonstration that more yeast, which is not regarded as an antiscorbutic, or some other source of B should fail to accomplish what is claimed for orange juice added to yeast, the conclusion of Harden, Zilva and Drummond is not convincing. The recent work of Parsons21 casts new light upon the question. The curative effects of feeding rat-livers to guinea pigs, which had developed scurvy, were investigated and this material was found rich in C. Practically no difference could be detected in the antiscorbutic content of the livers of rats which had been kept on a diet devoid of C and those which had been given orange juice to supply this factor.
Parsons states:
It seems entirely improbable that the presence of this factor in the bodies of these animals should be accidental, especially since the amounts in the bodies of the two sets of rats approximate each other so closely. A synthesis of this factor is indicated, both by these results, and by the excellent growth and reproduction obtained in rats by the feeding of rations ... in which no constituent has been shown to allay scurvy symptoms in the guinea pig. Closely allied to this hypothesis of a synthesis is the possibility that the rat can utilise some slightly different inactive forms of the antiscorbutic substance into which the active form perhaps might pass on aging, drying, or through some other condition, and from which it might be rapidly changed in such physiological processes as the sprouting of seeds. An alternative explanation is that the rat has a very definite food requirement for the antiscorbutic factor but that this is quantitatively very small in comparison with the requirement of the guinea pig and has been met in this experiment' by the content of the soy bean rations used. • . . Some constituent of this diet might presumably carry a sufficient quantity of the antiscorbutic factor for the requirement of the rat, but escape detection in the light of the much larger requirement of the guinea pig.
But if this explanation is accepted it is surprising to find such an abundance of the factor in the bodies of the rats fed on the scorbutic soy bean diet. It would be logical to assume that an extremely small requirement for a food factor would not necessitate the presence of a relatively large supply of that factor in the body of the animal. It is conceivable that the rat has acquired not only a lowered requirement but also a phenomenal capacity to store the antiscorbutic substance through a biological adaptation to a food supply which over long periods of time is very deficient in this substance.
18 McCollum and Parsons, J. Biol. Chem. 44, 603, 1920.
19 Harden and Zilva, Bioch. J. 12, 408,1918; Drummond, Ibid. 13, 77,1919.
20 Osborne and Mendel, J. Biol. Chem. 41, 554.
21 Parsons, J. Biol. Chem. 44, 587, 1920.
 
Continue to: