In 1909 Stepp13 began a series of experiments to determine whether animals are dependent on their food supply for lipoids or can furnish them by synthesis. He fed materials! extracted with ether and alcohol to mice and noted that without exception the mice succumbed in a few weeks when fed otherwise adequate food mixtures that had been thoroughly extracted. When the extracted material was replaced the food was rendered sufficient for maintenance. The lacking substance was assumed not to be inorganic since the addition of ash from the lipoid extracts failed to maintain the mice. Stepp concluded that the essential factors were not fats, since addition to the extracted food of butter, tripalmitin, tristearin, triolein, lecithin, and cholesterol in turn was without effect. The missing substance could however be extracted from skimmed milk.

In 1911 Osborne and Mendel14 published an account of an elaborate series of feeding experiments on rats, with isolated food substances, designed to compare the nutritive value of various proteins, using as a basal diet, starch, sugar, lard, agar (as roughage), and a mixture of inorganic salts. Among the many valuable points brought out in their monograph was the fact that even when this diet was supplemented by a sufficient amount of protein and consumed in amounts which fulfilled the energy requirements of the animals it nevertheless invariably failed either to induce substantial growth in young rats or to satisfy completely the maintenance requirements of older ones over long periods of time. Having observed that rats could be grown from an early age and even resuscitated after nutritive decline by a diet of milk powder mixed with lard and starch, they were led to suspect that the essential factor or factors might be found in the protein-free portion of the milk, and accordingly milk which had been freed from fat, protein, and water, was used to replace the inorganic salt mixture and part of the carbohydrate in the basal ration, with results which were surprisingly successful.

When 28.2% of this "protein-free milk" powder was incorporated in the diet not only was satisfactory growth obtained in the case of young animals, but recovery was promptly manifested in practically every case of nutritive decline due to unsatisfactory food.

10 Ztschr. f. physiol. Ch. 1891, 1, 15, 03.

11 A more complete account of the early nutrition experiments is given by McCollum, Am. J. Physiol. 25, 120.

12 Alleg. Med. Cent. Zeit. 1003, No. 1,1008, No. 0.

13 Bioch. Ztschr. 1000, 22, 45a; Ztschr. f. Biol. 1012, 57, 135, 1012-13, 59, 366.

14Carnegie Pub. 156, Pis. 1 A 2.

Fig. 2. - The picture (A) shows a rat which hod been fed for one month on a diet deficient in water-soluble vitamin. At this time the animal was so weak it was scarcely able to stand and would have died in a few hours if some source of this vitamin had not been furnished. After the picture was taken a small daily dose of yeast which is rich in the water-soluble vitamin was given to the rat, the food remaining otherwise exactly as before. Twelve days later the picture (B) was taken. The result is apparent.

Courtesy of the Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station (Bulletin 215).

Somewhat similar results were obtained by Hopkins in continuance of his earlier work and published by him in 1912.15 Using an artificial diet similar to that of Osborne and Mendel, consisting of casein, fat, starch, sugar, and inorganic salts, which were prepared by mixing equal parts of the ash of oats and dog biscuits, Hopkins added milk itself, but this was given in such small quantity that the total solids contained in it amounted to no more than from one to three or four per cent of the whole food eaten. This small addition induced normal growth upon dietaries which without it were incapable even of maintenance. In those experiments in which the basal diet contained fully purified material the rats without milk soon failed to grow. When the constituents were less completely purified, as when the protein was a commercial preparation of casein, slow growth occurred. In all cases the addition of small amounts of milk induced normal and continued growth. A similar, but less pronounced effect was obtained with the protein-free and salt-free extracts of milk solids and of yeast.

The total energy consumption of the animals under comparison was carefully determined, and it could be shown that the rats upon the purer dietary ceased to grow at a time when their intake was more than sufficient quantitatively to maintain normal growth. If growth continued (as upon the less pure basal dietary) it could be shown that the small milk addendum reduced the food consumption necessary for given weight increment to one half or less. The milk ration was fed separately and in advance of the administration of the main dietary. It could not therefore affect the palatability of the food or diminish its monotony. In general, moreover, it was found that cessation of growth upon the pure dietary took place before any failure in appetite, although the consumption might later fall to a lower level. Any effect of the addendum upon the appetite must therefore have been secondary to a more direct effect upon growth processes.

In a later publication Osborne and Mendel16 confirm their earlier results, but are still in doubt as to the cause. "Whether the deficiency of the purely artificial diet is to be attributed to improper proportions of its constituents, to improper combination of these constituents, or to the lack of some essential element, is at present difficult to define".

15 Hopkins, J. Physiol. 1912, 44, 425.

16 J. Biol. Chem. 13, 233, 1912-13.

They claimed however that preliminary sman found that poultry a considerable degree of success in nutrition which the symptoms hypothetical "hormone" which was assumed to and finally milk. Rats were said to have been maintained in good be effected long as 400 days on a diet composed of a purified protein was sucrose, and a salt mixture of inorganic salts in the proportion which they are found in milk.