Loewy, 1888

In a series of experiments made by Loewy1 in Zuntz's laboratory and primarily designed to study the influence of unoxi-dizable material (Glauber salts) in the intestinal tract, two experiments were made with water. In one it was found that 11 minutes after the subject had taken 100 grams of water the oxygen consumption increased from 218.5 c.c. to 221.8 c.c. per minute, an immaterial increase. Later (33 minutes after drinking the water) the oxygen consumption had increased to 232.2 c.c. - i. e., an increment of 14 c.c. of oxygen, or approximately 6 per cent. In another experiment, 10 minutes after taking 100 grams of water, the oxygen consumption increased from a basal value of 221 c.c. per minute to 226 c.c. per minute, an increment of only 5 c.c. of oxygen. Approximately half an hour later the oxygen consumption had increased to 242 c.c. per minute. Since no graphic record of the activity accompanied these experiments - an omission which has been criticized2 - it is difficult to state with certainty whether or not the ingestion of water actually produced a measurable increase in the metabolism.

Marcet, 1889

Marcet3 reported the results of a series of experiments with two subjects, which were designed primarily for a study of the influence of food. The general conclusions confirm the results of previous observations on the influence of food upon the carbon-dioxide production, namely, that the maximum amount occurs between 2 and 3 hours after the meal and the minimum amount just before breakfast.

Marcet, 1891

Later, Marcet4 published the results of a series of experiments on himself and his assistant, Russell, in which 6 experiments were made on each subject, about 2 hours after food, and 6 experiments during "fast," i. e., 4 hours after breakfast. Each experiment lasted 7 to 8 minutes. The subject, reclining in a steamer chair, inhaled through the nose and exhaled through the mouth, sometimes closing the nostrils with the fingers when necessary. The expired air was collected in a bell-jar suspended over salt water. The carbon dioxide was determined by titrating according to the method of Petten-kofer; the oxygen was determined by explosion with hydrogen. With himself, Marcet found that the oxygen consumed during digestion was 21.37 grams per hour as compared with 20.26 grams during fasting. The carbon-dioxide excretion also showed the influence of food. With his assistant, even a greater increment in the oxygen consumption per hour and per kilogram per hour was noted after food than with Marcet.

1Loewy, Arch. f. d. ges. Physiol., 1888, 43, p. 515.

2Benedict and Emmes, Am. Journ. Physiol., 1912, 30, p. 197.

3Marcet, Proc. Roy. Soc, 1889, 46, p. 340; also, Phil. Trans., 1890, 181, ser. B, p. 1.

4Ibid., 1891-92, 50, p. 58.

Marcet, 1892

Another set of experiments was made by Marcet1 with a slightly modified apparatus which permitted the direct determination of the amount of the inspired air. One of the subjects was Marcet himself, 64 years of age, and the other Smith, aged 23 years. With Smith 6 fasting experiments 5 hours after breakfast and 14 food experiments were made with environmental temperatures ranging from 12.9° to 22.2° C. The average values obtained for a period of 8 to 9 minutes were as follows: With food the oxygen consumed was 280 c.c. and the carbon dioxide produced 229 c.c.; during the fast the oxygen consumed was 250 c.c. and the carbon dioxide produced 216 c.c. Comparing the values obtained on himself and Russell in 1891 with these values obtained on himself and Smith, Marcet draws the following conclusions:

"The influence of food on the interchange of respiratory gases, although being attended with a rise in the oxygen consumed and carbonic acid expired, apparently varies with reference to the oxygen absorbed. Young and strong persons, requiring a full allowance of food, appear to absorb more oxygen while under the influence of a meal than while fasting, but late in life the oxygen absorbed appears to show little or no tendency to increase after a meal."2

In 1895 Marcet maintained in a Croonian lecture that the "period of the maximum consumption of oxygen is, undoubtedly, within the first hour after a midday meal."3 He concludes that with young men there is distinctly more oxygen absorbed 2 hours after a full meal than during a fast. In this discussion he used the results obtained in his experiments in 1891 and 1892.

Hanriot And Richet, 1891

In an extended series of observations on a single subject, Hanriot and Richet,4 employing essentially the same apparatus as in their earlier researches, studied the influence of food and fasting upon a subject 48 years old who weighed about 50 kilograms. Two and three determinations per day were made for about 3 1/2 months. The average value for the carbon-dioxide excretion per kilogram and per hour in 36 fasting experiments was 0.492 gram; in 86 experiments with food the average carbon-dioxide excretion increased to 0.569 gram. The authors conclude that after a mixed diet or a diet composed of carbohydrates a greater excretion of carbon dioxide with a more active ventilation begins about an hour after the ingestion of food and reaches its maximum from 2 1/2 to 3 1/2 hours afterwards.

1Marcet, Proc. Roy. Soc., 1892-93. 52, p. 213.

2Ibid., p. 224.

3Marcet, A contribution to the history of the respiration of man. Croonian Lectures delivered before the Royal College of Physicians in 1895, p. 28, 1897. 4Hanriot and Richet, Ann. de Chim. et de Phys., 1891, ser. 6, 22, p. 495.