308. Effect Of Adulteration

It cannot be claimed that the adulteration of milk with water renders it unsanitary or unhealthful, except that the food value may be reduced to a point that, in particular instances where milk is the chief article of diet, would cause undernourishment. Much market milk has not contained over 12.5 to 13 per cent solid matter, and when in sound condition it is considered a healthful article of food. It is absurd, therefore, to claim that the reduction of rich Jersey or Guernsey milk to as low a standard by the addition of pure water renders it unhealthful. The claim that the consumer may rightfully make is that he is defrauded when he pays for normal milk and gets a diluted article.

309. Milk Standards

In recent years the national government and some state governments have established food standards, including milk, have provided penalties for the sale of foods falling below the standards and the necessary machinery for enforcing such regulations. In the state of New York, the legal standard for cow's milk, below which it must not fall, is 11.5 per cent total solids, and 3 per cent of fat. It is provided, however, that if it can be shown that the normal milk of the cow or herd from which the milk is produced is below that standard, no penalty is attached to its sale.* This law has accomplished much good; but, on the other hand, it is quite evident that this legislation has tended to reduce a large proportion of market milk to approximately the legal standard through the keeping of cows giving a large volume of thin milk. A much more sensible plan would be to permit the vender of milk to guarantee a standard for his goods and then hold him responsible for meeting it.

310. The Removal Of A Portion Of The Milk Solids

This is done by the removal of cream. The effect of this is to decrease the proportion of solids in the milk, and to decrease the proportion of fat in the solids that remain behind. Because cream bears a much higher price than whole milk, some dealers have practiced removing the cream from the top of the cans, the partially skimmed milk being sold at the price of whole milk. The practice of par-tially creaming table milk has evidently been followed by hotels and restaurants, if we may judge by the quality of the milk that is furnished to guests to drink. In such cases, the laws intended to maintain commercial milk up to a certain standard fail to defend the actual consumer against an inferior article, and really operate to increase the gains of the dishonest purveyor. Just why the hotel keeper should be protected against fraud and then be permitted to offer illegal milk to his guest is not clear. It would seem that the law should protect the individual who actually uses the milk as food.

311. The Introduction Into Cow's Milk Of Non-Pathogenic Germ Life

Normal cow's milk as it comes from the udder is not entirely free from germ life, but the number of germs present are few. With the procedure ordinarily followed, milk almost immediately acquires bacteria, and under some circumstances continues to do so. These organisms have their source in the dust in the stable air, dirty utensils, the surface of the cow, the hands and clothes of the milker, and exposure to dirt and air in the house or during transportation. The germ life included in this class, that is, the non-pathogenic, cannot of itself produce disease. Apart from its effect on the milk, it is entirely harmless to the human subject. It is very undesirable to have milk heavily loaded with bacteria, however, especially that which must be held for some time before consumption, or is to be kept under conditions favorable for the growth of germ life, for the fermentations which these organisms cause render the milk unsound. Such milk is inferior in taste, and is unfit for feeding infants, as with the latter it induces diarrhea and cholera infantum, especially during the heated season.