This section is from the book "The Nutrition Of Man", by Russell H. Chittenden. Also available from Amazon: The Nutrition of Man.
Leaving out of consideration the extremes given, it is undoubtedly true that, within certain rather wide limits, there is an apparent tendency for people of different nutions, having a free choice of food and not restricted by expense, to consume daily approximately the same amounts of nutrients; to use what may be called liberal rather than small amounts of food; and, lastly, to consume food somewhat in proportion to the amount of work done. It is perhaps, therefore, not strange that.students of nutrition should have taken these results, obtained by the statistical method, as indicating the actual needs of the body for food, and that so-called "standard diets" and "normal diets" should have been constructed, based upon these and corresponding data. Thus, we have the widely adopted "Voit standard," composed of proteid 118 grams, carbohydrate 500 grams, and fat 56 grams, with a total fuel value of 3055 calories, as the amount of food required daily by a man of 70 kilos body-weight doing a moderate amount of work. These figures were obtained by Voit as an average of the food consumption of a large number of laboring men in Germany, and they carried additional weight because at that time Voit and others thought they had evidence that nitrogenous equilibrium could not be maintained for any length of time on smaller amounts of proteid.
The figures given in the preceding table under the head of American subjects constitute the "Atwater standards," and as already indicated, are based upon the dietetic habits of over 15,000 persons under different conditions of life and physical activity. In the words of the official Bulletin, these standards covering the quantities of food per day "are intended to show the actual food requirements of persons under different conditions of life and work." Here, however, lies an assumption which seems to meet with wide acceptance, but for which it is difficult to conceive any logical reason. The thousands of dietary studies made on peoples all over the world, affording more or lev accurate information regarding the average amounts of proteid, fat, and carbohydrate consumed under varying conditions are indeed most interesting and important, as affording information regarding dietetic customs and habits; bat, the writer fails to see any reason why such data need be assumed to throw any light on the actual food requirements of the tody. In the words of another, "Food should be ingested in just the proper amount to repair the waste of the body; to furnish it with the energy it needs for work and warmth; to maintain it in vigor; and, in the case of immature animals, to provide the proper excess for normal growth, in order to be of the most advantage to the body" (Benedict).
Any habitual excess of food, over and above what is really needed to meet the actual wants of the body, is not only uneconomical, but may be distinctly disadvantageous. Voit, among others, has clearly emphasized the general principle that the smallest amount of proteid, with non-nitrogenous food added, that will suffice to keep the body in a state of continual vigor is the ideal diet. My own conception of the true food requirements of the body has been expressed in the statement that man needs of proteids, fats, and carbohydrates sufficient to establish and maintain physiological and nitrogen equilibrium; sufficient to keep up that strength of body and mind that is essential to good health, to maintain the highest degree of physical and mental activity with the smallest amount of friction and the least expenditure of energy, and to preserve and heighten, if possible, the ordinary resistance of the body to disease germs. The smallest amount of food that will accomplish these ends is, I think, the ideal diet. There must truly be enough to supply the real needs of the body, but any great surplus over and above what is actually called for may in the long run prove an undesirable addition.
With these thoughts in mind, may we not reasonably ask why it should be assumed that there is any tangible connection between the dietetic habits of a people and their true physiological needs?
Arguments predicated on custom, habit, and usage have no physiological basis that appeals strongly to the impartial observer. Man is a creature of habits; he is quick to acquire new ones when his environment affords the opportunity, and he is prone to cling to old ones when they minister to his sense of taste. The argument that because the people of a country, constituting a given class, eat a certain amount of proteid food daily, the quantity so consumed must be an indication of the amount needed to meet the requirements of the body, is as faulty as the argument that because people of a given community are in the habit of consuming a certain amount of wine each day at dinner their bodies must necessarily be in need of the stimulant, and that consequently alcohol is a true physiological requirement. A large proportion of mankind is addicted to the tobacco habit, and to many persons the after-dinner cigar is as essential to comfort as the dinner itself; but would any one think of arguing that tobacco is one of the physiological needs of the body?
It is said that dietary studies made all over the civilized world " show that a moderately liberal quantity of protein is demanded by communities occupying leading positions in the world.... It certainly seems more than a remarkable coincidence that peoples varying so widely in regard to nationality, climatic and geographical conditions, and dietetic habits, should show such agreement in respect to consumption of protein and energy." Again, we hear it said that "whatever may be true of a few individuals, with communities a generally low condition of mental and physical efficiency, thrift, and commercial success, is coincident with a low proportion of protein in the diet." The writer, however, fails to find evidence in the results afforded by dietary studies that there is any causal relationship between the amount of proteid food consumed and the mental or physical supremacy of the people of a given nation or community. Cause and effect arf liable fo become reversed in arguments of this kind. It is certainly just as plausible to assume that increase in the consumption of proteid follows in the footsteps of commercial and other forms of prosperity, as to argue that prosperity or mental and physical development are the result of an increased intake of proteid food.
 
Continue to: