This section is from the book "Treatment By Hypnotism And Suggestion Or Psycho-Therapeutics", by Charles Lloyd Tuckey. Also available from Amazon: Treatment By Hypnotism And Suggestion, Or Psycho-Therapeutics.
She assured me that Dr. F------ was not in the room, but had been called away to see a patient; this I had suggested to her in the hypnotic sleep. On being told by me to see Dr. F------, she immediately looked at him, and expressed surprise at his sudden return. But in most cases the blotting out is complete, and the subject may even be pinched or pricked by the person designated as invisible without feeling anything, and the invisibility may be extended to any article which he (the subject) takes in his hand. The induction by suggestion alone of pseudo-paralysis in a limb is a curious phenomenon. I can say to E. F------, whom I have frequently put into a state of advanced somnambulism, ' You cannot move that arm or that leg,' and so evoke the idea of powerlessness, that for a few minutes the limb remains motionless; then, with a sensation as of ' pins and needles,' power comes back to it, and she can move it freely. Max Dessoir describes how he influenced a postman whom he could not hypnotize in any usual way. He told him to make the movements required in stamping letters, and, when he had done this for some minutes, cried in an authoritative tone, ' Now you cannot stop doing that !' The idea was fixed in the man's mind, and, in fact, he could not leave off.
During his performance of an act that with him had become automatic, the higher centres, being inactive, were easily inhibited, and the hypnotic condition was then induced by suggestion. One may call this hypnotism by surprise, and it corresponds to Preyer's cataplexy. I had once a somewhat similar experience: A lady came with a patient, her sister, and expressed great regret that neither I nor anyone else could hypnotize her, as she had often been tried with a view to cure her neuralgia. She sat down near me, and while hypnotizing the sister, who was an old patient and easily sent into the third stage (Liebeault) by passes, I kept my eye on her. I noticed that she was juite absorbed in watching the operation, so at the moment I finished hypnotizing the patient I put out my hand, and, placing it over the sister's eyes, told her authoritatively that she was also hypnotized. The effect was immediate and striking, for after twenty minutes' rest I awoke her, and she found her neuralgia gone. The auto-suggestion of insusceptibility being removed, I had no difficulty in hypnotizing her on subsequent occasions.
Thus an indirect method succeeded where I believe any number of direct attempts would have failed, for, as Forel says, the idea of insusceptibility, especially if strengthened by failures, is the most potent bar to success. I have frequently seen Dr. Arthur hypnotize his patients by telling them to listen to his watch ticking, and the sound will send them to sleep. I sometimes use this method in persons whose sight is weak or defective. At Nancy, Bernheim has almost given up fixation of the eyes, and relies upon verbal suggestion alone. The patient, lying with closed eyes, hears the doctor's somniferous suggestions, and generally falls very quickly into the hypnotic sleep.
The case af Mrs. M------, a hospital nurse, is typical and interesting. She was first hypnotized by me in October. 1888, and since then I have hypnotized her frequently - perhaps two hundred times - generally to demonstrate various phenomena to medical friends. She is a person of little education, but has good natural ability, and is a clever nurse. I find her a somnambulist of an advanced type, with no memory on waking of what has occurred during the hypnotic sleep. As she was a good and willing subject, I used to get her to obey my suggestions post-hypnotically; but on one occasion she took offence at some remark of a bystander, and told me she would never again do anything of the kind. Henceforth her reply was always No when I asked her to do anything on waking, and such suggestions were never carried out. After some months, however, I persuaded her to withdraw her opposition, and she now again goes through the little tests which I propose. I find, as Binet and Fere have observed in some of their cases, that this subject is quite unconscious of obeying any initiative except her own, and invariably finds some reason for her conduct.
For instance, she is told to move a lamp from one table to another, and if asked why she has done so, she replies that she thought it would look better in another place, or give some such plausible excuse. No one could be more surprised than she is when told that she has simply obeyed an order. And as in dreams no commands given seem ridiculous, and hardly any are deemed impossible to fulfil, so it is with such 'advanced' hypnotic subjects.
Nevertheless, Mrs. M------'s resistance to suggestion seems to show that some personal control is maintained, and her intelligent replies to questions demanding calculation and reasoning, such as, ' What is the best route to the city? How much time is required to get there?' imply some working of the higher faculties.
Dr. F------, a foreign physician of much experience, attempted in my presence to hypnotize this subject. Without being aware of it, she was protected by my having frequently told her, while she was in the hypnotic state, that she must allow no one except myself to send her to sleep. Dr. F------'s attempt to do so made her uncomfortable, but not at all sleepy, until I told her that she was to be influenced by him. My embargo thus removed, a few minutes sufficed to induce her usual state of profound somnambulism, in which she was anaesthetic and insensible to her surroundings. I now spoke to her, and she gave no reply, until Dr. F------told her to do so, when she immediately answered my questions (vide note, p. 130).
There is another curious phenomenon obtainable with the above-mentioned subject, as well as with many other somnambulists - a compulsory automatic action brought about and maintained by suggestion without hypnotism. *
Thus, I set Mrs. M------to perform the action of 'twiddling her thumbs,' and tell her that she is unable to discontinue it. Though she laughs and protests, and is apparently in full possession of her faculties, she cannot leave off the movement until I give her permission to do so.
 
Continue to: